View Single Post
  #9  
Old September 30th 07, 03:01 AM posted to rec.aviation.military,rec.aviation.military.naval,sci.military.naval
Mike Kanze
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 114
Default Seaplane Resurgence?

but will they now make a comeback in the US?

Short answer: No, IMHO.

Longer answer: Attempts at large-scale revival of seaplanes in the U.S. will likely meet the same ends as attempts to revive LTA.
a.. Too few suitable seadrome possibilities near most U. S. coastal population centers. And no possibilities at all in the continental heartland, other than the Great Lakes cities like Detroit or Chicago.
b.. Constant pre-landing obstruction clearance would be a major headache for near-urban seadromes - would not take a very large piece of harbor flotsam to hole a hull at takeoff or alighting speed.
c.. Need for major infrastructure improvements (large hangars, ramps, etc.) along increasingly expensive / scarce near-urban shoreline.
d.. Even a modest sea state can hinder or prohibit operations in more open waters.
e.. Higher cost of maintenance, especially for corrosion control, versus landplanes.
This does not say that seaplanes may not be suited for other locales. The freshwater lake interior regions of Russia and Canada come to mind as possibly suitable.

Just not a winner for the U.S.

--
Mike Kanze

"The greatest threat to our democracy is not from evil or incompetent leaders, but from an electorate with the attention span of a gerbil on crack."

- James Tulip, San Francisco Chronicle (7/25/2007)

wrote in message oups.com...
In addition to the C-130 Seaplane project:

http://www.aviationweek.com/aw/blogs...d-a01eb5e659b1


It looks like other seaplane ideas are being studied as well:

http://www.aviationweek.com/aw/blogs...7-b3cdb2aeb8fd

http://cisd.dt.navy.mil/div/cisd/fil...09dec2003).pdf


Japan and the (Former) USSR never really gave up on seaplanes, but
will they now make a comeback in the US?