Re: Oshkosh & Hot Beef Sandwiches

[[email protected]]

RST Engineering wrote:
> A few years ago I had a hot beef sandwich at the little mom'n'pop
> Ardy'n'Ed's drive in restaurant/carhop joint up on the northeast
corner of
> the field. Absolutely excellent.
>
> I've been trying to duplicate that recipe for lo these many years,
and can't
> seem to get it right. It is either overspiced or too bland, and I
can't
> get the combination down. Anybody got a Wisconsin hot beef sandwich
recipe
> they'd like to share?
>

Wouldn't it be more on topic if you were requesting "plans" for a
"homebuilt" sandwich?

Larry?

:-))))))))))

John Galban=====>N4BQ (PA28-180)

[John]

wrote:

>
> RST Engineering wrote:
>> A few years ago I had a hot beef sandwich at the little mom'n'pop
>> Ardy'n'Ed's drive in restaurant/carhop joint up on the northeast
> corner of
>> the field. Absolutely excellent.
>>
>> I've been trying to duplicate that recipe for lo these many years,
> and can't
>> seem to get it right. It is either overspiced or too bland, and I
> can't
>> get the combination down. Anybody got a Wisconsin hot beef sandwich
> recipe
>> they'd like to share?
>>
>
> Wouldn't it be more on topic if you were requesting "plans" for a
> "homebuilt" sandwich?
>
> Larry?
>
> :-))))))))))
>
> John Galban=====>N4BQ (PA28-180)

RV-8 it and it was good ummmmm ;-)
John

[satch]

Groan ... I think it's food poisoning.

[Juan Jimenez]

Look in the cookbook under "Local Recipes: State of Grease."

"RST Engineering" > wrote in message
...
>A few years ago I had a hot beef sandwich at the little mom'n'pop
>Ardy'n'Ed's drive in restaurant/carhop joint up on the northeast corner of
>the field. Absolutely excellent.
>
> I've been trying to duplicate that recipe for lo these many years, and
> can't seem to get it right. It is either overspiced or too bland, and I
> can't get the combination down. Anybody got a Wisconsin hot beef sandwich
> recipe they'd like to share?
>
> Jim
>

[Ron Natalie]

RST Engineering wrote:
> A few years ago I had a hot beef sandwich at the little mom'n'pop
> Ardy'n'Ed's drive in restaurant/carhop joint up on the northeast corner of
> the field. Absolutely excellent.
>
I guess you tried the obvious hack of callin Ardy&Ed's?

I'm a brat man myself.

[Jim Burns]

From a guy born and raised on a Wisconsin farm, eating his own farm raised
beef and roast beef... I'll agree with Juan... it's all about the grease :)
and the gravy.

We start with a well marbled roast and throw it in the crock pot with some
water, onions, salt, and pepper. Let it cook on low all day long. Strain
the liquid, add flour or a brown gravy mix to make a good brown gravy.
Don't let it get too thick. Add salt and pepper to taste. Shred the beef
into a large bowl, pour the gravy in, mix well. Use plenty of real butter
on the buns (remember the grease theme). You can add worstershire sauce or
hot sauce if you want, but we don't. You can also throw an au jou twist to
it and put the beef on french bread with some au jou dipping sauce. The
combination of the salty hot au jou with the greasy gravy and lots of butter
is great, you just need a LOT of napkins!

Jim

"RST Engineering" > wrote in message
...
> A few years ago I had a hot beef sandwich at the little mom'n'pop
> Ardy'n'Ed's drive in restaurant/carhop joint up on the northeast corner of
> the field. Absolutely excellent.
>
> I've been trying to duplicate that recipe for lo these many years, and
can't
> seem to get it right. It is either overspiced or too bland, and I can't
> get the combination down. Anybody got a Wisconsin hot beef sandwich
recipe
> they'd like to share?
>
> Jim
>
>

[Jay Honeck]

> We start with a well marbled roast and throw it in the crock pot with some
> water, onions, salt, and pepper. Let it cook on low all day long. Strain
> the liquid, add flour or a brown gravy mix to make a good brown gravy.
> Don't let it get too thick. Add salt and pepper to taste. Shred the beef
> into a large bowl, pour the gravy in, mix well. Use plenty of real butter
> on the buns (remember the grease theme). You can add worstershire sauce
> or
> hot sauce if you want, but we don't. You can also throw an au jou twist
> to
> it and put the beef on french bread with some au jou dipping sauce. The
> combination of the salty hot au jou with the greasy gravy and lots of
> butter
> is great, you just need a LOT of napkins!

Man, Jim, you've got my mouth watering, and now I'm pining for OSH in the
worst possible way...

My lifespan may be shorter, thanks to my Wisconsin upbringing and diet --
but I think it might be worth it.
--
Jay Honeck
Iowa City, IA
Pathfinder N56993
www.AlexisParkInn.com
"Your Aviation Destination"

[George Patterson]

Jim Burns wrote:
>
> :) OSH is only an hour or two away Jay!

The idea of wading through the snow covering the "north 40" makes that sandwich
much less appetizing to me.

George Patterson
He who would distinguish what is true from what is false must have an
adequate understanding of truth and falsehood.

[Jim Burns]

:) OSH is only an hour or two away Jay!
KOSH 151353Z VRB03KT 8SM CLR 00/M03 A2990 RMK AO2 SLP136 T00001028
Jim

"Jay Honeck" > wrote in message
news:sNnQd.542$zH6.46@attbi_s53...
> > We start with a well marbled roast and throw it in the crock pot with
some
> > water, onions, salt, and pepper. Let it cook on low all day long.
Strain
> > the liquid, add flour or a brown gravy mix to make a good brown gravy.
> > Don't let it get too thick. Add salt and pepper to taste. Shred the
beef
> > into a large bowl, pour the gravy in, mix well. Use plenty of real
butter
> > on the buns (remember the grease theme). You can add worstershire sauce
> > or
> > hot sauce if you want, but we don't. You can also throw an au jou twist
> > to
> > it and put the beef on french bread with some au jou dipping sauce. The
> > combination of the salty hot au jou with the greasy gravy and lots of
> > butter
> > is great, you just need a LOT of napkins!
>
> Man, Jim, you've got my mouth watering, and now I'm pining for OSH in the
> worst possible way...
>
> My lifespan may be shorter, thanks to my Wisconsin upbringing and diet --
> but I think it might be worth it.
> --
> Jay Honeck
> Iowa City, IA
> Pathfinder N56993
> www.AlexisParkInn.com
> "Your Aviation Destination"
>
>

[Jim Burns]

I know what you mean but actually it isn't bad. The snow was all but gone
up until yesterday, now we've got about 2 inches mixed with frozen ice and
slop. Spring is on it's way!
Jim

"George Patterson" > wrote in message
...
>
>
> Jim Burns wrote:
> >
> > :) OSH is only an hour or two away Jay!
>
> The idea of wading through the snow covering the "north 40" makes that
sandwich
> much less appetizing to me.
>
> George Patterson
> He who would distinguish what is true from what is false must have an
> adequate understanding of truth and falsehood.

[John Harlow]

“We take eighteen ounces of sizzling ground beef, and soak it in rich,
creamery butter, then we top it off with bacon, ham, and a fried egg. We
call it the Good Morning Burger.”

- Advertisement, causing Homer to drool

[Morgans]

"Jim Burns" > wrote in message
...
> From a guy born and raised on a Wisconsin farm, eating his own farm raised
> beef and roast beef... I'll agree with Juan... it's all about the grease
:)

Don't forget to add, that for maximum effect, the buns should be cooked with
real lard, too. That's how Hardies get such good buns!
--
Jim in NC

[Cy Galley]

From the Oshkosh Phone Book

Ardy and Ed's Drive In 2413 S Main Oshkosh, WI 920-303-0181
www.foodspot.com/ardyandeds


"John" > wrote in message
...
> wrote:
>
> >
> > RST Engineering wrote:
> >> A few years ago I had a hot beef sandwich at the little mom'n'pop
> >> Ardy'n'Ed's drive in restaurant/carhop joint up on the northeast
> > corner of
> >> the field. Absolutely excellent.
> >>
> >> I've been trying to duplicate that recipe for lo these many years,
> > and can't
> >> seem to get it right. It is either overspiced or too bland, and I
> > can't
> >> get the combination down. Anybody got a Wisconsin hot beef sandwich
> > recipe
> >> they'd like to share?
> >>
> >
> > Wouldn't it be more on topic if you were requesting "plans" for a
> > "homebuilt" sandwich?
> >
> > Larry?
> >
> > :-))))))))))
> >
> > John Galban=====>N4BQ (PA28-180)
>
> RV-8 it and it was good ummmmm ;-)
> John
>

[LCT Paintball]

> "We take eighteen ounces of sizzling ground beef, and soak it in rich,
> creamery butter, then we top it off with bacon, ham, and a fried egg. We
> call it the Good Morning Burger."
>
> - Advertisement, causing Homer to drool

And it's perfect for the Atkins diet. ! ;)

[Morgans]

"Cy Galley" > wrote

> From the Oshkosh Phone Book
>
> Ardy and Ed's Drive In 2413 S Main Oshkosh, WI 920-303-0181
> www.foodspot.com/ardyandeds
***************************************
Wadda ya know? Cy knows airplane repair, and his food. Not surprising,
really. <g>
--
Jim (ducking and running) in NC

[Jay Honeck]

>I know what you mean but actually it isn't bad. The snow was all but gone
> up until yesterday, now we've got about 2 inches mixed with frozen ice and
> slop. Spring is on it's way!

D'ja ever wonder how that field can be soft and muddy at this time of year,
yet is totally impervious to tie-downs in July?

:-)
--
Jay Honeck
Iowa City, IA
Pathfinder N56993
www.AlexisParkInn.com
"Your Aviation Destination"

[[email protected]]

Well, you'd better have a good morning, 'cause the afternoon's got a
heart attack scheduled with that breakfast! :)

-Malcolm Teas

[Juan Jimenez]

Geezus, I could feel my arteries hardening just from _reading_ this! Woof!

"Jim Burns" > wrote in message
...
> From a guy born and raised on a Wisconsin farm, eating his own farm raised
> beef and roast beef... I'll agree with Juan... it's all about the grease
> :)
> and the gravy.
>
> We start with a well marbled roast and throw it in the crock pot with some
> water, onions, salt, and pepper. Let it cook on low all day long. Strain
> the liquid, add flour or a brown gravy mix to make a good brown gravy.
> Don't let it get too thick. Add salt and pepper to taste. Shred the beef
> into a large bowl, pour the gravy in, mix well. Use plenty of real butter
> on the buns (remember the grease theme). You can add worstershire sauce
> or
> hot sauce if you want, but we don't. You can also throw an au jou twist
> to
> it and put the beef on french bread with some au jou dipping sauce. The
> combination of the salty hot au jou with the greasy gravy and lots of
> butter
> is great, you just need a LOT of napkins!
>
> Jim
>
> "RST Engineering" > wrote in message
> ...
>> A few years ago I had a hot beef sandwich at the little mom'n'pop
>> Ardy'n'Ed's drive in restaurant/carhop joint up on the northeast corner
>> of
>> the field. Absolutely excellent.
>>
>> I've been trying to duplicate that recipe for lo these many years, and
> can't
>> seem to get it right. It is either overspiced or too bland, and I can't
>> get the combination down. Anybody got a Wisconsin hot beef sandwich
> recipe
>> they'd like to share?
>>
>> Jim
>>
>>
>
>

[Juan Jimenez]

"Welcome to the Promised Land."
-- sign over the door of the cardiologist internship program manager's
office at every teaching hospital in Wisconsin

"John Harlow" > wrote in message
...
> "We take eighteen ounces of sizzling ground beef, and soak it in rich,
> creamery butter, then we top it off with bacon, ham, and a fried egg. We
> call it the Good Morning Burger."
>
> - Advertisement, causing Homer to drool
>

[Paul Dow]

So after all this, talk, do I hear interest in a RAH get-together at
Ardy & Ed's Drive In sometime late next July? We're gonna need proof of
the deliciousness of these sandwiches.

Cy Galley wrote:
> From the Oshkosh Phone Book
>
> Ardy and Ed's Drive In 2413 S Main Oshkosh, WI 920-303-0181
> www.foodspot.com/ardyandeds
>

[Cy Galley]

I eat OUT every night at Oshkosh. Won't tell you where as it would get
crowded, so I'd have to kill you! <GRIN>


"Morgans" > wrote in message
...
>
> "Cy Galley" > wrote
>
> > From the Oshkosh Phone Book
> >
> > Ardy and Ed's Drive In 2413 S Main Oshkosh, WI 920-303-0181
> > www.foodspot.com/ardyandeds
> ***************************************
> Wadda ya know? Cy knows airplane repair, and his food. Not surprising,
> really. <g>
> --
> Jim (ducking and running) in NC
>
>

[Morgans]

"Cy Galley" > wrote in message
news:4gTQd.5538$zH6.3388@attbi_s53...
> I eat OUT every night at Oshkosh. Won't tell you where as it would get
> crowded, so I'd have to kill you! <GRIN>

I ate in, last year. Under my van, for most meals as I recall! ;-(

Tell you what. One night next year, we'll go out and eat, my treat! Then
you'll have to show me at least one place!
--
Jim in NC

[Montblack]

(RST Engineering wrote:)
>A few years ago I had a hot beef sandwich at the little mom'n'pop
>Ardy'n'Ed's drive in restaurant/carhop joint up on the northeast corner of
>the field. Absolutely excellent.


West Wing had an episode where they talked about Dry Rub(??) sandwiches.
I've never had one myself. Could that be what you had? '...a hot beef
sandwich by any other name'

Speaking of good Wisconsin sandwiches, I had the best burger EVER in about
1983 outside of Menominee, Wis. The little bar was down an old dirt road
from the farm party we were attending. Guy would cook up burgers just once
or twice a week - that was it. The place was packed on Burger Night. The
secret recipe: The best parts of his freshly slaughtered cow went into the
grinder. He said he made his money on the beer :-)

Similar scene was repeated in the "Iaccoca" autobiography. Henry Ford II got
served T-bone/Porterhouse hamburgers up in the executive dining room. He
couldn't understand why no one ever made hamburgers as good as the ones he
got at work?


Montblack