Gary,

Well, to be fair to Thomas, he's not claiming the passenger had any legal
obligation. He's just saying the passenger was an idiot.

Actually, I was just taking sides with someone who said that originally, IIRC.
But I have to say you're right: There is a chance he didn't do anything because
he couldn't yet, because of the level of his training.

And Thomas has
yet to explain how he even concluded that the passenger did *not* correctly
advise the PIC.


Again, I think that possibility is simply ruled out by the fact that the plane
penetrated the ADIZ.

--
Thomas Borchert (EDDH)