If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#81
|
|||
|
|||
New trainer from SZD Bielsko
"Sally W" wrote in message ... But surely only the ones with winch experience teach winch launching? So it's not an issue? And surely no-one goes from aerotow to winching without getting some instruction? I'm sure that it's a rare situation. Fortunately, there is a lot of good guidance on the web about winch proceedures from various national aero clubs and quite a few instructors who read this guidance. Bill Daniels |
#82
|
|||
|
|||
New trainer from SZD Bielsko
On Jun 26, 8:57 pm, "Bill Daniels" bildan@comcast-dot-net wrote:
"Sally W" wrote in message ... But surely only the ones with winch experience teach winch launching? So it's not an issue? And surely no-one goes from aerotow to winching without getting some instruction? I'm sure that it's a rare situation. I hope it's as rare as flying pigs. Fortunately, there is a lot of good guidance on the web about winch proceedures from various national aero clubs and quite a few instructors who read this guidance. And I'd hope the instructors have been doing a bit more than reading the Internet for guidance. |
#83
|
|||
|
|||
New trainer from SZD Bielsko
Bill Daniels wrote:
"Sally W" wrote in message ... But surely only the ones with winch experience teach winch launching? So it's not an issue? And surely no-one goes from aerotow to winching without getting some instruction? I'm sure that it's a rare situation. Fortunately, there is a lot of good guidance on the web about winch proceedures from various national aero clubs and quite a few instructors who read this guidance. As you know, the training of the majority of winch qualified pilots (i.e., those with a ground launch endorsement) here in the US consisted of pulling a rusty underpowered Gerhlein out from behind a hangar, plopping the transitioning pilot in the front seat of a nose hook equipped 2-33, then three flights: pilot follows instructor on controls, instructor follows pilot on controls, instructor signs off pilot, pilot flies a solo launch. There are several clubs that now use winches as their primary launch method, and they take instruction (and safety) much more seriously. But, much of the resistance to increased use of winches in the US comes as a reaction to these past (for the most part) "training" activities... Marc |
#84
|
|||
|
|||
New trainer from SZD Bielsko
On 26 Jun, 19:44, Cats wrote:
On Jun 26, 5:54 pm, Ian wrote: There is at least one large club in England which teaches this as the right way to winch launch. Then if they are still doing that, I suspect they are not following the latest BGA advice: http://www.gliding.co.uk/bgainfo/doc...hlaunching.pdf A document which I saw for the first time a couple of weeks ago. I was rather struck by this "There is no case of an airworthy glider being damaged by excessive airspeed on a winch launch which is why it is not listed as a hazard." which makes me wonder why it is imediately followed by this "If the speed is excessive near the ground, climb gently to several hundred feet and release, or signal if the excess speed is now moderate." If it's not a hazard, why do anything about it? Ian |
#85
|
|||
|
|||
New trainer from SZD Bielsko
On Tue, 26 Jun 2007 14:10:57 -0700, Ian
wrote: If it's not a hazard, why do anything about it? To avoid breaking the cable? Bye Andreas |
#86
|
|||
|
|||
New trainer from SZD Bielsko
"Ian" wrote in message ups.com... On 26 Jun, 19:44, Cats wrote: On Jun 26, 5:54 pm, Ian wrote: There is at least one large club in England which teaches this as the right way to winch launch. Then if they are still doing that, I suspect they are not following the latest BGA advice: http://www.gliding.co.uk/bgainfo/doc...hlaunching.pdf A document which I saw for the first time a couple of weeks ago. I was rather struck by this "There is no case of an airworthy glider being damaged by excessive airspeed on a winch launch which is why it is not listed as a hazard." which makes me wonder why it is imediately followed by this "If the speed is excessive near the ground, climb gently to several hundred feet and release, or signal if the excess speed is now moderate." If it's not a hazard, why do anything about it? Ian The "no case" statement just means don't take precipitous action if the airspeed is too high. Accidents have occured from pilot actions that were unwarranted. None have occured simply due to exceeding Vw by a small margin. Excessive speed near the ground means that acceleration and therefore the winch power is way too high. The pilot is advised to release and land ahead. However, both statements lead one to think that the winch is controlling airspeed which is difficult since the winch driver has no idea what the glilder airspeed is. If the winch is producing the right power, the pilot can, and should, control airspeed with pitch. The relationship of power and airspeed is exactly like an airplane. With fixed power, raising the nose will reduce airspeed, lowering it will cause airspeed to increase. The relationship between pilot and winch driver is exactly like that between a pilot and flight engineer where the engineer controls power and the pilot flies the airplane. Bill Daniels |
#87
|
|||
|
|||
New trainer from SZD Bielsko
On Jun 26, 10:10 pm, Ian wrote:
On 26 Jun, 19:44, Cats wrote: On Jun 26, 5:54 pm, Ian wrote: There is at least one large club in England which teaches this as the right way to winch launch. Then if they are still doing that, I suspect they are not following the latest BGA advice: http://www.gliding.co.uk/bgainfo/doc...hlaunching.pdf A document which I saw for the first time a couple of weeks ago. I was rather struck by this "There is no case of an airworthy glider being damaged by excessive airspeed on a winch launch which is why it is not listed as a hazard." which makes me wonder why it is imediately followed by this "If the speed is excessive near the ground, climb gently to several hundred feet and release, or signal if the excess speed is now moderate." If it's not a hazard, why do anything about it? Ian Because if you don't release the weak link is going to break, which leaves you in a launch failure situation rather than a releasing at a more moderate angle, which is preferable. A high-speed link break is not very comfortable (I had one last weekend, when the winch driver inexplicably floored the winch half way up a launch). Breaking the weak link is also a major PITA for those on the ground (we lost the strop+rings, which I believe is £££). RE the club we're not naming - amazingly I understand they've not had a winch launch accident, at least not recently. Other clubs have though. Dan |
#88
|
|||
|
|||
New trainer from SZD Bielsko
Ian wrote:
http://www.gliding.co.uk/bgainfo/doc...hlaunching.pdf A document which I saw for the first time a couple of weeks ago. I was rather struck by this "There is no case of an airworthy glider being damaged by excessive airspeed on a winch launch which is why it is not listed as a hazard." which makes me wonder why it is imediately followed by this "If the speed is excessive near the ground, climb gently to several hundred feet and release, or signal if the excess speed is now moderate." If it's not a hazard, why do anything about it? Ian I think the point being made is that no-one has yet proved it to be a hazard in practice by pulling the wings off, or more likely causing the tailplane to fail. However, if you read "Gliding" by Steve Longland (which is the book-form advanced BGA manual plus), you will see that flying beyond the max winch speed at some point takes the glider outside its design limits. Outside the limits no-one knows what will happen to the airframe. Maybe it'll be fine, maybe not (and the parts of the book about repeated stresses outside design limits leading to gradual though invisible deterioration, followed by catastrophic failure, give pause for thought). As I read the advice, if your only choice is to accept excessive speed or to accept something worse, then excessive speed is the safer choice. If you can do something safe rather than overspeed, then do the other thing! For example, from my experience driving a winch, I've seen numerous pilots rotate and then immediately start wagging the glider's tail (the UK signal for "too fast"). If you read about the physics of the launch, at this stage the loads on the glider are low, and overspeeding presents little or no hazard. The consequence is often (especially if the glider is climbing through a wind gradient) that if the driver reduces the speed, a few seconds later the glider is too slow - now that *is* proved to be dangerous. Experienced winch-launching pilots who I know are content to accept overspeeding in the first part (say 1/3) of the launch and wait for the speed to settle to the correct figure. If not (in the second 1/3 where the loads are increasing) they signal to slow down. If speed is too high in the top 1/3 (where the forces start to approach or exceed design limits) then it's goodbye to the cable - but at that point you have enough height to make a safe circuit so it's only an argument with the driver about your wasted launch fee and not a case of recovering your remains from the runway. If the speed is madly excessive (and I've had this happen to me a couple of times) then even signalling can be a problem. In that case, allowing the glider to "float" up to circuit height with little or no load on the airframe is the safest way of coping, followed by forcible re-education of the winch driver. |
#89
|
|||
|
|||
New trainer from SZD Bielsko
On 26 Jun, 22:40, Andreas Maurer wrote:
On Tue, 26 Jun 2007 14:10:57 -0700, Ian wrote: If it's not a hazard, why do anything about it? To avoid breaking the cable? Then it would be a hazard! Ian |
#90
|
|||
|
|||
New trainer from SZD Bielsko
On 26 Jun, 22:42, "Bill Daniels" bildan@comcast-dot-net wrote:
The relationship of power and airspeed is exactly like an airplane. With fixed power, raising the nose will reduce airspeed, lowering it will cause airspeed to increase. It's not alwaysthat simple, and depends a lot on the construction of the winch. It makes a big difference, for example, if it has a torque convertor as opposed to a fxed ratio gearbox or a fluid flywheel. You need to take account of the tension-speed relationships for both the winch and the glider. Ian (one time winch instructor) |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
the Oz 3 surface trainer | patrick mitchel | Home Built | 2 | May 15th 07 03:19 AM |
WTB Trainer | Roy Bourgeois | Soaring | 0 | June 25th 06 04:50 PM |
***XC-Trainer Offer*** | [email protected] | Soaring | 0 | August 24th 05 05:21 PM |
AMD Alarus IFR Trainer | H.P. | Owning | 0 | August 5th 04 07:10 PM |
AMD Alarus IFR Trainer | H.P. | Piloting | 0 | August 5th 04 07:10 PM |