On Dec 11, 10:53 am, "Robert M. Gary" wrote:
On Dec 11, 6:17 am, "F. Baum" wrote:

As a
CFII I would never hire a CFI who did not understand that both the CFI
and the rated student *SHOULD* be logging PIC at the same time. If you
do not log your rated student's flights as PIC when you fly with them
you are doing them a disservice and are not understanding the rules.

This is not what is being disputed. Furthermore, the airlines frown on
this practice too. I havent filled out an app in awhile but I recall
the last ones I did fill out ask for time that I was "soley resposible
for the operation of the aircraft" . Maybe the feds could clear things
up a bit with verbage similar to this.

My guess it that you misunderstood what the local FSDO wrote. I would
suggest you post it here. If it really does say what you are saying
I'll take it to the FAA and have them reverse it.
That was a long time ago and I never had a copy of it. I doubt the FAA
would suport the logging of PIC by anyone other than the PIC.

-Robert, CFII