Log in

View Full Version : Peter Masak killed in 15 Meter Nationals crash


Jim
May 24th 04, 02:14 AM
copied from http://www.ssa.org/contests/

15 Meter Nationals
Report for 23 May
(report by John Good)

This is a hard report to write. A huge number of people were involved
in an enormous search and rescue effort that began at 6:30pm yesterday, and
continued without interruption until well after noon today. But we were not
able to produce the result we so earnestly sought. Peter Masak crashed in a
heavily wooded area on the east side of Tussey Mountain, a few miles south
of the village of Alexandria at about 4:30 yesterday. Rescuers finally
reached him at around 10:00am today. The crash was not survivable - his
glider was destroyed and he was killed on impact.
A full description of the rescue effort would be a long and possibly
interesting tale of heroic effort, a certain amount of official obstruction
and bungling, frustration, innovation, perseverance, and finally tragedy. I
will undertake to write this story at some point because there are some
valuable lessons to be learned. But I feel I can't do it justice now. I got
just 2 hours of sleep last night - plenty of others got none at all. The
emotional drain of all this is perhaps better imagined than described.

Though I didn't know Peter well, I counted him as a friend, and my
heart is heavy today. I'll skip long encomiums and simply say that he was an
excellent example of the gentlemanly, thoughtful and uncommonly talented
person that our sport seems to attract.


I have time for just a couple of thoughts:

The effort that this sort of search requires is simply mind-boggling.
I couldn't hope to fully list the people here who gave unstintingly of their
time and effort, with no thought for personal expense, comfort or safety. I'
ll mention Brian and Cheri Milner as representative of many, many others.
Brian left around 8:00pm yesterday and worked until 3:00pm today, ferrying
search crews around in his car, coordinating communications, and doing many
other things. Cheri manned the phone back at Mifflin County Airport; she
would not consider grabbing a couple of hours sleep at the risk of leaving a
phone call unanswered.

Peter carried an ELT (emergency locator transmitter) and its signal
was invaluable. Instead of concentrating our search in the Big Valley near
the home field (where most pilots flew yesterday) we were able to find his
location (about 30 miles from home) less than an hour after he was missed,
accurate to a few miles. An Air Force satellite picked up the signals, and
this produced an impressive response from the Civil Air Patrol and local
emergency squads, little of which would have been possible if all we'd been
able to report was an overdue pilot. It's true that the ELT did not save
Peter's life. It's also true that it did save an incalculable amount of
time, effort, worry, heartache and risk to searchers. The crash was in a
rugged section of a protected watershed where hiking and hunting are
restricted. One local on the scene estimated that without the ELT it would
have been "years" until the crash was found.

By general consensus, today was not a contest day. It's unfortunate
that we lost it, as the weather looked reasonably good and those who've been
following this contest know that this has not often been the case. We now
need valid tasks on at lest three of the last four scheduled contest days -
I hope we can get them.


- John Good

CO2ID
May 24th 04, 03:43 AM
John,
I am deeply saddened to hear of the loss of such a fine man. I share the pain.

Arnie
May 24th 04, 04:55 AM
"Jim" > wrote in message
...
> copied from http://www.ssa.org/contests/
>
> 15 Meter Nationals
> Report for 23 May
> (report by John Good)
>
> This is a hard report to write. A huge number of people were
involved
> in an enormous search and rescue effort that began at 6:30pm yesterday,
and
> continued without interruption until well after noon today. But we were
not
> able to produce the result we so earnestly sought. Peter Masak crashed in
a
> heavily wooded area on the east side of Tussey Mountain, a few miles south
> of the village of Alexandria at about 4:30 yesterday. Rescuers finally
> reached him at around 10:00am today. The crash was not survivable - his
> glider was destroyed and he was killed on impact.
(............)
Terribly saddened by these news, I share the pain.

Is it possible to tell us what happened ? (Out landing, collision,
incapacitation, thunderstorm)

f.blair
May 24th 04, 05:10 AM
Even though he was one of the top pilots and even manufactured varios, when
he was in our area for a few years, he was just one of the guys. I did a
BFR one year with him and it really felt strange, me checking out Peter
Masak. He will really be lost.

Fred Blair

Jim Vincent
May 24th 04, 05:40 AM
I had the pleasure of getting to know Peter over the last five years or so.

Of all the people I know, Peter is perhaps the most humble, yet the most
accomplished. When I describe him, I think of him as a renaissance man, versed
in science, art, and technology...par with Leonardo DaVinci.

I still cannot talk of him in the past tense...that will take quite a while. I
am honored to know him. My heart goes to his immediate family, as well as to
all of us in his extended soaring family.

The loss is not only of what he achieves, but also what a lifetime of the
future will bring.

The accident brings home the fragility of life and that even gods are striken
down. But being far far lesser than a god, I know I have to stay with soaring.
It is part of my life, and I know it is part of Peter's.

Go with the gods, Peter.

Jim Vincent
CFIG
N483SZ

John H. Campbell
May 24th 04, 05:57 AM
Oh, man. Peter contributed to the Vintage, Collegiate, and Homebuilder
movements, sponsored youth, invented revolutionary soaring products and so
on, besides being a World Team pilot for Canada and USA. So many of us in
the sport are better off for having known this friendly genius.

John H. Campbell
SSA Youth Committee

Ian McPhee
May 24th 04, 12:25 PM
Thats terrible. Spoke to Peter several times on phone about various
things and he sent me things to try. He sure was one of the main guys
who introduced winglets to gliding around the world. He seemed a very
niece bloke........Ian McPhee Australia

MikeYankee
May 24th 04, 05:48 PM
What a sad loss for soaring! I first met Peter in '87 when he did his 1000 km
flight under very difficult conditions at Ridge Soaring. I was among the many
who didn't make it that day; Peter and I wrote an article in Soaring about our
experiences. I will always remember his friendly, always optimistic manner and
his willingness to share whatever he knew with anyone who asked. Let's all
fly safely in his memory.



Mike Yankee

(Address is munged to thwart spammers.
To reply, delete everything after "com".)

Janos Bauer
June 3rd 04, 05:54 AM
For those who don't know Peter, I suggest to read his report about
2003 US 15m National in Free flight 2003/6 page 6:
http://www.wgc.mb.ca/sac/freeflight/03_06.pdf
If such a great man can die in this sport...

/Janos:(

MikeYankee
June 3rd 04, 02:43 PM
My computer has crashed twice trying to download from this link.

Anyone know another source?


Mike Yankee

(Address is munged to thwart spammers.
To reply, delete everything after "com".)

BGMIFF
June 4th 04, 03:08 AM
I don't think so, my Acrobat is up to date, and I can not get the file
either!!!

Brian
"Asbjorn Hojmark" > wrote in message
city.dk...
> On 03 Jun 2004 13:43:01 GMT,
> (MikeYankee) wrote:
>
> > My computer has crashed twice trying to download from this link.
>
> Maybe you should upgrade your Acrobat Reader.
>
> > Anyone know another source?
>
> Try www.hojmark.org/x/Freeflight-03-06-pp6-9.html
>
> HTH,
> -A
> --
> The Usenet Sect -- Resistance is futile. You will assimilate ň-|

tango4
June 4th 04, 06:18 AM
The newsletter appears to be on a very slow server and takes quite a while
to download. Try leaving your PC to stew over the link for a while, it
eventually gets it sorted.

Ian


"BGMIFF" > wrote in message
...
> I don't think so, my Acrobat is up to date, and I can not get the file
> either!!!
>
> Brian
> "Asbjorn Hojmark" > wrote in message
> city.dk...
> > On 03 Jun 2004 13:43:01 GMT,
> > (MikeYankee) wrote:
> >
> > > My computer has crashed twice trying to download from this link.
> >
> > Maybe you should upgrade your Acrobat Reader.
> >
> > > Anyone know another source?
> >
> > Try www.hojmark.org/x/Freeflight-03-06-pp6-9.html
> >
> > HTH,
> > -A
> > --
> > The Usenet Sect -- Resistance is futile. You will assimilate ň-|
>
>

George Vranek
June 4th 04, 11:28 PM
Does somebody know why the Peter Masak crashed?

George

Bob Kuykendall
June 4th 04, 11:47 PM
Earlier, George Vranek wrote:

> Does somebody know why the Peter Masak crashed?

Tom Knauff has retraced his flight in a motorglider,
and arrived at what I believe to be a credible explanation
of the sequence of events depicted in the flight recorder
data. The final event was probably a spin, but I don't
think we can ever be certain what precipitated it.

Thanks, and best regards to all

Bob K.
http://www.hpaircraft.com/hp-24

Jim Vincent
June 5th 04, 04:01 AM
>
>Does somebody know why the Peter Masak crashed?

Below is Tom Knauff's newsletter addressing this:

I’ve had lots of emails asking for any information about Peter Masak’s
accident. Doris and I flew our Scheibe SF28A motorglider, retracing Peter’s
flight. There is nothing remarkable about the events leading up to the
accident.



He was obviously planning to fly to, and over Tussey ridge, into ridge lift and
then south to a turnpoint. If he were successful, he would have been the only
pilot to do so, and probably would have easily won the day. Only two other
pilots flew to a nearby turnpoint, (Spruce Creek) and then returned towards the
contest site.



We began retracing the flight by flying the course and altitude as he crossed
the Huntingdon valley, west bound towards Tussey Ridge. Tussey is about 1,900
MSL feet high in the direction he was heading and from a few miles away, it
would have been easily seen he would need to find some lift in order to clear
the top of the mountain.



Approaching Tussey from about 3 miles away, it would be obvious he would need
to try ridge soaring another ridge in order to gain altitude. It is hard to
explain, but Tussey Mountain doubles back on itself, then doubles back again as
it continues South.



Peter flew around the end of the 2,200 ft high mountain, and maintained 1,833
feet for several seconds before the short ridge makes a slight bend so the
moderately strong SW winds were more favorable. The glider gained altitude to
nearly 1,900 feet MSL, and he was only 2,500 feet downwind from the 1,900 ft
high Tussey Ridge.



There is a very good landing field at the base of the ridge, and I am sure he
was not concerned at all about being able to abort the attempt and land in this
or any of several other fields nearby.



As Doris and I retraced his flight, I could not help believe I would have done
the same thing in the same circumstances. The valley he was in was wide enough
that a rather shallow turn could have been made, and I am also sure Peter’s
confidence was buoyed by his slight gain of altitude.



He could not fly further into the “V” shaped valley, as the terrain was
rising in front of him. He would have tried to fly a sharp 180 degree turn to
return to the lifting air he had just passed. The flight track shows the glider
losing 350 feet of altitude in a very small space, which can only be caused by
a spin. It is a very heavily wooded area, and the glider hit a large tree.



Peter first began flying at our gliderport in 1979, and he was an accomplished
pilot. Why the glider spun probably won’t be answered. Although the glider
was called the Scimitar, it really was a Ventus after Peter replaced his own
designed wings with Ventus wings a couple years ago.



Many factors we might not consider at first could have contributed to the
accident. Weight and balance must be considered. Many pilots move the CG well
aft in an attempt for better climb performance. Peter might have lost weight,
which can also affect CG.



Peter was instrumental in designing winglets for gliders, and even tried a
sound-generated boundry layer device. I am unaware of any other modifications
he might have made on his glider.



When Doris and I were circling in the valley, a thermal gently lifted us
upward, and a Red Tailed Hawk joined our thermal. This bird probably has a nest
nearby. Could the same hawk have distracted Peter? Did he try to avoid it?



I doubt if we can know what actually happened, but I expect this accident will
cause many of us to re-evaluate the risk level we are comfortable with.

Thomas Knauff
Knauff & Grove Soaring Supplies
3523 South Eagle Valley Rd
Julian, Pa 16844
Phone (814) 355 2483
Fax (814) 355 2633

http://www.eglider.org/


Jim Vincent
CFIG
N483SZ

Google