If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Fatal accident in Scotland
On 4 Sep, 16:02, Mark Dickson
wrote: The system of winch launch signalling, in the UK, was changed so that pilots had their fingers close to the release on take-off; not sticking two fingers up in the air. You are not meant to accept the cable until you are ready to launch, all fiddling complete; you accept the cable you are ready to go. Not meant to, no. However, I think there is another side: the cable should not be offered to the glider unless the launch can proceed immediately. All too often the cable is attached, then there is a short delay, then the deay gets longer, then the pilot gets distracted, then ... The old system ensured that when the launch started, the pilot had a had free. It may not have been in the right place, but at least it was guaranteed not to be reprogramming a GPS ... Ian |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Winch launch procedure and accidents
I learnt to glide after the new system was introduced. I have two hands and at the start of a winch launch I want one hand on the = release and the other on the joystick, so I have no free hand for signallin= g (at the all out stage) =20 I am happy either for someone external to signal, or as at happened when I = winched recently in France, to use the radio. I can also understand the use= of a wings level signal (for up slack), but this does not work when you ha= ve a glider full of water, which needs level wings prior to the start. Rory Newsgroup: rec.aviation.soaringSubject: Winch launch procedure and acci= dentsAuthor: Ian Date/Time: 15:20 04 September 2= 007 As I understand it, the British system was changed after accidents wher= e pilots accepted a cable without being ready to go and were winched off a= s a result of, for example, scratching their noses. __________________________________________________ _______________ The next generation of MSN Hotmail has arrived - Windows Live Hotmail http://www.newhotmail.co.uk= |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Winch launch procedure and accidents
On 4 Sep, 17:31, Rory O'Conor
wrote: I learnt to glide after the new system was introduced. I have two hands and at the start of a winch launch I want one hand on the = release and the other on the joystick, "On" the release? Eeek. People have had nasty accidents that way! Ian |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Winch launch procedure and accidents
Depends on your definition of 'on'. I have my fingers
'on' the release at the start of a winch lauch. By that I mean that I rest two straight fingers on the top of the release knob, either side of the cable. What I don't do is curl my fingers round it unless I need to pull it. At 19:01 04 September 2007, Ian wrote: On 4 Sep, 17:31, Rory O'Conor wrote: I learnt to glide after the new system was introduced. I have two hands and at the start of a winch launch I want one hand on the = release and the other on the joystick, 'On' the release? Eeek. People have had nasty accidents that way! Ian |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Winch launch procedure and accidents
FYI, quote from the BGA "SUPPLEMENT TO BGA ‘SAFE WINCH LAUNCHING’ LEAFLET" notes
for instructors: "If the wing drops on the ground the glider may rotate about the wing tip and cartwheel. If the wing drops in every hundredth launch, there will be one wing drop accident in 800 wing drop incidents. This is a recipe for complacency and indeed it is experienced pilots who have the majority of wing drop accidents. After the wing has dropped the cartwheel can be so rapid that no recovery by releasing or other means is possible. This hazard must be anticipated and pre-empted by conducting the launch with the left hand on the release, and releasing immediately if it is not possible to keep the wings level. Andrew Warbrick wrote: Depends on your definition of 'on'. I have my fingers 'on' the release at the start of a winch lauch. By that I mean that I rest two straight fingers on the top of the release knob, either side of the cable. What I don't do is curl my fingers round it unless I need to pull it. At 19:01 04 September 2007, Ian wrote: On 4 Sep, 17:31, Rory O'Conor wrote: I learnt to glide after the new system was introduced. I have two hands and at the start of a winch launch I want one hand on the = release and the other on the joystick, 'On' the release? Eeek. People have had nasty accidents that way! Ian |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Winch launch procedure and accidents
On Sep 4, 10:55 pm, ucsdcpc wrote:
FYI, quote from the BGA "SUPPLEMENT TO BGA 'SAFE WINCH LAUNCHING' LEAFLET" notes for instructors: "If the wing drops on the ground the glider may rotate about the wing tip and cartwheel. If the wing drops in every hundredth launch, there will be one wing drop accident in 800 wing drop incidents. This is a recipe for complacency and indeed it is experienced pilots who have the majority of wing drop accidents. After the wing has dropped the cartwheel can be so rapid that no recovery by releasing or other means is possible. This hazard must be anticipated and pre-empted by conducting the launch with the left hand on the release, and releasing immediately if it is not possible to keep the wings level. A timely quote. Please heed. I don't quite understand some of the discussion here. Things are very simple. You do not attach a cable to the glider until it is ready to fly. All checks complete, nothing left to do. (If you're still fiddling with the GPS at this point you're an idiot.) Then, "cable on please". You have one hand on the stick and the other holds the release. You will not have time to go feeling for the release if you need it. There is no way any launch could be violent enough that you'd pull the release accidently. Think about how hard you need to pull to operate the release, then try to imagine how a launch could be so rough that your arm could be moved enough to generate that same force against your will. Not going to happen. If, for any reason, you are no longer happy with proceeding with the launch while waiting for it to commence you pull the release. If a wing touches the ground you release instantly. I've seen four ground loops in the last month, each one because the pilot thought the glider would recover. Sometimes it will, sometime it won't. What the hell is the point in gambling on that? It takes all of a minute to reposition the glider and tug or winch cable. It's hard to see how you could screw up if you follow these simple procedures. I don't give a toss who invented them or why - they're safe, and that's all that matters to me. Dan |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Winch launch procedure and accidents
On 5 Sep, 01:31, Dan G wrote:
You do not attach a cable to the glider until it is ready to fly. All checks complete, nothing left to do. (If you're still fiddling with the GPS at this point you're an idiot.) Then, "cable on please". Which is fine in an ideal world. But it doesn't always work like that. Sometimes there are delays, and a safe system will take account of that possibility. You have one hand on the stick and the other holds the release. You will not have time to go feeling for the release if you need it. There is no way any launch could be violent enough that you'd pull the release accidently. Perhaps you always fly from nice, smooth, paved runways? It's hard to see how you could screw up if you follow these simple procedures. I don't give a toss who invented them or why - they're safe, and that's all that matters to me. It's when people start thinking that the rules will keep them safe that accidents happen. Ian |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Winch launch procedure and accidents
On Sep 5, 8:03 am, Ian wrote:
On 5 Sep, 01:31, Dan G wrote: You do not attach a cable to the glider until it is ready to fly. All checks complete, nothing left to do. Yes, precisely. I don't see any problems with that. I'll go further and state that I would need to be convinced that anything else was safer. Which is fine in an ideal world. But it doesn't always work like that. Sometimes there are delays, and a safe system will take account of that possibility. Er, what's the problem with releasing the cable if there's a delay? In what way isn't that a "safe system"? You have one hand on the stick and the other holds the release. You will not have time to go feeling for the release if you need it. That's my opinion, too. As an early solo neophyte who recently experienced my first low-level winch failure, heads down while groping for the cable release would have been too high a workload. In addition, there is a significant chance I would have grabbed the airbrake instead of the release. It's hard to see how you could screw up if you follow these simple procedures. I don't give a toss who invented them or why - they're safe, and that's all that matters to me. I'm interested in 1) if I follow those standard rules, what are the remaining potential problems and avoidance procedures 2) what's the relative probability and severity of problems with/ without hand on the release I suspect the (2) is the reason for the BGA selecting the current rules. The onus is firmly on anybody challenging the current rules to convince others that the rules should be changed. It's when people start thinking that the rules will keep them safe that accidents happen. True, but of course that has only tangential relevance to whether or not the rules are good. |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Winch launch procedure and accidents
"Dan G" wrote in message ups.com... You have one hand on the stick and the other holds the release. You will not have time to go feeling for the release if you need it. I am trying to think back, but with most (if not all) gliders I have flown this would not be practical because of the dash-mounted position of the release knob. I was taught that my left hand went behind (not on) the spoiler handle to guard it closed. Here it can prevent another type of launch accident and still be very close to the release knob. There is no way any launch could be violent enough that you'd pull the release accidently. I have had some pretty violent launches. Things get bumpy when you are rolling over grass on a single wheel at near-takeoff speeds. Vaughn |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Winch launch procedure and accidents
The issue might not be violence, per se, but more the quick acceleration of
the launch compresses the seat pillow, moving the pilot back. Unless you're on the ball, this can lead to unintended pull back on the stick. If your hand is on the release, you might release by mistake. I prefer to keep my knuckles on the release so I can easily reach it. "Vaughn Simon" wrote in message news "Dan G" wrote in message ups.com... You have one hand on the stick and the other holds the release. You will not have time to go feeling for the release if you need it. I am trying to think back, but with most (if not all) gliders I have flown this would not be practical because of the dash-mounted position of the release knob. I was taught that my left hand went behind (not on) the spoiler handle to guard it closed. Here it can prevent another type of launch accident and still be very close to the release knob. There is no way any launch could be violent enough that you'd pull the release accidently. I have had some pretty violent launches. Things get bumpy when you are rolling over grass on a single wheel at near-takeoff speeds. Vaughn |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Another fatal accident | Mike the Strike | Soaring | 0 | September 20th 06 11:50 PM |
Fatal accident in Italy | 2cernauta2 | Soaring | 1 | April 4th 06 05:50 PM |
Fatal accident near Wenatchee, WA | [email protected] | Soaring | 2 | June 27th 05 01:54 AM |
Pilot's 2nd Fatal Accident | Aardvark | Piloting | 44 | May 21st 04 02:34 PM |
Hawaii Fatal Accident | Rocky | Rotorcraft | 0 | July 25th 03 03:01 PM |