Ramapriya wrote:
Don Hammer wrote:

On 1 Jan 2005 15:17:49 -0800, "george" wrotD:

Also, since TCAS has been mandated, there has been only one mid-air
with equipped aircraft and it was because one crew ignored the
warning. (UPS and Aeroflot in Switzerland)


????? You mean the TCAS only gives a warning, with the pilots having a
say on whether or not to take action?? I was under the impression that
the TCAS sytems talk to each other and take automatic action to avoid a
collision!!

To leave it to the pilots doesn't appear to be too much of an
advantage, with a relative speed of two planes being about 1000 mph
towards each other. Also, given the small reaction time, there's also a
chance, howsoever small, that the pilots could both take action that'll
precipitate a collision instead of avoiding one; both diving, for
example.

If it isn't automatic, I think the TCAS should be. For sure.

20+ years ago I knew one of the early developers of TCAS. She told me
about some of the attempts at conflict resolution. For example, they
started off with a rule that said if two planes were heading directly at
each other, "pass with the other plane on the right". Fortunately,
they did simulations: the result is the colliding planes form a
decreasing-radius spiral about each other, always with the other plane
on the right.