I've gone through both books in great detail and have issues with both.
Generally, I think Aloni's is much better and much more reliable.
However, his kill list in the back is missing several pilots and has
incorrect info for several other pilots. I have talked directly to
three of these pilots and tend to trust their own info. Right now, I'm
trying to reconcile all this new info so I can update my web page. I
also understand that the next book in the series will be Aloni's
accounting of F-4 kills.