(Andrew Sarangan) wrote:

A transceiver might be useful as a backup if you
fly in Class B a lot, and for IFR. But I can't think
of any other reason why a student pilot would
need a transceiver. If you are interested in
listening to ATC communications, buy a scanner.

It can be a useful backup even if you aren't flying in Class B or IFR. And why
does a person have to *need* one for it to make sense to have one?? It's
helpful to be able to observe *and* listen when you're trying to learn the
radios, and you can do that at or near most airports with a handheld. You can
check the ATIS while you're at home (if you're within range). I love my Yaesu
and often bring it with me even when I'm not flying so I can listen. And having
experienced radio failure, I like knowing it's there, just in case. I don't
know why anyone would discourage a person from getting one.