If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
Udo Rumpf wrote:
I fly with a Dittle Radio. If the radio is on but I do not talk, my 7AH 12V battery lasts about 4.5 hour with the usual LNav, logger and 1530 Ipaq. The battery will read about 11.8 volts after that time. At that point if I make a call on the radio the chances are I will not be heard unless I am close to the field. That is due in large part the hand held radios seem not to do very well when it comes to receiving a call from a radio with lower battery power. You didn't say which Dittel, but the brochure for the one I looked (FSG 2T) indicated plenty of power (5 watts) at 11 volts. Perhaps yours is an older model, but even @ 2 watts (like the Becker 4201 and Microair), the range would drop off only about 40% compared the nominal 5 watts at 13.75 volts. It's possible you have a problem not related to the voltage; e.g., maybe the voltage is dropping well below the 11.8 volts when the transmitter is keyed, or the radio is not functioning within specifications. -- Change "netto" to "net" to email me directly Eric Greenwell Washington State USA |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
Paul Remde wrote:
Hi David, You crack me up. I highly recommend 12V systems in gliders. You can save yourself a lot of money and hassle by using 12V batteries. You want me to be like Mike/Strike and put in multiple 12 volt batteries in hopes of getting enough juice to run a panel? After a while, he'll figure out that switching batteries glitches his FR, computer, and radio, so he starts throwing in the monster capacitors, the power Shottkies, the microprocessor-controlled reed relays, and all the other garbage people use to try to get around the problems. Seems like when people try to be cheap and lazy, it ends up costing them time and money in the long run. It's one of those false economies type of things. My little 14 volt tail battery (singular) powers the panel just fine even after being cold-soaked at 18 grand for 5 hours. In fact, at the end of the flight, it delivers more juice to the panel than people flying around with 20 A-H of batteries have at take off. Been running a FR for about six years, and haven't had a single glitch in the data in all that time. If you have some actual information about why running undervoltage batteries is such a great idea, I'd like to hear it, but you really haven't offered anything but personal opinion with no facts to back it up. The design of radios has changed a lot in recent years. Good radios don't require 14V batteries. Low cost and old radios do prefer 14V power. Really? You need to immediately contact the German manufacturers and share your revelations with them. Since you know more about the radios than they do, they'll be happy to correct all the wrong information in their manuals. If you should happen to actually read the manuals, you'll see they all have nominal input voltages of 13.8 volts, just like always, but since you're so much smarter than they are, you can rewrite the manuals for them. Obviously, they all have no idea what they're talking about, since they're only the ones who designed the radios. Dave |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
I fly with a Dittle Radio. If the radio is on but I do not talk, my 7AH 12V battery lasts about 4.5 hour with the usual LNav, logger and 1530 Ipaq. The battery will read about 11.8 volts after that time. At that point if I make a call on the radio the chances are I will not be heard unless I am close to the field. That is due in large part the hand held radios seem not to do very well when it comes to receiving a call from a radio with lower battery power. You didn't say which Dittel, but the brochure for the one I looked (FSG 2T) indicated plenty of power (5 watts) at 11 volts. Perhaps yours is an older model, but even @ 2 watts (like the Becker 4201 and Microair), the range would drop off only about 40% compared the nominal 5 watts at 13.75 volts. It's possible you have a problem not related to the voltage; e.g., maybe the voltage is dropping well below the 11.8 volts when the transmitter is keyed, or the radio is not functioning within specifications. Eric Greenwell I have a 720A Dittle radio Power requirements; Receive .1 - .4 amps Transmit (tone) 1.4 amps (.8 amps unmodulated) The 11.8 volts I was referring to is before transmit. If I remember correctly when the battery is fully charged and I hit the transmit button the voltage drops from 12.7 to 12.2. Udo |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
"David Kinsell" wrote in message ... Paul Remde wrote: Hi David, You crack me up. I highly recommend 12V systems in gliders. You can save yourself a lot of money and hassle by using 12V batteries. You want me to be like Mike/Strike and put in multiple 12 volt batteries in hopes of getting enough juice to run a panel? After a while, he'll figure out that switching batteries glitches his FR, computer, and radio, so he starts throwing in the monster capacitors, the power Shottkies, the microprocessor-controlled reed relays, and all the other garbage people use to try to get around the problems. Seems like when people try to be cheap and lazy, it ends up costing them time and money in the long run. It's one of those false economies type of things. My little 14 volt tail battery (singular) powers the panel just fine even after being cold-soaked at 18 grand for 5 hours. In fact, at the end of the flight, it delivers more juice to the panel than people flying around with 20 A-H of batteries have at take off. Been running a FR for about six years, and haven't had a single glitch in the data in all that time. If you have some actual information about why running undervoltage batteries is such a great idea, I'd like to hear it, but you really haven't offered anything but personal opinion with no facts to back it up. The design of radios has changed a lot in recent years. Good radios don't require 14V batteries. Low cost and old radios do prefer 14V power. Really? You need to immediately contact the German manufacturers and share your revelations with them. Since you know more about the radios than they do, they'll be happy to correct all the wrong information in their manuals. If you should happen to actually read the manuals, you'll see they all have nominal input voltages of 13.8 volts, just like always, but since you're so much smarter than they are, you can rewrite the manuals for them. Obviously, they all have no idea what they're talking about, since they're only the ones who designed the radios. Dave I don't have a manual for my Becker AR3201 so I had a look on the manufacturer's website for the current equivalent model and found this: http://www.becker-avionics.com/product/files/ar4201.pdf The top of page 2 states: Supply Voltage: 12.4 - 15.1 V Emergency Supply Voltage: 10.0 V I am now confused ! Please can you explain what you mean by nominal input voltage - is that the average of the maximum and the minimum ? Any idea what is meant by Emergency Supply Voltage? Regards, John Wilton |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
Eric Greenwell wrote:
It's possible you have a problem not related to the voltage; e.g., maybe the voltage is dropping well below the 11.8 volts when the transmitter is keyed, or the radio is not functioning within specifications. Many of us use the LNAV battery voltage screen to check batteries (I assume the CAI 302 and other vario/flight computers offer the same thing). That seems to be pretty accurate and has the advantage of reading the voltage at the instrument where it counts, not at the battery before current must traverse small diameter wiring, corroded connectors, etc., with subsequent loss in voltage. BUT...one must key the radio mike and hold it down for several seconds (don't everyone do this at once on the local glider frequency) to get an updated reading for the voltage under full transmit load. That's nearly always lower. I've never checked to see whether the LNAV readout takes a while to register the new voltage or whether the battery actually sags after several seconds under load. I'm not sure it matters since few pilots seem to be able to limit their tranmissions to less than 5 seconds, though. Chip Bearden |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
Hi David,
I think your observations are interesting. One part that is interesting is that you talk about how so many pilots that use 12V systems are having problems. I have heard from both 12V and 14V advocates that have problems with their batteries. Like you, I have never had any problems with my batteries. I use 12V batteries. I think that the majority of "battery problems" are owner induced. It is difficult to remember when you purchased a battery. Most people naturally underestimate the age of their batteries. I think many pilots are flying with old batteries that have not been cared for and then they complain about them. I take care of my batteries. I don't let them sit for more than 3 months without recharging, I charge them before flying, I replace them every 2 years. Every time I get a new battery I put the date on it so that I will know when to replace it. I don't want a battery failure during a record flight or contest flight - or any flight for that matter. I stock a lot of Power-Sonic batteries for sale to glider pilots. My calendar reminds me to charge them every 3 months so they will not be damaged. Many pilots fly with 12V systems and we really are very happy with them. People can hear our radio transmissions from very far away and we are heard clearly. People who take care of their 14V systems will also have good results. They may truly have a few more watts of transmit power. To me the issues involved with 14V systems are not worth the extra small percentage of transmit power. Many glider pilots agree with me that 12V systems are great. Many glider pilots prefer 14V systems. I think it will always be that way. Issues with 14V systems. - Most glider battery compartments are designed to hold 12V batteries so it is difficult to secure a 14V battery well. Radio manufacturers make extremely rugged and easy to use battery boxes for 12V batteries, but 14V batteries don't fit into them. - It is difficult to match 12V and 2V batteries well so that they charge equally. I have tried running 14V systems in my gliders in the past. I found that the 2V battery was completely dead at the end of every soaring season. That is the main reason I switched to 12V systems. - 14V chargers are more difficult to find and more expensive. After you invest in one and later come to the conclusions that many of us have (that 12V systems are fine) you will throw away your expensive 14V charger and invest in a 12V charger. I find your comment about German radio manufacturers to be funny. They all sell 12V batteries and battery boxes. So they are endorsing the use of 12V batteries. They must agree with me (and many other glider pilots) that 12V systems are acceptable and, dare I say it... preferable. Uh Oh... I just top posted! (my preference) Good Soaring, Paul Remde "David Kinsell" wrote in message ... Paul Remde wrote: Hi David, You crack me up. I highly recommend 12V systems in gliders. You can save yourself a lot of money and hassle by using 12V batteries. You want me to be like Mike/Strike and put in multiple 12 volt batteries in hopes of getting enough juice to run a panel? After a while, he'll figure out that switching batteries glitches his FR, computer, and radio, so he starts throwing in the monster capacitors, the power Shottkies, the microprocessor-controlled reed relays, and all the other garbage people use to try to get around the problems. Seems like when people try to be cheap and lazy, it ends up costing them time and money in the long run. It's one of those false economies type of things. My little 14 volt tail battery (singular) powers the panel just fine even after being cold-soaked at 18 grand for 5 hours. In fact, at the end of the flight, it delivers more juice to the panel than people flying around with 20 A-H of batteries have at take off. Been running a FR for about six years, and haven't had a single glitch in the data in all that time. If you have some actual information about why running undervoltage batteries is such a great idea, I'd like to hear it, but you really haven't offered anything but personal opinion with no facts to back it up. The design of radios has changed a lot in recent years. Good radios don't require 14V batteries. Low cost and old radios do prefer 14V power. Really? You need to immediately contact the German manufacturers and share your revelations with them. Since you know more about the radios than they do, they'll be happy to correct all the wrong information in their manuals. If you should happen to actually read the manuals, you'll see they all have nominal input voltages of 13.8 volts, just like always, but since you're so much smarter than they are, you can rewrite the manuals for them. Obviously, they all have no idea what they're talking about, since they're only the ones who designed the radios. Dave |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
What "Dittel" Radio?
I hear this very commonly that "I have a Dittel" radio.....and I'm sure most people "assume" (and we all know what that means) that a "Dittel" radio is a "Walter Dittel" radio .....If it's an ATR (Dittel) of any kind then it is an "AVIONIC DITTEL" which is far from the "WALTER DITTEL" radio is all respects, quality, design, function and format.......No question the Walter Dittel radio's are among the very best ever produced for glider use....and a Walter Dittel (current models) radio draws and operates on lower current than nearly all the rest, operating 100% even well below 11 volts. Voltage (level) isn't however the only criteria, you have to have Amps (Capacity) also.... Always question your voltmeter as well.......if you are relying on the voltmeter in an L/Nav or for that matter, in any flight computer or even a separate voltmeters you are reading what that voltmeter (was) calibrated to....and often they are misleading, you can also have volts and not capacity...so though the voltmeter may show a higher value at idle, when loaded, transmitting for instance, with a low capacity battery source you will lose voltage quickly. Also, voltage at the meter (Voltmeter in computer or otherwise) may not be the same voltage at the transmitter......cable size, cable length, fuses, circuit breakers, all have a diminishing effect on available current and voltage at the final source (Radio). And without enough amperage capacity the voltage at the radio may be too low to Tx even though at lower voltage the Rx will be OK. As to others receiving your transmissions, it will make no difference if they are using a cheaper handheld radio or the best panle mounted receiver .....radio transmissions are either good or bad....and battery voltage will have very little to do with Tx range or the receivers ability on the other end.....if you have a low voltage, too low for the transmitter it will normally come off as a garbled to whatever receiver gets your signal. Finally, some radios are more voltage sensitive than others, and won't operate fully at too low a voltage, where others can, and of course some draw more current on standby than others. Most people "assume" that because a radio has a very low standby current requirement, that it will be much easier on batteries, Standby currents are almost always very low on most radios we would commonly use in gliders since few if any have bright LED displays or need to run warm like older tube radios did, and "most" will draw very similar currents on Tx, as long as their output power is similar..so if you get High Tx power ratings, you will also get high current requirements in your choice of radios....for our purposes, even 1 watt (carrier) transmitters will be more than enough providing your antenna is good and proper. Finally..since most better radios will operate at reasonable low (and high) voltages I suggest using 12V battery set-ups over 14 Volts.....providing you are using the same physical size (lead and acid) since in the 12V set-up you will be able to carry a larger capacity battery (Amp hours)..also if you feed the radio and other equipment at higher voltage, the capacity (use)(((amps))) will be drawn at a higher rate as well....meaning the battery will be drained more quickly at higher voltage.and though it has further to fall to get to the critical level than the lower voltage set, it will fall quicker.and with any battery, once it gets used and the capacity becomes lower, it will fall very, very fast to where it is unusable. I hope my explanations are correct and not too rambling..... Tim Wings & Wheels www.wingsandwheels.com I fly with a Dittle Radio. If the radio is on but I do not talk, my 7AH 12V battery lasts about 4.5 hour with the usual LNav, logger and 1530 Ipaq. The battery will read about 11.8 volts after that time. At that point if I make a call on the radio the chances are I will not be heard unless I am close to the field. That is due in large part the hand held radios seem not to do very well when it comes to receiving a call from a radio with lower battery power. I have made it a habit of switching to the reserve battery for my final glide and use this battery again the next day while I charge up the other one over night. I had an experience recently whereby heaved in the cockpit. I tried to make a call, that I would land in about 1/2 hour. I needed a bucket of hot water and clean closing. I was not received as I forgot to switch the battery. Lucky for me my call was being relayed and my wife was ready with the goods. Regards Udo |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
"Tim Mara" wrote in message ... What "Dittel" Radio? I hear this very commonly that "I have a Dittel" radio.....and I'm sure most people "assume" (and we all know what that means) that a "Dittel" radio is a "Walter Dittel" radio .....If it's an ATR (Dittel) of any kind then it is an "AVIONIC DITTEL" which is far from the "WALTER DITTEL" radio is all respects, quality, design, function and format.......No question the Walter Dittel radio's are among the very best ever produced for glider use....and a Walter Dittel (current models) radio draws and operates on lower current than nearly all the rest, operating 100% even well below 11 volts. Voltage (level) isn't however the only criteria, you have to have Amps (Capacity) also.... Always question your voltmeter as well.......if you are relying on the voltmeter in an L/Nav or for that matter, in any flight computer or even a separate voltmeters you are reading what that voltmeter (was) calibrated to....and often they are misleading, you can also have volts and not capacity...so though the voltmeter may show a higher value at idle, when loaded, transmitting for instance, with a low capacity battery source you will lose voltage quickly. Also, voltage at the meter (Voltmeter in computer or otherwise) may not be the same voltage at the transmitter......cable size, cable length, fuses, circuit breakers, all have a diminishing effect on available current and voltage at the final source (Radio). And without enough amperage capacity the voltage at the radio may be too low to Tx even though at lower voltage the Rx will be OK. As to others receiving your transmissions, it will make no difference if they are using a cheaper handheld radio or the best panle mounted receiver ....radio transmissions are either good or bad....and battery voltage will have very little to do with Tx range or the receivers ability on the other end.....if you have a low voltage, too low for the transmitter it will normally come off as a garbled to whatever receiver gets your signal. Finally, some radios are more voltage sensitive than others, and won't operate fully at too low a voltage, where others can, and of course some draw more current on standby than others. Most people "assume" that because a radio has a very low standby current requirement, that it will be much easier on batteries, Standby currents are almost always very low on most radios we would commonly use in gliders since few if any have bright LED displays or need to run warm like older tube radios did, and "most" will draw very similar currents on Tx, as long as their output power is similar..so if you get High Tx power ratings, you will also get high current requirements in your choice of radios....for our purposes, even 1 watt (carrier) transmitters will be more than enough providing your antenna is good and proper. Finally..since most better radios will operate at reasonable low (and high) voltages I suggest using 12V battery set-ups over 14 Volts.....providing you are using the same physical size (lead and acid) since in the 12V set-up you will be able to carry a larger capacity battery (Amp hours)..also if you feed the radio and other equipment at higher voltage, the capacity (use)(((amps))) will be drawn at a higher rate as well....meaning the battery will be drained more quickly at higher voltage.and though it has further to fall to get to the critical level than the lower voltage set, it will fall quicker.and with any battery, once it gets used and the capacity becomes lower, it will fall very, very fast to where it is unusable. I hope my explanations are correct and not too rambling..... Tim Wings & Wheels www.wingsandwheels.com Tim, your post is both enlightening and, as usual, very helpful. It leads me to think that transceivers have different power demand characteristics than varios and glide computers. Might not this lead to two different battery packs, one optimized for the high current demand of transceivers and one optimized for the low current demand of varios and glide computers? Bill Daniels |
#30
|
|||
|
|||
I don't think so......a "good" battery should easily meet the demands we as
glider owners and pilots might have....you'll find most variometers and flight computers as well as radios have quite wide voltage ranges and as radios typically are happy at about 11-15 volts and most variometers can handle quite well even wider ranges, typically from 9-16 volts a single "good" battery should work nicely....having a back-up for the minimum essential like the 9v battery back-up offered on Borgelt B-40's is a nice extra reserve to get you home......but aside from that, if you are having more than the very occasional main battery failure you probably just need to replace the old battery if it's getting weak, or up the AH capacity of the battery to a larger size...I am a very firm believer of the KISS principal... good luck and best regards Tim Wings & Wheels www.wingsandwheels.com "Bill Daniels" wrote in message ... Tim, your post is both enlightening and, as usual, very helpful. It leads me to think that transceivers have different power demand characteristics than varios and glide computers. Might not this lead to two different battery packs, one optimized for the high current demand of transceivers and one optimized for the low current demand of varios and glide computers? Bill Daniels |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Battery Question | [email protected] | Soaring | 19 | September 15th 05 01:38 AM |
Batteries, charger for Yaesu handheld - NiCad or NiMH? | David Herman | Owning | 10 | November 7th 04 04:30 PM |
14 Volt Gel Cell? | Joe Allbritten | Soaring | 32 | May 11th 04 01:37 AM |
Icom A5 Battery Tester ?? | Harry Gordon | Piloting | 5 | January 10th 04 01:29 PM |
Battery life...how to test? | Jim Kelly | Soaring | 2 | July 11th 03 09:12 PM |