View Single Post
  #10  
Old January 21st 08, 11:00 PM posted to rec.aviation.piloting
Larry Dighera
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 3,953
Default Mid-air in California

On Mon, 21 Jan 2008 19:55:03 GMT, wrote in
:

Larry Dighera wrote:
On Mon, 21 Jan 2008 17:45:03 GMT,
wrote in
:


Larry Dighera wrote:
On Mon, 21 Jan 2008 08:32:09 -0800, C J Campbell
wrote in
2008012108320950073-christophercampbell@hotmailcom:

The FAA probably had nothing to do with a crash at Corona.

Wasn't it the FAA who created Class B, C, and D airspace? To the
extent that this concentrates aircraft not in contact with ATC in the
limited airspace outside of Bravo, Charlie, and Delta airspace, the
FAA can perhaps be seen as contributory. But it's a stretch.

Here's a TAC:
http://skyvector.com/#32-24-2-4488-3214

Yeah, look at it closely.

The non-ATC controlled airspace around Corona is hardly limited.



I suppose that depends on how one characterizes 'limited.'


What I see is:


Class D with a ceiling of 2,700' within a mile north


TPA at Corona is 1533 and the pattern is to the south. The only way
to get to Corona through the CNO class D is to first go through the
ONT class C, and almost nobody does that except students being shown
how to use the radio.


The floor of outer ring of the KONT Class C is 2,700', so there's no
need to transition the KONT Class C from the north though the KCNO
Class D if you stay below 2,700', but that's not at issue here.


Class Charlie with a floor of 2,700' overhead


See above. If you are under the Class C and going to or coming from
Corona, you would never be that high anyway.


If remaining in VMC required it, you might.


Another Class Charlie a few miles to the SE


The floor of the SNA class C in that area is 3500 feet. There is no
reason to go in that direction unless you are actually going to SNA.


Of course, there is the reciprocal to that statement, when you are
arriving at KAJO.

You can't go down the coast that way as you would have to go through
a restricted areas around Camp Pendleton.


All you have to do to fly down the coast is stay a mile or two off
shore, and you'll be clear of R2503 A & D.

[...]


And then there are the ~4,000' mountains ~5 miles to the southeast and
the Paradise VORTAC ~3 miles NW that tend to concentrate aircraft.


And on the other side of those hills (the mountains are to the north)
is SNA and two restricted areas. You aren't going that way unless
you are going to either SNA or Hawaii.

I can think of no reason to anywhere near Paradise VORTAC either departing
or arriving VFR at Corona.


KAJO is located 3 miles from Paradise VORTAC; you don't get a choice.

I find those as limiting the airspace available to flights not in
contact with ATC. You say 'tomato'...


I find the Pacific Ocean and the 10,000 foot mountains far more
limiting than any controlled airspace area.


Agreed. But that wasn't part of what we were discussing.


Most of the airports in the basin are towered. The only ones that are
not are CCB, AJO, L67 (going away to developers), SBD, RIR and REI.


What is your point?

Of course, this is a non-issue for IFR flights and those receiving
Radar Traffic Advisory Service from ATC.