On Sat, 10 Dec 2005 01:24:19 +0000 (UTC), (Roy Smith) wrote:

In article t,
Roy Page wrote:
I am sure I can count on this newsgroup to give this question their best !

Would it be legal for a CFI [Not CFII] to act as PIC from the right seat
with a student in IMC ?

Yes, assuming the CFI is IFR current.

In my opinion regardless of the legality, it would be less than sensible,
what say the group ?

It depends. Is the CFI comfortable flying in IMC? How skilled is the
student? For somebody getting close to being ready for their
checkride, it should be no big deal, especially in relatively benign
conditions, and would be a valuble experience for the student.

It's certainly legal, but can the student count it as "Instrument
Instruction" when adding up the number of required hours before the
checkride? I think not.

--
Jay.
(remove dashes for legal email address)