"Newps" wrote in message
news:bKwSb.188426$xy6.966314@attbi_s02...
[...] The case was won by the defendants, the decision also
stated that a private party can tape and keep for his own personal use
stuff grabbed off the air.

If there was an actual court case in which that conclusion was reached, you
should have no trouble providing a specific citation, should you?

I'm aware of an "actual court case" that provided for time-shifting. None
that allow archiving.

Pete