John Smith wrote:

Well... MX is a troll, but he is right when he concludes that the
average pilot is too poorly trained to make a safe 180 after an
engine failure. The accidents are obvious.

I'm not convinced it's a case of being too poorly trained to make the
180 safely. I'd suggest that the best trained pilots would have a good
chance of dying if they attempted a 180 after a power failure on take
off.
I'm more inclined to believe that it's a case of the a/c not being
capable of making it back, no matter what the pilot's skill level.
Having said that, a well trained pilot would not attempt the 180 in the
first place, but that's not what you were suggesting.
Crash Lander

--