Thanks for the clear explanation, Steve. Let me summarize: The root cause of poor handling on tow is the tow plane down wash producing either differential lift if you’re not centered on the tow plane, or tip stalling if you are. Having the tow plane go faster gets you further above the stall speed-wise, and reduces your AoA because the down wash moves up.

Since turbulence interaction is causing the problem, it implies that you could combat a slow tow plane pilot who refuses to speed up by flying below his down wash. But comments in a previous thread indicate that those who tried that maneuver still had handling problems. Any idea why?

-John, Q3

On Tuesday, November 5, 2013 6:28:54 PM UTC-5, Steve Leonard wrote:
Back to seriousness. Ever looked and the con-trials behind an airline in flight? It is very narrow right at the plane, and spreads out as the plane moves away. The wake and downwash field are moving down and spreading out. The con-trail spreads out as it is marking a limit of the wake. All the air above the actual wake and downwash field is also pulled down by the downwash field behind the wing. Some very large distance away, this downward pull of air will be negligible, but in the amount of altitude you can rise above the wake on tow without seriously upsetting your tug, the downwash will still be about the same. So, getting above the wake may solve some of the awful handling because you aren't being trounced around, but you will still be very nose high and feel very uneasy. Interesting videos show the wake actually gets narrower for some distance behind the wing, and then spreads back out. So, there probably is some effect of the wing of the sailplane extending beyond the wake of short wing towplanes.

Why does increasing the towplane speed help? Two things. First, many things aerodynamic happen with the square of the speed. 10% increase in speed gives a bit over 20% increase in stall margin. Second, when the towplanes wing doesn't have to work as hard to keep it in the air, the size and intensity of the wake and downwash field decrease. So does the downwash angle.. So, by adding speed, the downwash angle is reduced, your required angle of attack is reduced, your margins and comfort levels all go up. And by the way, the wake will actually be higher where you are at the end of the same length tow rope, as it won't be angling down as much as it comes off the wing of the towplane.

As Andreas said, long wing towplanes don't create large angular downwash fields when flying at 55 knots. Pawnees and the like do.

Also worthy of note, I believe the downwash field increases in angle but decreases in velocity as a function of horizontal distance from the wing. So, the length of rope you chose to hang yourself with might also affect slow tow speed handling. Hint: I would try longer for better handling at the same tow speed. Gets you further horizontally and vertically from the wake.

Well, that was more than just two cents worth!

Steve