Problems in a commercial flight

Correction: Actually, Mxsmanic knows a great deal, _despite_ not being a
pilot.

I cannot disagree with this.

The problem is that you do not know what you do not know, and lack of
practical experience has left your knowledge with a great number of
holes that you refuse to acknowledge.

It is a typically sophomoric attitude (hence my initial impression
that you were an adolescent).

This is particularly true with respect to large aircraft, since most
of the pilots here are familiar only with the tiny aircraft they fly, whereas
he has studied both small and large aircraft.

That is a GROSS generalization.

Yes, some pilot's only care about the planes that they fly... I would
say that is actually the exception rather than the rule, however.

The rest of us have just as much a passion for aviation as yourself
AND we fly. When we're not spending our spare time in a cockpit, we
spend it learning about aircraft and aircraft systems... Aircraft
design (A particular favorite topic of mine) and other aviation
related topics... and hell, even flying sims...

More to the point: If you see an error in anything I've said, feel free to
point it out.

Your explanation of the cause of the roll oscillations was utterly
wrong, and your desire to attribute ultimate aircraft stability to
autopilot design is also largly incorrect (Except in a few isolated
(almost always military) cases of relaxed stability aircraft.

He doesn't have to pretend.

This might be a low blow but...

Isn't that the fundamental definition of Simulation?

Nor is he so insecure that he must engage in personal attacks if someone else seems to know more.

I actually agree that the personal attacks against you have grown more
disruptive than your actual sophomoric nature.

One of the aggravations I have had, however - is you do not seem to
respond to anything BUT the personal attacks - I have seen MANY
knowledgeable, polite corrections and responses to your assertions go
un-heeded while you chose only to argue with those who attacked you.
It gives the impression that you seek the negative attention over
actual helpfulness.

I still wish you'd take some time to get your information from sources
OTHER than public forums however... So many of your questions could be
answered so much easier and faster via a quick Google search.

And It would also be nice if you added an occasional "my understanding
is" disclaimer to some of your more authoritative-toned posts...