![]() |
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Mike Marron" wrote in message ... (Kirk Stant) wrote: Just for fun, off the top of your heads, which post-WW2 combat aircraft (any country) have NOT been used in their intended roles in an actual shooting war (or police action, or soccer riot, or whatever it's called these days)? And why? Some ROE: 1. Combat aircraft means it was designed or modified to employ air-to-air or air-to-ground/ship/boat weapons. 2. Combat means someone was activily shooting back (or really wanted to) while the aircraft was performing it's mission. 3. Let's leave out recce, that just gets too complicated! To start things off, here are my USAF candidates: B-36 - Held back from Korea for Nuke mission. B-47 - Too early for Korea, too late for Vietnam (remember, no recce). F-84F - Too early for Korea (ef considered a separate aircraft from straight-wing F-84s), too late for Vietnam. Combat use by other countries? F-89 - Too late for Korea (?), not needed (no bomber threat). F-106 - Not needed in Vietnam - F-102s deployed instead. F-101 (Yeah, I know about the RF-101 in Cuba and Vietnam). Don't know why F-101Cs weren't used early in Vietnam. Being phased out by then? Could be wrong, but here goes: B-36, B-47, F-84F, F-89, F-106, F-101, F-86D, F-94C, Saab Draken, Saab 29, F-4D Skyray, F7U Cutlass, F9F (swept-wing) Cougar, Gloster Javelin, Avro Vulcan, Handley Page Victor, Supermarine Scimitar, Fiat Vulcans performed bombing missions in the Falklands and Victors operated as tankers then and in Gulf War 1 G.91, English Electric Lightning, Dassault Mirage IV, Saab Viggen, Sukhoi Su-15, Shin Meiwa, Alpha Jet, Folland Gnat, BAe Hawk, Fuji T1F2, Supermarine Swift, Tupolov Tu-22, Tupulov Tu-26, B-58 Hustler, Tupolov Tu-16, North American B-45, Hawker Firebrand, Tupolov Tu-20, Hawker Siddeley Buccaneer, Hawker Sea Vixen, deHavilland Venom, Buccaneers were operational in the Gulf War and I believe Venoms did ground attack in Malaya and Sea Venoms operated in Korea McDonnell F2H-4 Banshee, North American FJ-4B Fury, deHavilland Vampire, Yakolev Yak-25A, Dassault Ouragen, McDonnell FH-1 Vampires saw service in Korea I think Phantom, Hawker Sea Fury, Grumman F7F Tigercat, McDonnell F3H Demon, Supermarine Attacker... Sea Furies were used off RN carriers in Korea I think. The Indians have used the attacker against Pakistan I believe Everything else got lots of chances to do their thing. At first glance, looks like the US taxpayer is getting a pretty good deal for his money! Kirk (tired of all the non-mil av bull**** on this group) Same. |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Keith Willshaw wrote:
"Mike Marron" wrote in message ... snip Buccaneers were operational in the Gulf War and I believe Venoms did ground attack in Malaya and Sea Venoms operated in Korea No Sea venoms that I'm aware of. Only the Colossus-class light fleets were deployed to Korea, and they had air groups of Seafires or Sea Furies and Fireflies. McDonnell F2H-4 Banshee, North American FJ-4B Fury, deHavilland Vampire, Yakolev Yak-25A, Dassault Ouragen, McDonnell FH-1 Vampires saw service in Korea I think Meteor. Phantom, Hawker Sea Fury, Grumman F7F Tigercat, McDonnell F3H Demon, Supermarine Attacker... Sea Furies were used off RN carriers in Korea I think. Yes, see above. The Indians have used the attacker against Pakistan I believe If it happened it was the other way around. Guy |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Guy Alcala wrote in message ...
Keith Willshaw wrote: "Mike Marron" wrote in message ... snip Buccaneers were operational in the Gulf War and I believe Venoms did ground attack in Malaya and Sea Venoms operated in Korea No Sea venoms that I'm aware of. Only the Colossus-class light fleets were deployed to Korea, and they had air groups of Seafires or Sea Furies and Fireflies. Venoms saw action in Suez 56. McDonnell F2H-4 Banshee, North American FJ-4B Fury, deHavilland Vampire, Yakolev Yak-25A, Dassault Ouragen, McDonnell FH-1 Vampires saw service in Korea I think Meteor. I believe Vamps were used in combat by Rhodesia and South Africa, and (possibly) by Jordan , India, and Egypt. Brooks Phantom, Hawker Sea Fury, Grumman F7F Tigercat, McDonnell F3H Demon, Supermarine Attacker... Sea Furies were used off RN carriers in Korea I think. Yes, see above. The Indians have used the attacker against Pakistan I believe If it happened it was the other way around. Guy |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Kevin Brooks" wrote in message om... Guy Alcala wrote in message ... Keith Willshaw wrote: "Mike Marron" wrote in message ... snip Buccaneers were operational in the Gulf War and I believe Venoms did ground attack in Malaya and Sea Venoms operated in Korea No Sea venoms that I'm aware of. Only the Colossus-class light fleets were deployed to Korea, and they had air groups of Seafires or Sea Furies and Fireflies. Venoms saw action in Suez 56. McDonnell F2H-4 Banshee, North American FJ-4B Fury, deHavilland Vampire, Yakolev Yak-25A, Dassault Ouragen, McDonnell FH-1 Vampires saw service in Korea I think Meteor. I believe Vamps were used in combat by Rhodesia and South Africa, and (possibly) by Jordan , India, and Egypt. Brooks Just read about a clash between Israeli Meteors and Egyptian Vampires last night in fact. (By which I mean I read about it last night, it happened in the 50's) |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
![]() "Guy Alcala" wrote in message . .. Keith Willshaw wrote: "Mike Marron" wrote in message ... snip Buccaneers were operational in the Gulf War and I believe Venoms did ground attack in Malaya and Sea Venoms operated in Korea No Sea venoms that I'm aware of. Only the Colossus-class light fleets were deployed to Korea, and they had air groups of Seafires or Sea Furies and Fireflies. Quite right they arrived too late for service in Korea now I think about it, I suspect they were used over Suez though. Keith |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article ,
Keith Willshaw wrote: "Guy Alcala" wrote in message ... Keith Willshaw wrote: ground attack in Malaya and Sea Venoms operated in Korea No Sea venoms that I'm aware of. Only the Colossus-class light fleets were deployed to Korea, and they had air groups of Seafires or Sea Furies and Fireflies. Quite right they arrived too late for service in Korea now I think about it, I suspect they were used over Suez though. From the last asking/reading about that particular mistake, Suez featured Venoms, (Sea Vemons?), Squarks, Wyverns, Meteors, Valiants and Canberras. And Vampires, on the Egyptian side, plus some Soviet types (Tu-16, I think, amongst others) -- Andy Breen ~ Interplanetary Scintillation Research Group http://users.aber.ac.uk/azb/ "Time has stopped, says the Black Lion clock and eternity has begun" (Dylan Thomas) |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
In article ,
Keith Willshaw wrote: Phantom, Hawker Sea Fury, Grumman F7F Tigercat, McDonnell F3H Demon, Supermarine Attacker... Sea Furies were used off RN carriers in Korea I think. The Indians have used the attacker against Pakistan I believe They certainly used the Squark - up to the 1980s when they got Harrier, but I'm not sure they used the Attacker? -- Andy Breen ~ Interplanetary Scintillation Research Group http://users.aber.ac.uk/azb/ "Time has stopped, says the Black Lion clock and eternity has begun" (Dylan Thomas) |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
![]() Mike Marron wrote: (Kirk Stant) wrote: Just for fun, off the top of your heads, which post-WW2 combat aircraft (any country) have NOT been used in their intended roles in an actual shooting war (or police action, or soccer riot, or whatever it's called these days)? And why? Some ROE: 1. Combat aircraft means it was designed or modified to employ air-to-air or air-to-ground/ship/boat weapons. 2. Combat means someone was activily shooting back (or really wanted to) while the aircraft was performing it's mission. 3. Let's leave out recce, that just gets too complicated! To start things off, here are my USAF candidates: B-36 - Held back from Korea for Nuke mission. B-47 - Too early for Korea, too late for Vietnam (remember, no recce). F-84F - Too early for Korea (ef considered a separate aircraft from straight-wing F-84s), too late for Vietnam. Combat use by other countries? F-89 - Too late for Korea (?), not needed (no bomber threat). F-106 - Not needed in Vietnam - F-102s deployed instead. F-101 (Yeah, I know about the RF-101 in Cuba and Vietnam). Don't know why F-101Cs weren't used early in Vietnam. Being phased out by then? Could be wrong, but here goes: B-36, B-47, F-84F, F-89, F-106, F-101, F-86D, F-94C, Saab Draken, Saab 29, F-4D Skyray, F7U Cutlass, F9F (swept-wing) Cougar, Gloster Javelin, Avro Vulcan, Handley Page Victor, Supermarine Scimitar, Fiat G.91, English Electric Lightning, Dassault Mirage IV, Saab Viggen, Sukhoi Su-15, Shin Meiwa, Alpha Jet, Folland Gnat, BAe Hawk, Fuji T1F2, Supermarine Swift, Tupolov Tu-22, Tupulov Tu-26, B-58 Hustler, Tupolov Tu-16, North American B-45, Hawker Firebrand, Tupolov Tu-20, Hawker Siddeley Buccaneer, Hawker Sea Vixen, deHavilland Venom, McDonnell F2H-4 Banshee, North American FJ-4B Fury, deHavilland Vampire, Yakolev Yak-25A, Dassault Ouragen, McDonnell FH-1 Phantom, Hawker Sea Fury, Grumman F7F Tigercat, McDonnell F3H Demon, Supermarine Attacker... Everything else got lots of chances to do their thing. At first glance, looks like the US taxpayer is getting a pretty good deal for his money! Kirk (tired of all the non-mil av bull**** on this group) Same. A Correction: Tu-16 Badgers have seen combat-by the Iraqis in 1967 against the Israelis and in 1980-88 against Iran; Soviet Badgers were in Afghanistan. Libyan Tu-22s have seen combat in Chad, Sudan, and Tanzania. Soviet Tu-22M (Tu-26) Backfires were used in Afghanistan in 1987-88, and in the first Chechen campaign. Buccaneers in S.African service saw combat in Angola, Sea Furies in Korea, Suez, and by the Cubans against the Bay of Pigs force; F7Fs saw action in Korea, while French F-84Fs were also in Suez.Vulcans flew the Black Buck missions in the Falklands War, with Victors as Tankers there and in Desert Storm. RB-45s flew in Korea. Posted via www.My-Newsgroups.com - web to news gateway for usenet access! |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
In message , Mike Marron
writes Could be wrong, but here goes: F-101, Did recce over Vietnam, didn't it? Gloster Javelin, Indonesian Confrontation, 1960s Avro Vulcan, Black Buck raids, Falklands Handley Page Victor Tanking in the Falklands and IIRC the Gulf, plus some "small war" bombing IIRC. Fiat G.91, English Electric Lightning, Folland Gnat, Used in combat by the Indians. BAe Hawk, Used by several buyers for COIN against terrorists / ruthless repression of noble dissidents. Tupolov Tu-22 Libyan bombing raids vs. Chad, IIRC. Tupolov Tu-16, Egyptian raids vs. Israel, and I think Iranian Badgers saw some combat in the Iran-Iraq war. Hawker Siddeley Buccaneer South Africans used them in Namibia, and they also flew combat in Gulf War '91. Dassault Ouragen Used by the Israelis in 1967. Hawker Sea Fury Korea. -- When you have to kill a man, it costs nothing to be polite. W S Churchill Paul J. Adam MainBoxatjrwlynch[dot]demon{dot}co(.)uk |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
"Paul J. Adam" wrote in message ...
In message , Mike Marron writes Could be wrong, but here goes: F-101, Did recce over Vietnam, didn't it? The original poster discounted that use, but you are correct--it also collected bullet holes over Cuba. Gloster Javelin, Indonesian Confrontation, 1960s Did it shoot at anybody, or get shot at? Avro Vulcan, Black Buck raids, Falklands Ooops! I think I called them "Black Bart"! Too much time wasted watching "The Simpsons", I guess... Handley Page Victor Tanking in the Falklands and IIRC the Gulf, plus some "small war" bombing IIRC. Correct on the first two, but I don't think so on the bombing--confusing it with Valiant, perhaps? Fiat G.91, English Electric Lightning, Folland Gnat, Used in combat by the Indians. BAe Hawk, Used by several buyers for COIN against terrorists / ruthless repression of noble dissidents. Tupolov Tu-22 Libyan bombing raids vs. Chad, IIRC. I believe you are right--I had the same general recollection. Tupolov Tu-16, Egyptian raids vs. Israel, and I think Iranian Badgers saw some combat in the Iran-Iraq war. I believe the Egyptians also used them in Yemen. Hawker Siddeley Buccaneer South Africans used them in Namibia, and they also flew combat in Gulf War '91. Dassault Ouragen Used by the Israelis in 1967. Amongst others, IIRC. Hawker Sea Fury Korea. And Cuba. Brooks |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Homebuilt Aircraft Frequently Asked Questions List (FAQ) | Ron Wanttaja | Home Built | 40 | October 3rd 08 03:13 PM |
Homebuilt Aircraft Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) | Ron Wanttaja | Home Built | 0 | October 1st 04 02:31 PM |
Homebuilt Aircraft Frequently Asked Questions List (FAQ) | Ron Wanttaja | Home Built | 0 | September 2nd 04 05:15 AM |
Homebuilt Aircraft Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) | Ron Wanttaja | Home Built | 0 | May 1st 04 07:29 PM |
Homebuilt Aircraft Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) | Ron Wanttaja | Home Built | 4 | August 7th 03 05:12 AM |