"Tim J" wrote in
. net:

So what are you saying? The approach chart is/was wrong or
the pilots made an error?

The pilots made an error. Dive and drive is dangerous. I'm in
no particular hurry to get out of the clouds - at MDA is fine.
Why would anyone be in a huge hurry to get out of the clouds?
Being in a hurry is almost always dangerous, sometimes fatal.

--
Regards,

Stan