If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes
On Sun, 19 Feb 2017 08:02:38 -0800, Tango Eight wrote:
On Sunday, February 19, 2017 at 9:59:27 AM UTC-5, Martin Gregorie wrote: On Sun, 19 Feb 2017 05:08:07 -0800, Tango Eight wrote: Had a side stick for a decade. Center stick is just better. Can you expand a bit, please? Sure. I think the irreducible issue is simply one of leverage and limited motion options. There's only one way to grip the stick, there's only one way to interact with it. All of the side stick designs I've seen for direct mechanical actuation of controls require a sliding fore/aft motion for elevator (elbow + shoulder) and a rolling motion of the wrist for aileron. Blending those motions with finesse is just more work (more fatigue) than a conventional gimballed stick. I landed out a couple of times in my side stick glider simply because I got tired and sloppy after 4+ hours and couldn't climb well. Coordination never became unconscious in that ship. The other things that I don't like about side stick equipped gliders tend to be the *reasons* designers opted for side sticks, not the sticks themselves: supine seating position, lousy forward visibility, tiny instrument pods, cockpits with no extra space for anything. That said, I have always had a desire to fly (but not own!) a Diana2, just because the thing was so radical. Thanks for the additional detail. Like you I'd like to check out a Diana 2 for comfort and forward visibility and wonder if cricked necks could be a problem. I entirely understand your point about about panel space. -- martin@ | Martin Gregorie gregorie. | Essex, UK org | |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes
On Sun, 19 Feb 2017 09:46:35 -0700, Bob Whelan wrote:
As a natural right-hander, I've often imagined adapting to a left-side stick (think many powerplanes) would require far more "mental adaptation" on my part than did adapting to my Zuni's right-side-stick. Maybe some Airbus-driving glider pilots will chime in? As a natural left-hander, I do most things left-handed. Yes, I built Free Flight models with the timer on the left but the start trigger on the right and I start engines left-handed. However, I had no problem learning to fly gliders right-handed: that was a non-issue. These days I normally fly right-handed and use my left for fiddling with instruments. I only swap hands in the Libelle to raise or lower the wheel. The only other thing I'm exclusively right-handed for is using cameras, which all seem to be designed by right-handers for right-handers. -- martin@ | Martin Gregorie gregorie. | Essex, UK org | |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes
How does a side stick compare to a parallelogram stick (e.g. Glasflugel)?
|
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes
Again, I've never flown a side stick, though if you think about it, a
simple Cessna with a yoke is flown with the left hand, ala side stick. The parallelogram stick in the Mosquito feels better than a floor gimballed center stick. It's very smooth operating and the throw is small enough that you can fly with wrist motion. Very nice. On 2/19/2017 2:06 PM, Del Jensen wrote: How does a side stick compare to a parallelogram stick (e.g. Glasflugel)? -- Dan, 5J |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes
On Sun, 19 Feb 2017 13:06:04 -0800, Del Jensen wrote:
How does a side stick compare to a parallelogram stick (e.g. Glasflugel)? DG-300 is also a parallelogram stick AFAIK. I've not flown a Glasflugel Mosquito but I have sat in one I was considering buying and handled the stick. The Mossy and the DG-300 sticks seemed pretty similar except that the Mossy's trim worked a lot better. From what others have said, it sounds as though the side stick is less 'natural' because centralised ailerons mean the handle sticks out horizontally from the cockpit wall but in the DG-300/Mossy its vertical like a conventional stick. Both side and parallelogram sticks require you to rotate your wrist to operate the ailerons, though with a parallelogram stick that would depend on just how you hold the stick. -- martin@ | Martin Gregorie gregorie. | Essex, UK org | |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes
Are the differences in jets documented? The Saab Gripen has a center stick for example, despite being newer than an F-16.
Russians also standardized center stick. |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes
|
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes
I finally got a few minutes to respond in the long form. Here are a bunch of points in no particular order:
* For a human factors class towards my psych minor, my semester project was comparing a sliding side stick with a pivoting center stick for a simple tracking task. The results suggested that tracking was improved when it involved angular displacement of the wrist. Tracking was also improved with greater linear and angular travel. * Because of their size and general characteristics, sailplanes tend to have long control system paths and also a lot of roll and yaw inertia. Flying a sailplane is definitely work in the technical sense of a force applied over a distance (control stick travel). The shorter the travel, the greater the force required to do the necessary work of defecting a control surface. But when you crowd the control stick up against the cockpit rail, you tend to run out of travel. * From a practical perspective, if you're going to have a side stick, you improve its chances of working well if you: -Maximize control stick travel -Reduce control system friction -Reduce control system slop and lost motion -Increase control system stiffness (reduce "springiness") -Reduce control system and surface inertia To this end, some of the side stick implementations we've seen in the soaring world have been disappointing. In the HP-18, you get 4.3" of horizontal travel between full nose up and nose down. In that travel, you move two relatively large ruddervators that are sized and counterweighted more for their effect as rudders than as elevators. To move them, you slide 24 feet (!) of 5/8" aluminum tubing through a dozen raw nylon guides. The ailerons aren't much better, again using simple plastic guides. In both dimensions there tends to be a lot of slop and friction that effectively masks what little stability the ship has. In the Zuni, the side stick is connected to an all-flying tailplane, which regardless of its demand for fine touch has a lot of inertia of its own. * I flew an HP-18 once with the side stick, and converted it to center stick before I flew it again. * I anticipate that we might see a resurgence in side stick adoption once fly by wire becomes more common. I figure we'll see a hybrid approach in which the control stick has a limited direct mechanical connection, say to the outboard flaperons and half of the elevator. That will be supplemented by electronic connections to inboard flaperons, spanwise camber control, and the other elevator half. Such a system would offer advanced control features including auto flaps, auto speed-to-fly, and perhaps even auto thermal centering, but still have enough control for a safe landing if the electronic stuff fails. Thanks, Bob Kuykendall https://www.facebook.com/HP-24-Sailp...t-200931354951 www.hpaircraft.com |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes
I transitioned to Diana SZD-56 (identical side-stick to Diana 2) with 1500 hours. Gimbaled stick: no slide. It’s all in the wrist. Everyone asks how long does it take to get used to it? Answer: No time: it’s completely natural. Nobody believes me. But the stick is where my hand is. Central stick would be perfect if one’s hand came out of his fly.
“I like flying with a side stick. It feels natural.“ -Mike Opitz Feb 19 Switching hands? I’m not ambidextrous, but I have no trouble twiddling knobs with my left hand (or operating gear, spoilers or flapperons). And without a central stick, the closer instrument panel is very handy, so to speak. Left-handers? While sitting, rest your right hand on your right thigh, and left on left. Now pretend you’re flying with a gimbaled side-stick on your right. Ask your left hand to mimic the motions of your right. It’s as if your hands were connected by a parallelogram. “…no big deal with the stick in my left hand. -Mike Opitz Feb 19 “…I'd like to check out a Diana 2 for comfort and forward visibility and wonder if cricked necks could be a problem.” -Martin Gregorie Feb 19 Diana’s seating is almost too comfortable! Isn’t there an FAR against napping at altitude? Diana’s transparent canopy goes nearly to the nose, so forward visibility is as good as it can be. I never had a cricked neck, but looking up was a bit awkward. So I spring-loaded the headrest pivot. Now when I look up at clouds (or the rare glider temporarily above me) the headrest swivels down and then pops back up for cruising. Perfect! -Jack Wyman |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
Why are side sticks unpopular in sailplanes
I also flew a gimbaled side-stick for 8 years in a Millennium ultralight sailplane. It was so smooth, natural and comfortable I looked for a sailplane with the same arrangement. But alas, all I could find were clunky setups with sliding sticks. No wonder side sticks get a bad rap in our little world.. The center stick is OK, side stick is better, more natural.
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Neat Video Shows Two Passenger Jets Landing Side-By-Side at the Same Time | Miloch | Aviation Photos | 0 | June 14th 16 04:28 AM |
HP310 and hx4705 - side by side, first impression | Darryl Ramm | Soaring | 0 | February 22nd 09 02:42 AM |
Saturn V S-IC (first) stage are placed side by side prior to commencement of the mating of the two stages 6416485.jpg | [email protected] | Aviation Photos | 0 | April 12th 07 01:28 AM |
For Mitchell Holman, if you want them... - F-15 & F-16 on pedestals WPAFB side by side.JPG (1/1) | Blue Oval/Dan Edwards | Aviation Photos | 4 | January 19th 07 01:19 AM |
Is That a Resistor Wired Between the Hot Side and the Switch Side of the Solenoid? | jls | Owning | 3 | April 11th 04 04:55 PM |