On Thu, 5 Apr 2007 14:18:37 -0700, "Lee McGee" wrote:

Normal people talking in a group do not repeat the entire conversation every
time they respond.

No, but they don't respond to a comment two or three days later, either.

If you've got an active topic, you don't know what specific comments the poster
is responding to. Top posting is like telling the punch line of the joke
*first*.

HOWEVER...I will agree that bottom posting relies more heavily on the poster
trimming the previous comments. If you're too lazy to trim, then by all means,
top post.

Ron Wanttaja