![]() |
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Mfg. 2000, s/n 2023, Acrylic Paint, Carbon elevator
with stiffened tail allows 150kts Vne, Cleveland Wheel & Brake, Huge cockpit for big and tall pilots, Graphlite carbon fiber spar is extremely strong and durable, dual battery holder, Winter ASI, COBRA Trailer, NDH. Discus 2 performance at a fraction of the cost. CO 303-438-6597 |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
At 02:42 08 February 2007, Steve Davis wrote:
Discus 2 performance at a fraction of the cost. That would be why there was so many flying at the last Std Class World Champs then.. And why there was so many flying at the Std Class Worlds when the original Discus was the class of the field. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Peter F wrote:
At 02:42 08 February 2007, Steve Davis wrote: Discus 2 performance at a fraction of the cost. That would be why there was so many flying at the last Std Class World Champs then.. And why there was so many flying at the Std Class Worlds when the original Discus was the class of the field. 41 Discus 2 A & B in the US 6 flew in 2006 Senior Contest, Seminole Lake Gliderport, Florida 23 Genesis II in the US 2 flew in 2006 Senior Contest, Seminole Lake Gliderport, Florida That's a reasonable representation. Those old guys know how to get the most for their money. ![]() Jack |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Peter,
Well, it's winter, I'll bite. Speaking of the Worlds, Clem Bowman was getting ready to take one to the Worlds - unfortunately that never happened. I'll defer to the opinions of Karl Striedieck, Bill Bartell, JJ Sinclair, David Mercer, Bob Salvo and Ron Gaynier. I believe all have won contest days with the ship. Dick Johnson's flight test (online at ssa.org, I believe) has a nice polar and a performance evaluation if you are interested. He even has overlay comparisons with a Discus to make it easy. Ever flown one? Mike Brooks |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 8, 3:50 am, wrote:
Ever flown one? It seems a bit of a stretch to claim the Genesis is as good as the Discus 2. I raced a lot with a local Genesis pilot and you couldn't convince me, or him, that was true. Contest results are not always a good indication of glider performance though. A tiny perceived difference in performance will have all the top pilots flying one or two types and they will win. If you put that group of pilots in a different glider type they would still win. I flew the prototype Genesis at Uvalde, liked it, but didn't buy one. Andy |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 8, 9:58 am, "Andy" wrote:
On Feb 8, 3:50 am, wrote: Ever flown one? It seems a bit of a stretch to claim the Genesis is as good as the Discus 2. I raced a lot with a local Genesis pilot and you couldn't convince me, or him, that was true. Contest results are not always a good indication of glider performance though. A tiny perceived difference in performance will have all the top pilots flying one or two types and they will win. If you put that group of pilots in a different glider type they would still win. I flew the prototype Genesis at Uvalde, liked it, but didn't buy one. Andy Maybe. What were your experiences, then? Were you ahead in the high- speed cruise, the climb, or both? Ballasted or dry? Agreed that if you put top pilots in a different machine, they'll still win. We're talking a few percent one way or the other here. In my case at least, the ship is not the limiting factor. It's something to talk about until the season starts up, though.... Mike |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Jack wrote:
Peter F wrote: At 02:42 08 February 2007, Steve Davis wrote: Discus 2 performance at a fraction of the cost. That would be why there was so many flying at the last Std Class World Champs then.. 41 Discus 2 A & B in the US 6 flew in 2006 Senior Contest, Seminole Lake Gliderport, Florida 23 Genesis II in the US 2 flew in 2006 Senior Contest, Seminole Lake Gliderport, Florida That's a reasonable representation. Sure, but the real question is (was) - if the Genesis 2 is as good as a Discus 2, why aren't there more G2's? Tony V. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Feb 8, 8:12 am, Tony Verhulst wrote:
Jack wrote: Peter F wrote: At 02:42 08 February 2007, Steve Davis wrote: Discus 2 performance at a fraction of the cost. That would be why there was so many flying at the last Std Class World Champs then.. 41 Discus 2 A & B in the US 6 flew in 2006 Senior Contest, Seminole Lake Gliderport, Florida 23 Genesis II in the US 2 flew in 2006 Senior Contest, Seminole Lake Gliderport, Florida That's a reasonable representation. Sure, but the real question is (was) - if the Genesis 2 is as good as a Discus 2, why aren't there more G2's? Tony V. Good question. I think there are a lot of variables involved here. For one, the G2 is an unorthodox design, and I think we've seen that in many different aircraft that tends to lead to low production numbers. Beech Starship comes to mind. Clem Bowman's accident certainly must have had some effect on orders. We will never know what would have happened had he continued his successful racing career in the G2. Otherwise - there are plenty of designs that were successful sailplanes but had limited production runs. How about the Sisu? The number of units produced is not necessarily a good metric of the absolute value of a glider. The G2 can be debated in a number of ways. Some people just don't like they way they look - fair enough. That's personal taste. But if you have a look at the numbers (and maybe even fly one), I think the reason for the low production number lies outside the performance realm and gets into the area of manufacturing issues. My hat is off to the people that worked hard to produce them. Mike Brooks |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
At 10:30 08 February 2007, Jack wrote:
41 Discus 2 A & B in the US 6 flew in 2006 Senior Contest, Seminole Lake Gliderport, Florida 23 Genesis II in the US 2 flew in 2006 Senior Contest, Seminole Lake Gliderport, Florida That's a reasonable representation. Those old guys know how to get the most for their money. ![]() Jack So there are twice as many D2s as Genesis 2s in the US, but three times as many flew at the above contest. Not sure if you're arguing for or against the G2 |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
The Genesis 2 continued in production thru 2000 and
there may have been one or two built in early 2001. If you look at the US stock market performance, most major companies peaked in early 2000 followed by steady stock price declines through 2001. Stock prices may have started to rebound in late 2001; we'll never know because 9/11, an anthrax scare, smallpox worries and the crash of an Airbus in New York caused a multi-trillion dollar decline in travel and tourism which reverberated throughout the economy. This extended what would have been a relatively mild economic downturn into a mild downturn that lasted a very long time. I say it was mild because 6% was considered full employment until the mid eighties. Now, 6% unemployment is considered a recession in America. (In Europe, 6% unemployment would be called 'unprecedented prosperity a major economic boom and proof positive that socialism, high taxes and unrestricted immigration works,' but they'll never see a 6% unemployment rate, at least not in western Europe.) :-) Anyway, people in America don't buy gliders if they don't have a fair amount of disposable income and it's hard to get a lot of that when the price of your stock went from eighty to ten. Production of the Genesis stopped, Rolladin-Schneider went belly up, more used gliders were on the market and most glider manufacturers went thru some very hard times. DG and Schemp-Hirth probably stayed in business because of deep pockets by owners - going out of business in Germany can be more expensive than staying in business - and purchases by European gliding clubs, not because of individual buyers. Also, Clem Bowmans' accident had a very big effect. There were a lot of rumors that the Genesis didn't have automatic control connections- it does- and since it looks like a flying wing it should somehow be able to fly without an elevator - it won't. Had he continued racing the Genesis 2 it probably would have been much more successful. At 14:48 08 February 2007, wrote: On Feb 8, 8:12 am, Tony Verhulst wrote: Jack wrote: Peter F wrote: At 02:42 08 February 2007, Steve Davis wrote: Discus 2 performance at a fraction of the cost. That would be why there was so many flying at the last Std Class World Champs then.. 41 Discus 2 A & B in the US 6 flew in 2006 Senior Contest, Seminole Lake Gliderport, Florida 23 Genesis II in the US 2 flew in 2006 Senior Contest, Seminole Lake Gliderport, Florida That's a reasonable representation. Sure, but the real question is (was) - if the Genesis 2 is as good as a Discus 2, why aren't there more G2's? Tony V. Good question. I think there are a lot of variables involved here. For one, the G2 is an unorthodox design, and I think we've seen that in many different aircraft that tends to lead to low production numbers. Beech Starship comes to mind. Clem Bowman's accident certainly must have had some effect on orders. We will never know what would have happened had he continued his successful racing career in the G2. Otherwise - there are plenty of designs that were successful sailplanes but had limited production runs. How about the Sisu? The number of units produced is not necessarily a good metric of the absolute value of a glider. The G2 can be debated in a number of ways. Some people just don't like they way they look - fair enough. That's personal taste. But if you have a look at the numbers (and maybe even fly one), I think the reason for the low production number lies outside the performance realm and gets into the area of manufacturing issues. My hat is off to the people that worked hard to produce them. Mike Brooks |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
YAMAHA FZ 750 FZ750 RUNNING GENESIS ENGINE FOR SALE | Karsten | Home Built | 0 | September 3rd 04 07:34 PM |
YAMAHA FZ 750 FZ750 RUNNING GENESIS ENGINE FOR SALE | Karsten | Products | 0 | September 3rd 04 07:34 PM |
Genesis 2 Production | Istvan Csonka | Soaring | 0 | January 15th 04 04:19 PM |
GENESIS 2 RECOMMENDATION | Gordon Schubert | Soaring | 5 | January 3rd 04 06:38 AM |
GENESIS 2 RECOMMENDATION | Gordon Schubert | Soaring | 7 | January 2nd 04 02:40 AM |