"Richard Hertz" wrote in message
t...

Can anyone point out why the following approaches have minor differences
(specifically the minimums and the MAP):

RUT LOC/DME 19
RUT LOC 19 (with DME)


It looks like the missed approach procedure is the culprit. The procedure
for the LOC RWY 19 uses the RUT VOR/DME while the procedure for the LOC/DME
RWY 19 does not. Apparently not using the VOR/DME for the procedure pushes
the MAP 1.5 miles further out and bumps up the MDA and minima a bit. The
LOC RWY 19 is a better approach, but would be NOTAMed NA if the RUT VOR/DME
is out of service.