On Nov 6, 1:30*am, "Robert M. Gary" wrote:
On Nov 5, 1:31*pm, "Ol Shy & Bashful" wrote:

Robert
Get over yourself! Lets regale everyone about flying 20' over the
water and 200' in a J-3. What does that have to do with improving
anything here? What is your definition of a "real airplane"? You just
having a bad day?

It just seems ashame. We used to have students post problems and we
would offer them solutions. Now you're posting a solution that is
looking for a problem. I just think its a sad commentary on this group
that we have to find problems for solutions because there isn't enough
real aviation going on to stimulate discussion about actual student
problems.

-Robert, CFII

What the devil IS your problem? This is absolutely normal procedure
for ANY competent CFI. It's done all the time.
I don't know what your problem is with this poster but he is doing
nothing improper, either from the instructor, OR the forum point of
view.
Dudley Henriques