If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#231
|
|||
|
|||
"Martin Hotze" wrote in message ... "Gig 601XL Builder" wr.giacona@coxDOTnet wrote: Your putting the effect before the cause. Could it be that "it simply doesn't appear on the radar of too many people" because it costs to damn much to do it thier? no. and nobody I talked to had the slightest idea about the costs. for sure they meant that it isn't the cheapest hobby, but compared to skiing (with all the associated costs) or golfing or other things it is still within reach (I made my private pilot license here when I was an office clerk for the social security administration with an average paycheck). #m -- http://www.hotze.priv.at/album/aviation/caution.jpg Well France has a long tradition of aviation even rivaling the US. What happened that knocked it of the radar if it wasn't cost. I know cost has hammered it pretty good here in the US. El Dorado AR a town of 25,000 in a county with about 50,000 has two airports ELD and F43. When I was growing up there were three FBOs that rented, chartered and all that fun stuff. When I got my PPL in 79-80 there were two and the one I used had three aircraft that stayed rented on the weekend and were pretty well used during the week. I think the other FBO had two. Then I went off to school for 4 years. When I returned they were all gone there have been a couple try to start up since then and they have all failed miserably. We had no real economic down turn here and we still have more than our fair share of Doctors, Lawyers and Oil Men. THe two things that killed it were the cost of AVGAS and Insurance. |
#232
|
|||
|
|||
Decimated since when? Post a reference statistic and time as a starting
point. Well, let's start with the fact that France's efforts at flight pre-date our own. Is 1903-ish far enough back for you? What taxes particularly are you referring to? Avgas taxes. The price of avgas in France (as the subject of this thread states) has now exceeded $7.50 per gallon, solely as a result of their very aggressive tax policies. Where does France get its processed petroleum products and what factors make the cost of avgas what it is? I presume that they get their petroleum from the same worldwide supply as the U.S. -- yet our avgas is "only" $3.30-ish per gallon. You just pulled thos whole argument out of your ass, dear, and while it might make an interesting thesis for a classroom debate, you should quit defending it unless you have a lot of facts to back up your assertions. As opposed to your well-thought out, carefully crafted counter-arguments? ;-) The facts are clear. It is your unwillingness to accept them that is puzzling. Why -- especially in an aviation forum -- are you (and Larry, Martin, and a couple of other folks) defending a foreign tax system that more than DOUBLES the price of aviation? This makes no sense to me. And why are people required to choose aviation as a pursuit based on the population of their country? They're not. But based on the population of France, there should be many times more pilots -- ESPECIALLY given their proud heritage of flight. I'm still waiting for an answer: If it's NOT the outrageous cost of avgas that has nearly killed general aviation in France, what is it? Why, in the land of Bleriot and Saint-Exupery, are there so (relatively) few men and women feeling the call to the skies, if NOT for price considerations? -- Jay Honeck Iowa City, IA Pathfinder N56993 www.AlexisParkInn.com "Your Aviation Destination" |
#233
|
|||
|
|||
"Stella Starr" wrote in message news:8bP9e.5414$r53.3247@attbi_s21... Jay Honeck wrote: Show me one statistic that disproves that aviation in France hasn't been decimated by the French government's predatory aviation gas tax strategy. Decimated since when? Post a reference statistic and time as a starting point. What taxes particularly are you referring to? Where does France get its processed petroleum products and what factors make the cost of avgas what it is? You just pulled thos whole argument out of your ass, dear, and while it might make an interesting thesis for a classroom debate, you should quit defending it unless you have a lot of facts to back up your assertions. You obviously missed the post with the extensive supporting evidence. |
#234
|
|||
|
|||
"Larry Dighera" wrote in message ... On Thu, 21 Apr 2005 13:55:25 GMT, "Jay Honeck" wrote in hhO9e.5889$c24.2848@attbi_s72:: TRAINS? High speed (180 mph) European trains are preferable to airline transportation within Europe. No security lines nor baggage waiting, and you can walk around and eat first class cuisine en route. It's possible to travel in your sleep on slower European trains, save the cost of a night's lodging, and arrive at your destination rested and ready. If you haven't tried it, don't knock it. I tried it, they were on strike, again and again and again and again. |
#235
|
|||
|
|||
What is going to happen
to cigarette smoking in Iowa if (when?) the legislature double the tax on a pack of smokes Iowa smokers will purchase out of state. The aviation parallel, of course, is simply to witness how many foreign-born pilots come to America to train -- to escape predatory taxation. I'm all for people quitting smoking, but adding 60-some cents per pack tax -- overnight -- seems like a great way to (a) cut tax income for the State and (b) create a thriving black market. Heck, I remember in the 1970s my parents would pay a trucker friend to pick up 50 cartons of cigarettes whenever he drove through Virginia (?) because they cost a whole dollar less (per carton!) then they did in Wisconsin. With this proposed tax, the difference could be as much as $12 per carton! Social engineering through taxation -- even well-meaning efforts -- almost always seems to have unforeseen consequences. -- Jay Honeck Iowa City, IA Pathfinder N56993 www.AlexisParkInn.com "Your Aviation Destination" |
#236
|
|||
|
|||
High speed (180 mph) European trains are preferable to airline
transportation within Europe. No security lines nor baggage waiting, That's interesting. You would think after the train bombings in Spain, there would be as much -- or more -- security efforts expended on them? -- Jay Honeck Iowa City, IA Pathfinder N56993 www.AlexisParkInn.com "Your Aviation Destination" |
#237
|
|||
|
|||
|
#238
|
|||
|
|||
Martin Hotze wrote: "Jay Honeck" wrote: It's the relative PROPORTION of pilots, aircraft, and airports that is out of whack in France. If aviation weren't dead in France, they should have the same PROPORTION of pilots, aircraft and airports as the US. they apparently have other priorities. They have faster trains, for example. How does this compare with the US? We have some fast trains too but we can't get them to stop so they have been mothballed for a while. |
#239
|
|||
|
|||
Jay Honeck wrote:
Okay, Stefan -- the ball is in your court. Show me one statistic that disproves that aviation in France hasn't been decimated by the French government's predatory aviation gas tax strategy. Ok. Let's start at the basics. First, statistics can't prove or disprove anything. Carefully done (which few are), they can show correlations. But interpreting those correlations is science (and an art) in itself. So you started with the wrong question in the first place. Then, to correct a misinformation: Avgas is not only taxed in France. It is similiarly taxed throughout Europe. So if you want to bash somebody, then you must bash whole Europe. (Yes, in this case, generalisation is allowed.) I'm aware that bashing France is very popular among certain Americans these days, but it is as it is. Third, to correct another misinformation: It's not only avgas which is taxed, but all oil products which is used for engines. (Jet fuel is an exeption, but this is a long story. So let's forget this for the moment.) Yes, auto gas is also highly taxed. But, surprize surprize, car traffic isn't dead at all throughout Europe. Which already is that proof you asked for. Yes, "grassroot aviation" as you name it is very expensive in Europe. Operating a light single under VFR costs about twice what it does in the USA. But is it because of the taxation? To a small degree. Gas tax contribute approximately one quarter to the hourly rate. Frankly, as I said, private aviation is expensive. But somebody with an average income can afford it if he really wants. (Unemployed are another story, of course, but I guess they can't afford it in the USA, either.) I'm not aware of anybody who really wanted to fly and couldn't do it because of the price. I do know some who fly fewer hours, though. So why is there less GA in Europe than in the USA? (It undoubtedly is less.) First, as others mentioned, there are very few occations where GA for transprotation reasons makes sense. Distances are smaller, so usually train and/or car is not only cheaper but actually faster, too, and if you really want to go far, you take an airline. So GA (that grassroot GA, not biz jets) is a purely recreational activity. And now comes the bummer: There are actually people out there who are not interested in learning to fly! They just don't care! Yes, it's shocking, I know, but it's the way it is. But then, it's maybe not that surprizing at all: In Europe, nobody cares for baseball, either, but everybody talks about soccer! Can you imagine this? Or, back to aviation: In many European countries, soaring is more popular than motorized flight, and not for financial reasons. Other countries, other cultures, other hobbies. (Having lived for some time abroad helps a lot in accepting this.) So, to summarize: Yes, there is fewer GA in Europe. But even if you would wipe all avgas taxes, there wouldn't be more. Stefan |
#240
|
|||
|
|||
Jay Honeck wrote:
As a fellow Iowan you can relate to this example: What is going to happen to cigarette smoking in Iowa if (when?) the legislature double the tax on a pack of smokes, as they are debating this very week? Predictions range from a 13% to 26% drop in smoking. Knowing a couple of smokers myself, my prediction is they will just mumble somewhat, then rise their tobacco budget and continue to smoke. Stefan |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Soaring near Paris, France (Not Texas :-) | [email protected] | Soaring | 17 | November 13th 04 06:39 PM |
News from France | HECTOP | Piloting | 12 | April 1st 04 01:16 AM |
Russia joins France and Germany | captain! | Military Aviation | 12 | September 9th 03 09:56 AM |
France Bans the Term 'E-Mail' | bsh | Military Aviation | 38 | July 26th 03 03:18 PM |
"France downplays jet swap with Russia" | Mike | Military Aviation | 8 | July 21st 03 05:46 AM |