![]() |
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
What would you do in the following situtation:
You are approaching a non towered field, communicate right and all that stuff, your on final, suddenly a cessna pulls up and starts it's take off roll. Also lets bring the same situation to a towered airport where the controller tells you to go around while you are on final. I am asking this because I am just wondering that at some point the aircraft could collide (one climbing out, the other at pattern altitude), and what the pilot going around should do... |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Nik" wrote in message ups.com... What would you do in the following situtation: You are approaching a non towered field, communicate right and all that stuff, your on final, suddenly a cessna pulls up and starts it's take off roll. Also lets bring the same situation to a towered airport where the controller tells you to go around while you are on final. I am asking this because I am just wondering that at some point the aircraft could collide (one climbing out, the other at pattern altitude), and what the pilot going around should do... In both cases, announce your intentions, offset your approach and fly an upwind leg (typically to the right of the runway centerline). You should adjust your upwind leg to keep the rogue aircraft/pilot in view until it is no longer a collision threat. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Ok thank you...
How would you say the intentions though? -Nik |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Nik" wrote in message ups.com... Ok thank you... How would you say the intentions though? -Nik "Your Location Traffic, NXYZ is going around due to departing traffic on Runway **, will fly an upwind on the Right side of Runway **." |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Nik wrote:
Ok thank you... How would you say the intentions though? -Nik "Going around, sidestepping to the right" |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article . com,
"Nik" wrote: What would you do in the following situtation: You are approaching a non towered field, communicate right and all that stuff, your on final, suddenly a cessna pulls up and starts it's take off roll. Aviate, Navigate, Communicate. How much space is between the two of you? If he's already rolling and you're still 1/4 mile out, the safest thing might be to just land behind him. The alternative is to go around. There is no one right answer. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
The microphone is not a flight control. It's not what you say that counts,
it's what you do. "Buzzbomb 34X going around, moving to the right of the runway" would be plenty. The rationale for moving to the right is that with you in the left seat, you can watch the other plane and take evasive action if necessary. We have grass between the two parallel runways at Boeing Field in Seattle, and when the tower issues a go-around it is usually "go around, fly over the grass, maintain visual separation from the Flybird to your (right.left), report midfield downwind." Bob Gardner "Nik" wrote in message ups.com... Ok thank you... How would you say the intentions though? -Nik |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Nik wrote:
What would you do in the following situtation: You are approaching a non towered field, communicate right and all that stuff, your on final, suddenly a cessna pulls up and starts it's take off roll. I would immediately abort the approach, climb, and maneuver so I was flying parallel to the runway at a safe distance until I could get a better sense of what the other pilot is going to do. As soon as practical, get out of the pattern and re-enter it per the published procedures (standard or otherwise). At no time would I put myself in front of the other plane, since I then lose my only defense against a midair--visual contact with the other aircraft so I can maintain separation. How can I trust that this pilot, who didn't acknowledge my presence before by either waiting or making radio calls, will see me? Answer: I don't trust that pilot, or any other when it comes to my own safety. Also lets bring the same situation to a towered airport where the controller tells you to go around while you are on final. I go around. If the scenario matches the above, I would still abort, climb, and fly parallel to the runway, all the while explaining to ATC what my intentions are. I'm not the one who would get busted because I'm complying with the instruction to "Go Around", I'm the one on final, and I'm maneuvering to avoid a collision. An argument *could* be made (though I'm not sure how strong or weak it is) that I was in an "emergency situation" and was deviating from whatever regulations I needed to in order to avoid contact with another aircraft. The way I fly, if the controller says "go around", by the time he finishes the word "around", my throttle is already wide open. My instructor taught me well to have an instinctive reaction to going around. It saved my bacon a couple times after some approaches that didn't translate into good landings. I am asking this because I am just wondering that at some point the aircraft could collide (one climbing out, the other at pattern altitude), and what the pilot going around should do... The aircraft will collide only if you let them (provided you have time to avoid the situation). Chris G. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Nik wrote:
What would you do in the following situtation: You are approaching a non towered field, communicate right and all that stuff, your on final, suddenly a cessna pulls up and starts it's take off roll. Also lets bring the same situation to a towered airport where the controller tells you to go around while you are on final. I am asking this because I am just wondering that at some point the aircraft could collide (one climbing out, the other at pattern altitude), and what the pilot going around should do... This EXACT situation happened to me on about my second or third time of solo flying practice in the pattern. I had been flying a few circuits around the pattern, announcing my position the way I'd been taught. I was landing at a comfortable interval behind another aircraft, but as soon as the aircraft in front of me crossed the threshold, a departing plane pulled out in front of me to get in position for a takeoff roll. I kept the departing plane in sight, and announced "Cessna 123XY going around due to traffic on the runway". (I probably should have specified "departing traffic", because just after I made my announcement, the aircraft which had just landed and cleared the runway said "Bonanza 234ab is clear of the runway" -- he may have thought I was tailgating him). I heard another voice say "he pulled right out in front of you, didn't he?". I started climbing to pattern altitude and kept the departing plane in sight by a combination of moving to the right a bit and slipping. I got to pattern altitude about the time I was over the far end of the runway. About then, I decided it was silly to follow the runway centerline all the way to a normal crosswind, especially with the rogue aircraft climing on nearly the same trajectory, so I did a short crosswind while he was still well below me and I joined the normal base leg, announcing intentions the whole way. I never heard the departing aircraft say anything. I assume he had no radio or was too embarassed. I'm not sure that what I did was textbook perfect; I was improvising as a very green student. But the important thing was that I kept the departing aircraft in sight, I announced my intentions, I stayed in a fairly normal pattern watching for other traffic, I didn't make any assumptions that the departing aircraft had a radio or was going to follow any standard procedures, and I didn't let his mistake upset me too much. --Rich |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Kyle Boatright wrote:
"Nik" wrote in message ups.com... Ok thank you... How would you say the intentions though? -Nik "Your Location Traffic, NXYZ is going around due to departing traffic on Runway **, will fly an upwind on the Right side of Runway **." I'd probably say I was going around due to a fool on the runway, but otherwise I concur with what you suggest. :-) Matt |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|