Larry Dighera
November 1st 07, 04:32 PM
Would it have been possible for Congress to have caused this data to
be made public if NASA had been privatized and the study conducted by
the private corporation contracted to fulfill NASA's role?
>>> Top News: NASA to Release Survey
NASA WILL RELEASE "SECRET" PILOT SAFETY SURVEY
(http://www.avweb.com/eletter/archives/avflash/988-full.html#196491)
After being inundated with criticism from all sides after a NASA
official refused to release safety data to an Associated Press
reporter who requested it, NASA Administrator Michael Griffin told
a congressional panel on Wednesday that the information will be
made public after all (PDF
(http://democrats.science.house.gov/Media/File/Commdocs/hearings/2007/full/31oct/Griffin_testimony.pdf)).
"I regret any impression that NASA was or would in any way try to
put commercial interests ahead of public safety," NASA's
administrator, Michael Griffin, told the House Science Committee
(http://www.science.house.gov/publications/hearings_markups_details.aspx?NewsID=2022).
"That was not and never will be the case." The official who denied
the reporter's request had said the information might scare people
away from flying and hurt the industry. Griffin said that under
federal law, "NASA is required to protect confidential commercial
information that is voluntarily provided to the agency and would
not customarily be released to the public." But, he said, all of
the data from the safety survey that does not contain confidential
commercial information, or information that could compromise the
anonymity of individual pilots, will be released as soon as
possible.
http://www.avweb.com/eletter/archives/avflash/988-full.html#196491
http://www.science.house.gov/press/PRArticle.aspx?NewsID=2011
By this letter, we are directing NASA to halt any destruction of
records relating to the NAOMS project, whether in the possession
of the agency or its contractors, and as defined in the attached
Appendix. Destruction of documents requested as part of a
Congressional inquiry is a violation of criminal federal law. 18
U.S.C. 1505 ... .
As I am sure you know, this is not the first time this year that
we have written regarding a report that NASA was involved in the
destruction of materials. In that prior instance, your own General
Counsel destroyed video records of your appearance before the
staff of the Inspector General. The evidence of misconduct was so
clear that the Chairman and Ranking Member of the Investigations
and Oversight Subcommittee sent a bipartisan referral letter to
the Department of Justice seeking the prosecution of your General
Counsel. ...
http://www.science.house.gov/press/PRArticle.aspx?NewsID=2031
Press Releases :: October 31, 2007
Committee Members to NASA: Public Has a Right to See U.S. Air
Safety Survey Data
The survey, conducted over more than six years at a cost of more
than $11 million taxpayer dollars, was expected to be the
forward-looking tool the U.S. would use to identify emerging
aviation safety problems. Instead, NASA stopped the NAOMS project
– despite the fact that it had enjoyed unusual success in
gathering responses from pilots – and has done nothing since to
provide the flying public with the insights gained from the
survey....
“NASA has a very important responsibility to protect public safety
and to be held accountable for taxpayer funds – neither of these
obligations has been met in NASA’s handling of the aviation study.
The safety of the public has to be our first priority, especially
with more and more Americans flying every year. Although
Administrator Griffin delivered the data to the committee, I call
on him to make the entire study public as soon as possible so
airlines can take the proper precautions to protect their
passengers,” said Space and Aeronautics Subcommittee Chairman Mark
Udall (D-CO). ...
The U.S. aviation system is changing due to new information and
communications technologies that are being introduced into the
system. It anticipated that air travel demand will increase by as
much as a factor of three by 2025 – equating to 2.3 billion air
travelers. The voluntary safety reporting systems of the past may
no longer be sufficient to deal with all of the changes projected
for the nation’s air transportation system– and NAOMS was designed
to be a new, comprehensive safety measurement and analysis tool
that would help ensure that the national airspace remains safe in
the coming years. ...
Hasn't ASRS data been historically made publicly available?
http://democrats.science.house.gov/Media/File/Commdocs/hearings/2007/full/31oct/McVenes_testimony.pdf
STATEMENT OF CAPTAIN TERRY MCVENES EXECUTIVE AIR SAFETY CHAIRMAN
AIR LINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION, INTERNATIONAL BEFORE THE U.S. HOUSE
OF REPRESENTATIVES COMMITTEE ON SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
...
NASA, especially through the Aviation Safety Reporting System
(ASRS) program, has always been an important player in aviation
safety. Its human factors research, in particular, has provided
great value to our industry. The National Aviation Operational
Monitoring Service (NAOMS) survey was part of the early effort to
provide more information to help all of us improve aviation
safety. This first survey was a test of the process and
methodology. We understand that the data extracted from this
survey were summarized and those summaries were shared with the
government and industry. As in any first test, the data didn’t
correlate very well with data from other sources, possibly due to
the mix of general aviation and airline operations. The aviation
community had plans to further analyze those discrepancies and
determine if the data were reliable, but funding for NAOMS ran
out. That is when ALPA stepped in to help keep the project alive
as a part of our involvement with the Commercial Aviation Safety
Team (CAST). While we have been working with CAST to modify the
survey, we did not receive any of the collected data from NASA.
...
http://asrs.arc.nasa.gov/search/database.html
ASRS Online Database
Access to the ASRS database is now available! The ASRS Database
query search retrieves records by searching on many fields,
including location, aircraft and operation type, and anomaly.
Researchers, pilots, controllers, dispatchers, cabin crew, ASAP
managers, government agencies, and others are encouraged to access
specific data from the world's leading repository of aviation
safety information.
be made public if NASA had been privatized and the study conducted by
the private corporation contracted to fulfill NASA's role?
>>> Top News: NASA to Release Survey
NASA WILL RELEASE "SECRET" PILOT SAFETY SURVEY
(http://www.avweb.com/eletter/archives/avflash/988-full.html#196491)
After being inundated with criticism from all sides after a NASA
official refused to release safety data to an Associated Press
reporter who requested it, NASA Administrator Michael Griffin told
a congressional panel on Wednesday that the information will be
made public after all (PDF
(http://democrats.science.house.gov/Media/File/Commdocs/hearings/2007/full/31oct/Griffin_testimony.pdf)).
"I regret any impression that NASA was or would in any way try to
put commercial interests ahead of public safety," NASA's
administrator, Michael Griffin, told the House Science Committee
(http://www.science.house.gov/publications/hearings_markups_details.aspx?NewsID=2022).
"That was not and never will be the case." The official who denied
the reporter's request had said the information might scare people
away from flying and hurt the industry. Griffin said that under
federal law, "NASA is required to protect confidential commercial
information that is voluntarily provided to the agency and would
not customarily be released to the public." But, he said, all of
the data from the safety survey that does not contain confidential
commercial information, or information that could compromise the
anonymity of individual pilots, will be released as soon as
possible.
http://www.avweb.com/eletter/archives/avflash/988-full.html#196491
http://www.science.house.gov/press/PRArticle.aspx?NewsID=2011
By this letter, we are directing NASA to halt any destruction of
records relating to the NAOMS project, whether in the possession
of the agency or its contractors, and as defined in the attached
Appendix. Destruction of documents requested as part of a
Congressional inquiry is a violation of criminal federal law. 18
U.S.C. 1505 ... .
As I am sure you know, this is not the first time this year that
we have written regarding a report that NASA was involved in the
destruction of materials. In that prior instance, your own General
Counsel destroyed video records of your appearance before the
staff of the Inspector General. The evidence of misconduct was so
clear that the Chairman and Ranking Member of the Investigations
and Oversight Subcommittee sent a bipartisan referral letter to
the Department of Justice seeking the prosecution of your General
Counsel. ...
http://www.science.house.gov/press/PRArticle.aspx?NewsID=2031
Press Releases :: October 31, 2007
Committee Members to NASA: Public Has a Right to See U.S. Air
Safety Survey Data
The survey, conducted over more than six years at a cost of more
than $11 million taxpayer dollars, was expected to be the
forward-looking tool the U.S. would use to identify emerging
aviation safety problems. Instead, NASA stopped the NAOMS project
– despite the fact that it had enjoyed unusual success in
gathering responses from pilots – and has done nothing since to
provide the flying public with the insights gained from the
survey....
“NASA has a very important responsibility to protect public safety
and to be held accountable for taxpayer funds – neither of these
obligations has been met in NASA’s handling of the aviation study.
The safety of the public has to be our first priority, especially
with more and more Americans flying every year. Although
Administrator Griffin delivered the data to the committee, I call
on him to make the entire study public as soon as possible so
airlines can take the proper precautions to protect their
passengers,” said Space and Aeronautics Subcommittee Chairman Mark
Udall (D-CO). ...
The U.S. aviation system is changing due to new information and
communications technologies that are being introduced into the
system. It anticipated that air travel demand will increase by as
much as a factor of three by 2025 – equating to 2.3 billion air
travelers. The voluntary safety reporting systems of the past may
no longer be sufficient to deal with all of the changes projected
for the nation’s air transportation system– and NAOMS was designed
to be a new, comprehensive safety measurement and analysis tool
that would help ensure that the national airspace remains safe in
the coming years. ...
Hasn't ASRS data been historically made publicly available?
http://democrats.science.house.gov/Media/File/Commdocs/hearings/2007/full/31oct/McVenes_testimony.pdf
STATEMENT OF CAPTAIN TERRY MCVENES EXECUTIVE AIR SAFETY CHAIRMAN
AIR LINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION, INTERNATIONAL BEFORE THE U.S. HOUSE
OF REPRESENTATIVES COMMITTEE ON SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
...
NASA, especially through the Aviation Safety Reporting System
(ASRS) program, has always been an important player in aviation
safety. Its human factors research, in particular, has provided
great value to our industry. The National Aviation Operational
Monitoring Service (NAOMS) survey was part of the early effort to
provide more information to help all of us improve aviation
safety. This first survey was a test of the process and
methodology. We understand that the data extracted from this
survey were summarized and those summaries were shared with the
government and industry. As in any first test, the data didn’t
correlate very well with data from other sources, possibly due to
the mix of general aviation and airline operations. The aviation
community had plans to further analyze those discrepancies and
determine if the data were reliable, but funding for NAOMS ran
out. That is when ALPA stepped in to help keep the project alive
as a part of our involvement with the Commercial Aviation Safety
Team (CAST). While we have been working with CAST to modify the
survey, we did not receive any of the collected data from NASA.
...
http://asrs.arc.nasa.gov/search/database.html
ASRS Online Database
Access to the ASRS database is now available! The ASRS Database
query search retrieves records by searching on many fields,
including location, aircraft and operation type, and anomaly.
Researchers, pilots, controllers, dispatchers, cabin crew, ASAP
managers, government agencies, and others are encouraged to access
specific data from the world's leading repository of aviation
safety information.