Log in

View Full Version : Tiger moth loses power on t/o, augers into a tree, none hurt.


Tman
September 1st 08, 11:26 AM
http://www.courant.com/community/news/en/hc-ewinplane0901.artsep01,0,5972072.story

Anyone know -- what speed does a T/M stall at? My guess is pretty slow,
say 30 kts.

This is exactly how I envision a crash into trees "ought to" happen, if
its gotta happen, in a slow-stalling speed craft, say a single Cessna.
Just a little luck, a little help from the wind, full flaps if you got
em, and controlled flight as slow as possible into the treetops...


T

Bertie the Bunyip[_24_]
September 1st 08, 02:07 PM
Tman <x@x> wrote in :

> http://www.courant.com/community/news/en/hc-ewinplane0901.artsep01,0,59
> 72072.story
>
> Anyone know -- what speed does a T/M stall at? My guess is pretty
> slow, say 30 kts.
>

About 38 Knots.

> This is exactly how I envision a crash into trees "ought to" happen,
> if its gotta happen, in a slow-stalling speed craft, say a single
> Cessna. Just a little luck, a little help from the wind, full flaps if
> you got em, and controlled flight as slow as possible into the
> treetops...
>

ouch. Poor thing. Looks like it will live to fight another day, though.

They don't have much in the way of carb heat. Icing is very common problem
with a Gypsy.



Bertie

Zebulon
September 1st 08, 02:49 PM
"Bertie the Bunyip" > wrote in message
...
> Tman <x@x> wrote in :
>
>> http://www.courant.com/community/news/en/hc-ewinplane0901.artsep01,0,59
>> 72072.story
>>
>> Anyone know -- what speed does a T/M stall at? My guess is pretty
>> slow, say 30 kts.
>>
>
> About 38 Knots.
>
>> This is exactly how I envision a crash into trees "ought to" happen,
>> if its gotta happen, in a slow-stalling speed craft, say a single
>> Cessna. Just a little luck, a little help from the wind, full flaps if
>> you got em, and controlled flight as slow as possible into the
>> treetops...
>>
>
> ouch. Poor thing. Looks like it will live to fight another day, though.
>
> They don't have much in the way of carb heat. Icing is very common problem
> with a Gypsy.
>
>
>
> Bertie

Isn't Google nice, shame you never post the link.

Now come back and lie about it. Tell us how you already knew and never have
to use Google.

September 1st 08, 03:54 PM
On Sep 1, 7:49 am, "Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote:
> "Bertie the Bunyip" > wrote in 8.18...

>
> > They don't have much in the way of carb heat. Icing is very common problem
> > with a Gypsy.
>
> > Bertie
>
> Isn't Google nice, shame you never post the link.
>
> Now come back and lie about it. Tell us how you already knew and never have
> to use Google.

Be hard to find that on Google, I think. I owned an Auster
with Gipsy, and it quit on me when it iced up. The Auster's setup had
automatic carb heat, and I suspect the Tiger Moth uses the same thing.
The heat comes on as the power is reduced through about half throttle,
since it's linked to the throttle instead of being separate, and so if
the dewpoint is high enough carb ice is likely. Further, the heat is
marginal; it's taken from up against the side of the crankcase, which
may or may not be very warm. It doesn't come off the exhaust like most
NA aircraft. Ice at full throttle is therefore very possible.
http://www.johnjohn.co.uk/compare-tigermothflights/img/gipsy_major.jpg
You can see that big round thing in the middle of the picture? The
carb heat pickup, and linkages are visible around the heat valve,
connected to the throttle on the carb below the valve.

Dan

Zebulon
September 1st 08, 04:55 PM
> wrote in message
...
>
> Be hard to find that on Google, I think. I owned an Auster
> with Gipsy, and it quit on me when it iced up. The Auster's setup had
> automatic carb heat, and I suspect the Tiger Moth uses the same thing.
> The heat comes on as the power is reduced through about half throttle,
> since it's linked to the throttle instead of being separate, and so if
> the dewpoint is high enough carb ice is likely. Further, the heat is
> marginal; it's taken from up against the side of the crankcase, which
> may or may not be very warm. It doesn't come off the exhaust like most
> NA aircraft. Ice at full throttle is therefore very possible.
>
> http://www.johnjohn.co.uk/compare-tigermothflights/img/gipsy_major.jpg
> You can see that big round thing in the middle of the picture? The
> carb heat pickup, and linkages are visible around the heat valve,
> connected to the throttle on the carb below the valve.
>
> Dan


Carb heat had nothing to do with it, the question was stall speed.

By the way, since when did you take Bertie to raise?

Bertie the Bunyip[_25_]
September 1st 08, 05:01 PM
"Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote in :

>
> "Bertie the Bunyip" > wrote in message
> ...
>> Tman <x@x> wrote in
>> :
>>
>>> http://www.courant.com/community/news/en/hc-
ewinplane0901.artsep01,0,
>>> 59 72072.story
>>>
>>> Anyone know -- what speed does a T/M stall at? My guess is pretty
>>> slow, say 30 kts.
>>>
>>
>> About 38 Knots.
>>
>>> This is exactly how I envision a crash into trees "ought to" happen,
>>> if its gotta happen, in a slow-stalling speed craft, say a single
>>> Cessna. Just a little luck, a little help from the wind, full flaps
>>> if you got em, and controlled flight as slow as possible into the
>>> treetops...
>>>
>>
>> ouch. Poor thing. Looks like it will live to fight another day,
>> though.
>>
>> They don't have much in the way of carb heat. Icing is very common
>> problem with a Gypsy.
>>
>>
>>
>> Bertie
>
> Isn't Google nice, shame you never post the link.



Didn't have to. I've flown Tiger Moths.
>
> Now come back and lie about it. Tell us how you already knew and never
> have to use Google.
>


Bwawhahwhahwhahwh!



Bertie
>
>

Bertie the Bunyip[_25_]
September 1st 08, 05:02 PM
wrote in
:

> On Sep 1, 7:49 am, "Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote:
>> "Bertie the Bunyip" > wrote in
>> 8.18...
>
>>
>> > They don't have much in the way of carb heat. Icing is very common
>> > problem with a Gypsy.
>>
>> > Bertie
>>
>> Isn't Google nice, shame you never post the link.
>>
>> Now come back and lie about it. Tell us how you already knew and
>> never have to use Google.
>
> Be hard to find that on Google, I think. I owned an Auster
> with Gipsy, and it quit on me when it iced up. The Auster's setup had
> automatic carb heat, and I suspect the Tiger Moth uses the same thing.
> The heat comes on as the power is reduced through about half throttle,
> since it's linked to the throttle instead of being separate, and so if
> the dewpoint is high enough carb ice is likely. Further, the heat is
> marginal; it's taken from up against the side of the crankcase, which
> may or may not be very warm. It doesn't come off the exhaust like most
> NA aircraft. Ice at full throttle is therefore very possible.
> http://www.johnjohn.co.uk/compare-
tigermothflights/img/gipsy_maj
> or.jpg
> You can see that big round thing in the middle of the picture? The
> carb heat pickup, and linkages are visible around the heat valve,
> connected to the throttle on the carb below the valve.


Yeah, it never happened to me, but I was warned about it.

"Don't dawdle around at low revs"

Bertie

Bertie the Bunyip[_25_]
September 1st 08, 05:03 PM
"Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote in :

>
> > wrote in message
> ...
>>
>> Be hard to find that on Google, I think. I owned an Auster
>> with Gipsy, and it quit on me when it iced up. The Auster's setup had
>> automatic carb heat, and I suspect the Tiger Moth uses the same thing.
>> The heat comes on as the power is reduced through about half throttle,
>> since it's linked to the throttle instead of being separate, and so if
>> the dewpoint is high enough carb ice is likely. Further, the heat is
>> marginal; it's taken from up against the side of the crankcase, which
>> may or may not be very warm. It doesn't come off the exhaust like most
>> NA aircraft. Ice at full throttle is therefore very possible.
>>
>> http://www.johnjohn.co.uk/compare-tigermothflights/img/gipsy_major.jpg
>> You can see that big round thing in the middle of the picture? The
>> carb heat pickup, and linkages are visible around the heat valve,
>> connected to the throttle on the carb below the valve.
>>
>> Dan
>
>
> Carb heat had nothing to do with it, the question was stall speed.


Wow! New heights of idiocy!
>
> By the way, since when did you take Bertie to raise?



Evidentally the same time as you, whatever that means, k00kie boi.


Bertie

Zebulon
September 1st 08, 05:08 PM
"Bertie the Bunyip" > wrote in message
...
>
>
> Didn't have to. I've flown Tiger Moths.


Ya lie about everything else, why stop now.

Vaughn Simon
September 1st 08, 07:43 PM
"jeremy" > wrote in message
...
> According to the article the TM has two "layers" of wings :-)

A rare example of a reporter actually getting something basically right, in
spite of an apparent profound ignorance of aviation and its vocabulary.


--
Vaughn

.................................................. .......
Nothing personal, but if you are posting through Google Groups I may not receive
your message. Google refuses to control the flood of spam messages originating
in their system, so on any given day I may or may not have Google blocked. Try
a real NNTP server & news reader program and you will never go back. All you
need is access to an NNTP server (AKA "news server") and a news reader program.
You probably already have a news reader program in your computer (Hint: Outlook
Express). Assuming that your Usenet needs are modest, use
http://news.aioe.org/ for free and/or http://www.teranews.com/ for a one-time
$3.95 setup fee.
.................................................. ........

Will poofread for food.

Gezellig
September 1st 08, 08:56 PM
On Mon, 01 Sep 2008 06:26:50 -0400, Tman wrote:

> http://www.courant.com/community/news/en/hc-ewinplane0901.artsep01,0,5972072.story
>
> Anyone know -- what speed does a T/M stall at? My guess is pretty slow,
> say 30 kts.

Max speed: 92 kt
Cruise speed: 75 kt
Stall: 35 kt
Rate of climb: 750 fpm
Range: 200 nm

Engine
Gipsy Major 1 developing 130 hp at 2,350 rpm.

> This is exactly how I envision a crash into trees "ought to" happen, if
> its gotta happen, in a slow-stalling speed craft, say a single Cessna.
> Just a little luck, a little help from the wind, full flaps if you got
> em, and controlled flight as slow as possible into the treetops...
>
> T

Nice job, yeah.

a[_3_]
September 1st 08, 09:04 PM
On Sep 1, 6:26*am, Tman <x@x> wrote:
> http://www.courant.com/community/news/en/hc-ewinplane0901.artsep01,0,...
>
> Anyone know -- what speed does a T/M stall at? *My guess is pretty slow,
> say 30 kts.
>
> This is exactly how I envision a crash into trees "ought to" happen, if
> its gotta happen, in a slow-stalling speed craft, say a single Cessna.
> Just a little luck, a little help from the wind, full flaps if you got
> em, and controlled flight as slow as possible into the treetops...
>
> T

Augered in is for sure what had not happened. JFK Jr augered in. This
pilot looks to have impacted at minimum airspeed, good on him!

Bertie the Bunyip[_25_]
September 1st 08, 09:53 PM
"Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote in :

>
> "Bertie the Bunyip" > wrote in message
> ...
>>
>>
>> Didn't have to. I've flown Tiger Moths.
>
>
> Ya lie about everything else, why stop now.
>
>
>

Really?


Name one, k00kie boi.





Bertie

george
September 1st 08, 10:17 PM
On Sep 2, 8:53*am, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:

> Really?
>
> Name one, k00kie boi.
>
Seems to have been engine failure on takeoff.
We used to use DH82s in the topdressing industry.
Todays wreck at the end of the airstrip was back flying the next day
thanks to very good engineers and the toughness of the aeroplane

Bertie the Bunyip[_25_]
September 1st 08, 11:45 PM
george > wrote in news:17ac164a-6cb2-4ffc-ae83-
:

> On Sep 2, 8:53*am, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
>
>> Really?
>>
>> Name one, k00kie boi.
>>
> Seems to have been engine failure on takeoff.
> We used to use DH82s in the topdressing industry.
> Todays wreck at the end of the airstrip was back flying the next day
> thanks to very good engineers and the toughness of the aeroplane
>
>

Hard to beat a steel tube fuse and wood wings for strenght!

bertie

george
September 2nd 08, 12:48 AM
On Sep 2, 10:45*am, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
> george > wrote in news:17ac164a-6cb2-4ffc-ae83-
> :
>
> > On Sep 2, 8:53*am, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
>
> >> Really?
>
> >> Name one, k00kie boi.
>
> > Seems to have been engine failure on takeoff.
> > We used to use DH82s in the topdressing industry.
> > Todays wreck at the end of the airstrip was back flying the next day
> > thanks to very good engineers and the toughness of the aeroplane
>
> Hard to beat a steel tube fuse and wood wings for strenght!

Hey Bertie.
Keep up with the details and your little playmate from several
messages back might have to admit that you know something of the
DH82 ..
:-)

Bertie the Bunyip[_25_]
September 2nd 08, 01:06 AM
george > wrote in news:e4aaa3ee-4fc4-48de-b34f-
:

> On Sep 2, 10:45*am, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
>> george > wrote in news:17ac164a-6cb2-4ffc-ae83-
>> :
>>
>> > On Sep 2, 8:53*am, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
>>
>> >> Really?
>>
>> >> Name one, k00kie boi.
>>
>> > Seems to have been engine failure on takeoff.
>> > We used to use DH82s in the topdressing industry.
>> > Todays wreck at the end of the airstrip was back flying the next day
>> > thanks to very good engineers and the toughness of the aeroplane
>>
>> Hard to beat a steel tube fuse and wood wings for strenght!
>
> Hey Bertie.
> Keep up with the details and your little playmate from several
> messages back might have to admit that you know something of the


Wouldn't matter if I was Geoffrey DeHavilland. He wouldn't admit it.

He seems to think he's doing me some damage, or something. It is fun
watching him try, though.

I haven't got a lot of Tiggy time. I would really like to try some of the
other Moths, though. I always thought the Hornet Moth was a beautiful
airplane, for instance. And the Gypsy Moth is th epretiest of the lot in my
book. Maybe someday..

Bertie

george
September 2nd 08, 05:45 AM
On Sep 2, 12:06*pm, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:

> I haven't got a lot of Tiggy time. I would really like to try some of the
> other Moths, though. I always thought the Hornet Moth was a beautiful
> airplane, for instance. And the Gypsy Moth is th epretiest of the lot in my
> book. Maybe someday..
>
I've got (as I mentioned elsewhere) a couple of hours but I much
prefer the enclosed cockpit with the knob marked Cabin Heat. :-)

Bertie the Bunyip[_25_]
September 2nd 08, 06:23 AM
george > wrote in
:

> On Sep 2, 12:06*pm, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
>
>> I haven't got a lot of Tiggy time. I would really like to try some of
>> the other Moths, though. I always thought the Hornet Moth was a
>> beautiful airplane, for instance. And the Gypsy Moth is th epretiest
>> of the lot in
> my
>> book. Maybe someday..
>>
> I've got (as I mentioned elsewhere) a couple of hours but I much
> prefer the enclosed cockpit with the knob marked Cabin Heat. :-)
>

Not me! Biplanes biplanes biplanes...



Bertie

Zebulon
September 2nd 08, 01:34 PM
"Bertie the Bunyip" > wrote in message
...
> george > wrote in
> :
>
>> On Sep 2, 12:06 pm, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
>>
>>> I haven't got a lot of Tiggy time. I would really like to try some of
>>> the other Moths, though. I always thought the Hornet Moth was a
>>> beautiful airplane, for instance. And the Gypsy Moth is th epretiest
>>> of the lot in
>> my
>>> book. Maybe someday..
>>>
>> I've got (as I mentioned elsewhere) a couple of hours but I much
>> prefer the enclosed cockpit with the knob marked Cabin Heat. :-)
>>
>
> Not me! Biplanes biplanes biplanes...
>
>
>
> Bertie

Talks cheap for an anonymous wanna be.

Ref Mx.

Bertie the Bunyip[_25_]
September 2nd 08, 01:46 PM
"Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote in :

>
> "Bertie the Bunyip" > wrote in message
> ...
>> george > wrote in
>> news:0a9a5143-fbf4-4694-b22b-ad1b6c94e18f@
25g2000prz.googlegroups.com:
>>
>>> On Sep 2, 12:06 pm, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
>>>
>>>> I haven't got a lot of Tiggy time. I would really like to try some
of
>>>> the other Moths, though. I always thought the Hornet Moth was a
>>>> beautiful airplane, for instance. And the Gypsy Moth is th
epretiest
>>>> of the lot in
>>> my
>>>> book. Maybe someday..
>>>>
>>> I've got (as I mentioned elsewhere) a couple of hours but I much
>>> prefer the enclosed cockpit with the knob marked Cabin Heat. :-)
>>>
>>
>> Not me! Biplanes biplanes biplanes...
>>
>>
>>
>> Bertie
>
> Talks cheap for an anonymous wanna be.





Yes, it is,



Bertie

george
September 3rd 08, 12:20 AM
On Sep 3, 12:34*am, "Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote:

> Talks cheap for an anonymous wanna be.

And so you persist

Lonnie[_3_]
September 3rd 08, 12:31 AM
"george" > wrote in message
...
On Sep 3, 12:34 am, "Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote:

>> Talks cheap for an anonymous wanna be.

>And so you persist

I don't claim to be a world class aviatior. Take it up with your hero
Gertie.

Mike[_22_]
September 3rd 08, 12:50 AM
"Lonnie" <@_#~#@.^net> wrote in message
...
>
> "george" > wrote in message
> ...
> On Sep 3, 12:34 am, "Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote:
>
>>> Talks cheap for an anonymous wanna be.
>
>>And so you persist
>
> I don't claim to be a world class aviatior. Take it up with your hero
> Gertie.

You don't claim to be an aviator period, and your complete lack of any
substantive posts prove it. You have proved yourself to be a world class
putz.

george
September 3rd 08, 01:03 AM
On Sep 3, 11:31*am, "Lonnie" <@_#~#@.^net> wrote:
> "george" > wrote in message
>
> ...
> On Sep 3, 12:34 am, "Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote:
>
> >> Talks cheap for an anonymous wanna be.
> >And so you persist
>
> I don't claim to be a world class aviatior. Take it up with your hero

You're not up on understanding remarks in context !

Bertie the Bunyip[_25_]
September 3rd 08, 10:38 AM
"Lonnie" <@_#~#@.^net> wrote in :

>
> "george" > wrote in message
> ...
> On Sep 3, 12:34 am, "Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote:
>
>>> Talks cheap for an anonymous wanna be.
>
>>And so you persist
>
> I don't claim to be a world class aviatior. Take it up with your hero
> Gertie.

Awww, you sound bitter and not just a little bit twisted.



Bertie

September 3rd 08, 02:25 PM
On Sep 3, 4:38*am, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
> "Lonnie" <@_#~#@.^net> wrote :
>
>
>
> > "george" > wrote in message
> ....
> > On Sep 3, 12:34 am, "Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote:
>
> >>> Talks cheap for an anonymous wanna be.
>
> >>And so you persist
>
> > I don't claim to be a world class aviatior. Take it up with your hero
> > Gertie.
>
> Awww, you sound bitter and not just a little bit twisted.
>
> Bertie

I would not be surprised if he were actually the alter ego and
sockpuppet of MX. Or perhaps Jay.

Bertie the Bunyip[_25_]
September 3rd 08, 04:19 PM
wrote in
:

> On Sep 3, 4:38*am, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
>> "Lonnie" <@_#~#@.^net> wrote
>> :
>>
>>
>>
>> > "george" > wrote in message
>>
>> >m..
> .
>> > On Sep 3, 12:34 am, "Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote:
>>
>> >>> Talks cheap for an anonymous wanna be.
>>
>> >>And so you persist
>>
>> > I don't claim to be a world class aviatior. Take it up with your
>> > hero Gertie.
>>
>> Awww, you sound bitter and not just a little bit twisted.
>>
>> Bertie
>
> I would not be surprised if he were actually the alter ego and
> sockpuppet of MX. Or perhaps Jay.


Jay tried it before and it bit him on the ass. Nah, Maxie is a different
k00k.


Bertie

Rich Ahrens[_2_]
September 5th 08, 06:17 AM
on 9/3/2008 6:25 AM said the following:
> On Sep 3, 4:38 am, Bertie the Bunyip > wrote:
>> "Lonnie" <@_#~#@.^net> wrote :
>>
>>
>>
>>> "george" > wrote in message
>>> ...
>>> On Sep 3, 12:34 am, "Zebulon" <@###@.^net> wrote:
>>>>> Talks cheap for an anonymous wanna be.
>>>> And so you persist
>>> I don't claim to be a world class aviatior. Take it up with your hero
>>> Gertie.
>> Awww, you sound bitter and not just a little bit twisted.
>>
>> Bertie
>
> I would not be surprised if he were actually the alter ego and
> sockpuppet of MX. Or perhaps Jay.

Nah, Maxie is a *special* resident of Oklahoma.

Google