Matt Giwer wrote:


The night isn't over. But everyone that dies from lack of
electricity, water, food, medicine or any other cause related to this
siege or the occupation in general has been murdered by Israel. As such
deaths are mostly among children and the elderly it is going to be a
very unpleasant accounting to Israel's already blood-drenched scorecard.

The Israels have permitted the influx of minimal shipments of fuel,
water, food and medicine. If they meant to slaughter Gaza City, they
would have done it already. Why not apply Ockahm's Razor. Maybe all the
Israelis want it the return of Lt. Shalit. Could it be possible?

As to group punishment, everytime a Jihadi straps on an explosive belt
and blows himself to Paradise in a Pizza Parlor or at a bus stop, that
is group punishment. When the Palis do it, you judge it to be just. When
Isrealis do targeted assassination of their enemies you express how
Shocked! Shocked! you are at Israeli brutality. If the Israelis were
truly as brutal and evil as you claim there would be barely a hundred
Palestineans left alive, even as we speak. You are a bull**** artist.

Bob Kolker