View Single Post
  #8  
Old March 6th 10, 04:16 AM posted to rec.aviation.military,sci.military.naval,rec.aviation.military.naval
Ray O'Hara[_3_]
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 28
Default "Vanishing American Air Superiority"


"Paul Saccani" wrote in message
...
On Fri, 5 Mar 2010 07:59:46 -0800 (PST), Mike
wrote:

The U.S. backed into the high-low mix out of desperation. The
frontline fighter in 1943 was the Republic P-47, an excellent aircraft
with one major drawback: Its combat radius was limited to 300 miles.
That meant that it could not escort bombers to Germany and back,
leaving the 8th Air Force's B-17s and B-24s at the mercy of German
defenses. By sheer accident, a failing attack plane, the A-35, was
mated with the British Merlin engine (the same as used by the
Spitfire). The result was a magical airplane -- the P-51 Mustang, a
fighter capable of flying deep into Germany and back while at the same
time agile enough to outfly most opponents.


This is quite mistaken.

The Merlin was first fitted to five aeroplanes (with the USAAC
designation P-51) of the first batch of Mustang Mk. 1s. These aircraft
were named Mustang Mk X. They were definitely not the A36 Apache
(the A35 was a version of the A31 Vengenance).

This wasn't accidental, deficiencies above 15,000 feet with the
Allision powerplant at altitudes above 15,000 feet were identified in
early testing, and Air Chief Marshall Wilfrid Freeman authorised test
and development of a Merlin engined version in April 1942. This was
before the A36 had even been ordered.

The A36 was ordered simply because USAAC funds for fighters in Fiscal
year 1942 had already been exhausted. General Oliver Nichols and
Major Benjamin Kelsey decided to use funds allocated for Attack
Bombers and had NAA make the minimum changes needed to legally produce
a genuine attack version. But the first 150 P-51 were already ordered
before this decision, and the first 150 P-51 for USAAC were already
flying before the follow on expedient A36 was flying.

The A36 hadn't even had first flight by the time that Merlin engined
Mustang Mk Xs were already flying. And Packard Merlin engined Mustang
Mk 1As were ordered from NAA before the A36 had even been thought of.


the whole article was bull****.