Ian Stirling wrote:

Peter Dohm wrote:
snip

The 9 cylinder 1820 and 1840 CID radials used on B-17's were geared
approximately 16:9. However, your point is well taken, and I also am unable
to name any 4 or 6 cylinder engines that have stood the test of time with
reduction drives.

I also believe that tuning any drive system, including a PSRU, is a
science--when fully understood. And therein lies the rub: There's plenty
left to learn--especially if it must also be light. So, in practice, you
are right--it is still an art. :-(


I suspect that electronics help.
Instrumenting the shaft, to measure resonances in real time is no longer
prohibitively expensive.
I suspect a belt PSRU - if properly configured could act to decouple the
prop from the engine/shaft somewhat.
Add one or more rotational vibrational dampers - fill the shaft with
oil? And trim.



Best tool available to the amateur is a variable speed strobe - Party Light!

That way you can actually look and SEE what's happening.


Richard