If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to replacing instrument panels
Why bother chasing a new instrument panel? They are very expensive, hard to get, and a blank "factory" panel is difficult to cut properly and get "spot on".
This alternative method works great and actually offers "easier to service" benefits. The concept is to cut a new panel from redi-available and relatively inexpensive soft aluminum sheet then fasten the new aluminum panel to your old factory panel "skelton" by use of rivnuts. With the old panel completely stripped, "hollow" out the panel "face" creating a structural skelton to hold the new aluminum panel. It takes a bit of fiddle and fit but it comes together quickly. Leave as much lip as possible to maintain strength and hold rivnuts. Done correctly, it is hard to notice new panel is an overlay. The best example of this was a 2 piece aluminum panel with a removable full length center section that allowed you to replace your flight computer in less than 30 minutes. The center section also mounted the transponder, switches, fuses, and USBs below the flight computer allowing complete access to the maze of all that without removing the canopy. Beats the hell out of servicing something mounted to a factory panel. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to replacing instrument panels
ben soaring wrote on 2/23/2021 4:14 PM:
Why bother chasing a new instrument panel? They are very expensive, hard to get, and a blank "factory" panel is difficult to cut properly and get "spot on". This alternative method works great and actually offers "easier to service" benefits. The concept is to cut a new panel from redi-available and relatively inexpensive soft aluminum sheet then fasten the new aluminum panel to your old factory panel "skelton" by use of rivnuts. With the old panel completely stripped, "hollow" out the panel "face" creating a structural skelton to hold the new aluminum panel. It takes a bit of fiddle and fit but it comes together quickly. Leave as much lip as possible to maintain strength and hold rivnuts. Done correctly, it is hard to notice new panel is an overlay. The best example of this was a 2 piece aluminum panel with a removable full length center section that allowed you to replace your flight computer in less than 30 minutes. The center section also mounted the transponder, switches, fuses, and USBs below the flight computer allowing complete access to the maze of all that without removing the canopy. Beats the hell out of servicing something mounted to a factory panel. How about just bolt on the new panel, then use a router to cut away the pieces of the old panel that show through the new panel? That leaves as much of the old panel as possible. I like the concept. -- Eric Greenwell - Washington State, USA (change ".netto" to ".us" to email me) - "A Guide to Self-Launching Sailplane Operation" https://sites.google.com/site/motorg...ad-the-guide-1 |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to replacing instrument panels
On Tuesday, February 23, 2021 at 7:15:01 PM UTC-5, ben soaring wrote:
Why bother chasing a new instrument panel? They are very expensive, hard to get, and a blank "factory" panel is difficult to cut properly and get "spot on". This alternative method works great and actually offers "easier to service" benefits. The concept is to cut a new panel from redi-available and relatively inexpensive soft aluminum sheet then fasten the new aluminum panel to your old factory panel "skelton" by use of rivnuts. With the old panel completely stripped, "hollow" out the panel "face" creating a structural skelton to hold the new aluminum panel. It takes a bit of fiddle and fit but it comes together quickly. Leave as much lip as possible to maintain strength and hold rivnuts. Done correctly, it is hard to notice new panel is an overlay. The best example of this was a 2 piece aluminum panel with a removable full length center section that allowed you to replace your flight computer in less than 30 minutes. The center section also mounted the transponder, switches, fuses, and USBs below the flight computer allowing complete access to the maze of all that without removing the canopy. Beats the hell out of servicing something mounted to a factory panel. I like this concept. Got any photos to share?? |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to replacing instrument panels
One drawback is that the former skeletonized panel will interfere with the backside surface of the "new" panel, making instruments not fit with the flush mounting intended by the designers. Mounting screws will be (possibly) too short, and some corners of the instruments may not sit flat against the panel. These deficiencies may be acceptable to some, but not to me. I'd rather go the extra mile and do it right with a new panel, like I have done four times in the past. I'm getting better at it, too!
|
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to replacing instrument panels
I like this concept. Got any photos to share?? Sorry, no pictures. Mark is correct as double panel thickness does not work well. You can remove most of the factory panel face so the instruments mounted to the aluminum overlay do not not touch the original panel when attached. You just have to leave 4-6 tabs large enough to hold a rivnut and there is usually plenty of non-interfering factory panel material to locate the tabs. The most important thing is avoid cutting into the radius lip of the factory panel as it weakens the skeleton structure. This is not a kitchen table project; but, if you have access to tools and are handy, then it's no big deal. Use "hard" poster board to make a full panel template... no concern if it takes more than one try to get the template you like. You can layout the holes on the poster board which establishes where to locate the rivnut tabs. I use Adobe PDF , Microsoft Paint, and Microsoft Publisher to make accurate (within 0.1mm) full size instrument "pictures" and move them around the poster board until the layout "works". The cheaper aluminum sheet from the local sheet metal shop works just fine. Use "soft" alloys like 3003 or 5052. 6061 is OK too but more expensive. Do not use hard aluminum like 2024 or 7005; its difficult to work with and much more expensive. 0.100 thickness works well. Cover the sheet aluminum with white contact "shelf paper"; it's much easier to draw on the contact paper than the bare aluminum. Use the poster board to trace out the full panel then cut with a jigsaw using a metal cutting blade. Layout your instrument holes and center punch. Then a drill press, a good fresh hole saw, and random files and you got it. Use a good hole saw, cheap ones can wobble making an oblong hole. Always cut a test hole and measure before you start on the real panel. So endeth the lesson and good luck. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to replacing instrument panels
On Wednesday, 24 February 2021 at 08:03:05 UTC, ben soaring wrote:
I like this concept. Got any photos to share?? Sorry, no pictures. Mark is correct as double panel thickness does not work well. You can remove most of the factory panel face so the instruments mounted to the aluminum overlay do not not touch the original panel when attached. You just have to leave 4-6 tabs large enough to hold a rivnut and there is usually plenty of non-interfering factory panel material to locate the tabs. The most important thing is avoid cutting into the radius lip of the factory panel as it weakens the skeleton structure. This is not a kitchen table project; but, if you have access to tools and are handy, then it's no big deal. Use "hard" poster board to make a full panel template... no concern if it takes more than one try to get the template you like. You can layout the holes on the poster board which establishes where to locate the rivnut tabs. I use Adobe PDF , Microsoft Paint, and Microsoft Publisher to make accurate (within 0.1mm) full size instrument "pictures" and move them around the poster board until the layout "works". The cheaper aluminum sheet from the local sheet metal shop works just fine. Use "soft" alloys like 3003 or 5052. 6061 is OK too but more expensive. Do not use hard aluminum like 2024 or 7005; its difficult to work with and much more expensive. 0.100 thickness works well. Cover the sheet aluminum with white contact "shelf paper"; it's much easier to draw on the contact paper than the bare aluminum. Use the poster board to trace out the full panel then cut with a jigsaw using a metal cutting blade. Layout your instrument holes and center punch. Then a drill press, a good fresh hole saw, and random files and you got it. Use a good hole saw, cheap ones can wobble making an oblong hole. Always cut a test hole and measure before you start on the real panel. So endeth the lesson and good luck. The reason that glider manufacturers stopped using aluminum panels was to reduce leg injuries in an accident or bail-out. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to replacing instrument panels
John Galloway wrote on 2/24/2021 6:18 AM:
On Wednesday, 24 February 2021 at 08:03:05 UTC, ben soaring wrote: I like this concept. Got any photos to share?? Sorry, no pictures. Mark is correct as double panel thickness does not work well. You can remove most of the factory panel face so the instruments mounted to the aluminum overlay do not not touch the original panel when attached. You just have to leave 4-6 tabs large enough to hold a rivnut and there is usually plenty of non-interfering factory panel material to locate the tabs. The most important thing is avoid cutting into the radius lip of the factory panel as it weakens the skeleton structure. This is not a kitchen table project; but, if you have access to tools and are handy, then it's no big deal. Use "hard" poster board to make a full panel template... no concern if it takes more than one try to get the template you like. You can layout the holes on the poster board which establishes where to locate the rivnut tabs. I use Adobe PDF , Microsoft Paint, and Microsoft Publisher to make accurate (within 0.1mm) full size instrument "pictures" and move them around the poster board until the layout "works". The cheaper aluminum sheet from the local sheet metal shop works just fine. Use "soft" alloys like 3003 or 5052. 6061 is OK too but more expensive. Do not use hard aluminum like 2024 or 7005; its difficult to work with and much more expensive. 0.100 thickness works well. Cover the sheet aluminum with white contact "shelf paper"; it's much easier to draw on the contact paper than the bare aluminum. Use the poster board to trace out the full panel then cut with a jigsaw using a metal cutting blade. Layout your instrument holes and center punch. Then a drill press, a good fresh hole saw, and random files and you got it. Use a good hole saw, cheap ones can wobble making an oblong hole. Always cut a test hole and measure before you start on the real panel. So endeth the lesson and good luck. The reason that glider manufacturers stopped using aluminum panels was to reduce leg injuries in an accident or bail-out. The panel on my Std Cirrus was metal, no flange, and solidly mounted. The edges above the legs were like dull knives. A metal panel mounted on composite panel (as suggested here) would have a flange, and perhaps be just as safe as the original composite panel. Also, for decades, many/most panels are on pods that rotate upwards, which reduces the chance for injury. -- Eric Greenwell - Washington State, USA (change ".netto" to ".us" to email me) - "A Guide to Self-Launching Sailplane Operation" https://sites.google.com/site/motorg...ad-the-guide-1 |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to replacing instrument panelsM
On Wednesday, February 24, 2021 at 6:58:03 AM UTC-8, Eric Greenwell wrote:
John Galloway wrote on 2/24/2021 6:18 AM: On Wednesday, 24 February 2021 at 08:03:05 UTC, ben soaring wrote: I like this concept. Got any photos to share?? Sorry, no pictures. Mark is correct as double panel thickness does not work well. You can remove most of the factory panel face so the instruments mounted to the aluminum overlay do not not touch the original panel when attached. You just have to leave 4-6 tabs large enough to hold a rivnut and there is usually plenty of non-interfering factory panel material to locate the tabs. The most important thing is avoid cutting into the radius lip of the factory panel as it weakens the skeleton structure. This is not a kitchen table project; but, if you have access to tools and are handy, then it's no big deal. Use "hard" poster board to make a full panel template... no concern if it takes more than one try to get the template you like. You can layout the holes on the poster board which establishes where to locate the rivnut tabs. I use Adobe PDF , Microsoft Paint, and Microsoft Publisher to make accurate (within 0.1mm) full size instrument "pictures" and move them around the poster board until the layout "works". The cheaper aluminum sheet from the local sheet metal shop works just fine. Use "soft" alloys like 3003 or 5052. 6061 is OK too but more expensive. Do not use hard aluminum like 2024 or 7005; its difficult to work with and much more expensive. 0.100 thickness works well. Cover the sheet aluminum with white contact "shelf paper"; it's much easier to draw on the contact paper than the bare aluminum. Use the poster board to trace out the full panel then cut with a jigsaw using a metal cutting blade. Layout your instrument holes and center punch. Then a drill press, a good fresh hole saw, and random files and you got it. Use a good hole saw, cheap ones can wobble making an oblong hole. Always cut a test hole and measure before you start on the real panel. So endeth the lesson and good luck. The reason that glider manufacturers stopped using aluminum panels was to reduce leg injuries in an accident or bail-out. The panel on my Std Cirrus was metal, no flange, and solidly mounted. The edges above the legs were like dull knives. A metal panel mounted on composite panel (as suggested here) would have a flange, and perhaps be just as safe as the original composite panel. Also, for decades, many/most panels are on pods that rotate upwards, which reduces the chance for injury. -- Eric Greenwell - Washington State, USA (change ".netto" to ".us" to email me) - "A Guide to Self-Launching Sailplane Operation" https://sites.google.com/site/motorg...ad-the-guide-1 For those comfortable with fiberglass work, just scarf out the old panel from the rear, leaving the flange. Clamp to a flat surface that has mold release on it (plastic wrap works ok) and lay in 5 or 6 layers of medium strength cloth. Cut new holes with hole saw ( 2.25” & 3.125” available) in drill press from rear side. Fill, prime and paint in flat black. Peace of cake, JJ |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to replacing instrument panels
Why not make a new panel by tracing the outline of the factory on the
new aluminum (or glass or carbon sheet), cutting it out, laying out the new instrument holes, and cutting and drilling as necessary? It seems much simpler, but I wonder if I'm missing something. Dan 5J On 2/24/21 1:03 AM, ben soaring wrote: I like this concept. Got any photos to share?? Sorry, no pictures. Mark is correct as double panel thickness does not work well. You can remove most of the factory panel face so the instruments mounted to the aluminum overlay do not not touch the original panel when attached. You just have to leave 4-6 tabs large enough to hold a rivnut and there is usually plenty of non-interfering factory panel material to locate the tabs. The most important thing is avoid cutting into the radius lip of the factory panel as it weakens the skeleton structure. This is not a kitchen table project; but, if you have access to tools and are handy, then it's no big deal. Use "hard" poster board to make a full panel template... no concern if it takes more than one try to get the template you like. You can layout the holes on the poster board which establishes where to locate the rivnut tabs. I use Adobe PDF , Microsoft Paint, and Microsoft Publisher to make accurate (within 0.1mm) full size instrument "pictures" and move them around the poster board until the layout "works". The cheaper aluminum sheet from the local sheet metal shop works just fine. Use "soft" alloys like 3003 or 5052. 6061 is OK too but more expensive. Do not use hard aluminum like 2024 or 7005; its difficult to work with and much more expensive. 0.100 thickness works well. Cover the sheet aluminum with white contact "shelf paper"; it's much easier to draw on the contact paper than the bare aluminum. Use the poster board to trace out the full panel then cut with a jigsaw using a metal cutting blade. Layout your instrument holes and center punch. Then a drill press, a good fresh hole saw, and random files and you got it. Use a good hole saw, cheap ones can wobble making an oblong hole. Always cut a test hole and measure before you start on the real panel. So endeth the lesson and good luck. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Another way to replacing instrument panels
On Wednesday, February 24, 2021 at 10:38:37 AM UTC-8, Dan Marotta wrote:
Why not make a new panel by tracing the outline of the factory on the new aluminum (or glass or carbon sheet), cutting it out, laying out the new instrument holes, and cutting and drilling as necessary? It seems much simpler, but I wonder if I'm missing something. Dan 5J On 2/24/21 1:03 AM, ben soaring wrote: I like this concept. Got any photos to share?? Sorry, no pictures. Mark is correct as double panel thickness does not work well. You can remove most of the factory panel face so the instruments mounted to the aluminum overlay do not not touch the original panel when attached. You just have to leave 4-6 tabs large enough to hold a rivnut and there is usually plenty of non-interfering factory panel material to locate the tabs. The most important thing is avoid cutting into the radius lip of the factory panel as it weakens the skeleton structure. This is not a kitchen table project; but, if you have access to tools and are handy, then it's no big deal. Use "hard" poster board to make a full panel template... no concern if it takes more than one try to get the template you like. You can layout the holes on the poster board which establishes where to locate the rivnut tabs. I use Adobe PDF , Microsoft Paint, and Microsoft Publisher to make accurate (within 0.1mm) full size instrument "pictures" and move them around the poster board until the layout "works". The cheaper aluminum sheet from the local sheet metal shop works just fine. Use "soft" alloys like 3003 or 5052. 6061 is OK too but more expensive.. Do not use hard aluminum like 2024 or 7005; its difficult to work with and much more expensive. 0.100 thickness works well. Cover the sheet aluminum with white contact "shelf paper"; it's much easier to draw on the contact paper than the bare aluminum. Use the poster board to trace out the full panel then cut with a jigsaw using a metal cutting blade. Layout your instrument holes and center punch. Then a drill press, a good fresh hole saw, and random files and you got it. Use a good hole saw, cheap ones can wobble making an oblong hole. Always cut a test hole and measure before you start on the real panel. So endeth the lesson and good luck. Best to keep the flange that most newer ships have incorporated. Much safer and the panel mount holes remain the same. |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Selling: 2 instrument panels for LS-10. Also 57mm Airspeed indicator. | John Bojack J4 | Soaring | 4 | January 17th 17 04:30 AM |
Replacing innertubes without replacing tires? | Ben Jackson | Owning | 28 | November 6th 06 04:54 PM |
F4 Phantom Jet vs concrete wall + McDonnell Aircraft F-4 instrument panels | Hans | Piloting | 2 | May 22nd 06 10:48 PM |
F4 Phantom Jet vs concrete wall + McDonnell Aircraft F-4 instrument panels | Hansi | Instrument Flight Rules | 0 | May 22nd 06 08:44 PM |
Replacing Instrument Faces? | Marco Leon | Owning | 1 | October 25th 04 06:02 PM |