"A Guy Called Tyketto" wrote in message
. ..

Exactly what I've been saying.


Yeah, you're both wrong.



I never said you had to readback
a clearance INTO Class C, but that if a controller tells you for
whatever reason to remain OUTSIDE of Class C, that should be read back.


It SHOULD be read back? Are you sure? Previously you claimed it MUST be
read back. Which is it?