If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Discus verus Discus 2, LS8, ASW 28
Kilo Charlie wrote:
"Eric Greenwell" wrote in message news:BfY_g.3453$PA3.2721@trndny04... Neither does the ASW 28 canopy. Starting with the ASH 26, Schleicher has incorporated a Roeger hook or equivalent in it's gliders. I believe the LS8 has also has one, or DG has made one available for it as a retrofit. Eric Greenwell - Washington State, USA Not sure what a Roeger hook is but the LS-8 has a spring loaded mechanism at the front of the canopy which releases and at the same time a clamp at the back of the canopy that latches resulting in the canopy getting blown up at the nose and over the back. Sounds like a much better way to exit than anything else I've heard of.....other than an ejection seat of course! From the DG website: "To avoid these situations [canopy not ejecting properly] Prof. Roeger of the Technical University Aachen many years ago invented a special hook, since named for him. After the emergency release the hook turns on the rear canopy frame and prevents it from moving back. The airstreams flowing into the cockpit cannot escape and therefore lifts the canopy, which rotates on the Roeger hook and forces the front of the canopy to lift off and depart rearwards over the tail fin. Such a Roeger hook has been a mandatory installation in all new sailplanes for some years. Great, problem solved." In addition, DG offers these "hooks" as for retrofit into their older gliders, now including the LS series. Good for them! I urge all pilots of older DG/LS gliders to install one soon - the cost for the kit is less than 200 Euro, according to DG's website, and installation relatively easy. -- Eric Greenwell - Washington State, USA Change "netto" to "net" to email me directly "Transponders in Sailplanes" on the Soaring Safety Foundation website www.soaringsafety.org/prevention/articles.html "A Guide to Self-launching Sailplane Operation" at www.motorglider.org |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Discus verus Discus 2, LS8, ASW 28
Marc Ramsey wrote:
Jack wrote: Enough already! How about the DG-303? You asking or suggesting? I'd like to see the DG-303 included in these comparisons. Jack |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Discus verus Discus 2, LS8, ASW 28
I've flown my Ventus 2C alongside the Discus 2, ASW-28, and LS-8, and
if I chose to go with the flapless crowd, my first choice would be the LS8/18, based upon its performance, cockpit ergonomics, ease of assembly, and bang for the buck. The LS-8s I fly with (against?) in Arizona -- at least four of them -- I've only been able to beat in high-speed glides. I think they are amazing sailplanes. But those three gliders are all close enough in quality and performance that if I were buying in the used market, I would take the first good value that came along. ~ted/2NO |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Discus verus Discus 2, LS8, ASW 28
Jack wrote:
Marc Ramsey wrote: Jack wrote: Enough already! How about the DG-303? You asking or suggesting? I'd like to see the DG-303 included in these comparisons. I owned a DG-303 Acro and raced it in standard class in a couple of regionals. I've also flown a Discus 1 and an ASW-24 on a number of occasions. The three gliders are almost indistinguishable in performance at equivalent wing loadings. I could usually outclimb a 24, and hold my own with a Discus. Above 80 knots (wet), a 24 was noticeably faster, I could usually stay with a Discus. In my opinion, the Discus is the nicest handling of the three, and the DG is a bit easier to fly well than the 24. The DG is the most comfortable of the three for me (5'11, 200 lbs, long legs), and has the best visibility. The gelcoat on the 303 is a lot better quality than what was used on the Discus and 24. You can get a used 303 for about the cost of a Discus or 24 that is twice the age. Where the newer standard class ships shine is at the higher end of the speed range, in 90+ knot head to head runs with D2s between thermals, I'd usually end up at the next one several hundred feet below. The difference was a bit less dramatic with the LS8 and ASW-28. I never felt any performance disadvantage at all relative to the Discus 1 or ASW-24. Marc |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Discus verus Discus 2, LS8, ASW 28
Marc Ramsey wrote: Jack wrote: Marc Ramsey wrote: Jack wrote: Enough already! How about the DG-303? You asking or suggesting? I'd like to see the DG-303 included in these comparisons. I owned a DG-303 Acro and raced it in standard class in a couple of regionals. I've also flown a Discus 1 and an ASW-24 on a number of occasions. The three gliders are almost indistinguishable in performance at equivalent wing loadings. Marc My sense after flying wingtip-to-wingtip on ridge and thermal with all of these ships (excpept the 303) over several years is that the variation in individual ships is way larger than the theoretical performance variation. In other words, there are probably some D2s that are WAY better than some LS8s; conversely, there are some LS8s that are way better than some D2s. Things like wing smoothness (Monday gliders), sealing, and CG seem to be much bigger factors than the basic aircraft. As an example, a friend of mine recently redid his ASW-27 wings; he found waviness approaching 6 thou in several areas. He profiled and smoothed down to less than 3 thou everywhere. If you believe Johnson's tests, 4 thou or so is the maximum acceptable to prevent peformance degredation. I will admit that it seems to me like a well flown D2a is the best of the bunch at cruise and climb (dolphin) flying, especially at high speed. However, over a long contest with some weak weather thrown in, I feel like my LS8 is just as good if not a little bit better. Then again, I might be biased :-) Erik Mann LS8-18 P3 |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Discus verus Discus 2, LS8, ASW 28
Uk handicaps
LS8 100 ASW28 100 Discus 2 100 Discus 98 DG303 98 ASW24 97 Interestingly the first 14 places in the last world championships were Discus 2 or LS8. First and third were LS8s. In the real world pilot capabilities are far more variable than glider performance. I have seen an ex world champion in a club class DG101 without water beat most standard class gliders in a competition. There is no substitute for skill. Nigel |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Discus verus Discus 2, LS8, ASW 28
It's not even winter yet in the Northern Hemisphere and we're already
starting the "which glider is best?" stuff. Variability among different serial numbers of the same glider is much less than it used to be but it's still there due to wing waviness, winglets, CG, sealing, etc. Probably more of a factor is the pilot, certainly in climb and even in cruise/pull ups to a certain extent. Based on comparison flying, if I were after the absolute best performance, I might slightly favor the Discus 2a--several of them have given me fits in thermals and I watched Chip Garner and a few other drivers do amazing things this summer. But I can't fit into one (I'm 6'3"). Moreover, I strongly prefer Schleicher's safety features (crashworthy cockpit, energy-absorbing landing gear) which is what pushed me in that direction nearly 15 years ago after a long love affair with LS. In considering used ships, gel coat condition should always be a major consideration, maybe more so than any differences among models. That said, based on my experience and just to keep the discussion going, I believe a good used ASW 24 with aftermarket winglets represents a great value. My ASW 24 with Hank Nixon's winglets will climb with nearly any glider and better than many (the stories about the '24's climb "problem" started in its pre-winglets life). And at Uvalde this summer carrying full water, I didn't give away much, if anything, at high speed to most other gliders [would that the same could be said about the piloting]. It's difficult to make absolute statements about performance because almost no one but a professional leech tucks in right behind another glider and locks on. If you're seriously considering any of the Discus 2, LS-8 or ASW 28, talk to the owners. Like the '24 and the original Discus, each of these has little things that will annoy you as well as remarkable performance and handling. Chip Bearden ASW 24 "JB" |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Discus verus Discus 2, LS8, ASW 28
At 21:36 22 October 2006, Roger wrote:
How do these two gliders compare to one another? Ah yes, winter is upon us. This sort of discussion seems to boil down to a lot of anectodal evidence from matching airspeed and glides and the such...out of curiousity I might try to query further into what your desires are. 1.) Money is no object...that extra point or two of L/D is worth thousands? 2,) Looking cool on the ground or in the trailer is a factor? 3.) How much is this bird going to get flown, or better yet...raced? 4.) John Cochrane has some excellent writing on how incremental improvements in piloting allows one to skip a generation of gliders and still keep up...is this a factor? I am not posting to hurl stones here...I spent endless hours comparing gliders before I bought my previous two. And I think analysis is important...but defining ones' needs is sometimes equally as significant. Has anyone generated a graph of cost/LD when comparing these ships? In today's market I would assume a fairly clean Discus is 1/2 the cost of a new ship. |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Discus verus Discus 2, LS8, ASW 28
Slightly off topic, but addresses your last point.
'Rollings Law of Price and Performance (for NEW gliders)' Performance varies with the square root of wing-span; price varies with the square of wing-span. At 00:06 24 October 2006, Stewart Kissel wrote: At 21:36 22 October 2006, Roger wrote: How do these two gliders compare to one another? Ah yes, winter is upon us. This sort of discussion seems to boil down to a lot of anectodal evidence from matching airspeed and glides and the such...out of curiousity I might try to query further into what your desires are. 1.) Money is no object...that extra point or two of L/D is worth thousands? 2,) Looking cool on the ground or in the trailer is a factor? 3.) How much is this bird going to get flown, or better yet...raced? 4.) John Cochrane has some excellent writing on how incremental improvements in piloting allows one to skip a generation of gliders and still keep up...is this a factor? I am not posting to hurl stones here...I spent endless hours comparing gliders before I bought my previous two. And I think analysis is important...but defining ones' needs is sometimes equally as significant. Has anyone generated a graph of cost/LD when comparing these ships? In today's market I would assume a fairly clean Discus is 1/2 the cost of a new ship. |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
Glider pricing
"Chris Rollings" wrote in message ... Slightly off topic, but addresses your last point. 'Rollings Law of Price and Performance (for NEW gliders)' Performance varies with the square root of wing-span; price varies with the square of wing-span. The first is aerodynamically correct. The second is market observation. The cost of materials varies by the weight of the bare airframe. All else like instruments are the same for all gliders. Labor for a given production technique probably related to surface area. The biggest determinant of the final price is production volume. Or, more correctly, the volume anticipated at the start of production. If a manufacturer knew from the start that the final production numbers would exceed say, 3000 gliders, investments in labor saving tooling would make sense. This, in turn, would increase the production run yet more since lower prices would eintice still more buyers. But of course, how do you know you are going to produce a lot of gliders? Bill Daniels |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Discus 2b cockpit comfort? | Jeremy Zawodny | Soaring | 11 | January 12th 04 08:03 PM |
[LBA] Schempp-Hirth - Discus bT - Discus | Frederic FUCHS | Soaring | 0 | September 17th 03 08:42 AM |
All Czech built Discus grounded | Paul | Soaring | 0 | September 14th 03 02:22 AM |
18m Discus | Burt Compton | Soaring | 2 | September 8th 03 10:52 AM |
Discus Wing question | John Galloway | Soaring | 6 | August 23rd 03 07:52 AM |