If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
bad engine performance today
Today I was doing some touch and go's in a C152 with one of my
students to prepare for his first solo. It was a very hot day (35C), but density altitude was only 2500 or so. I noticed as we were climbing upwind, the plane was climbing very slowly, even right at Vy. The runway is very long (11,800 ft), but when we reached the opposite threshold, we were only about 500 AGL. Normally at the end of the threshold we are between 900 and 1000 AGL, and thats with switching to cruise climb after 500 AGL... Then when we got to downwind, my student pulled the power back to 2300 RPM (cruise) and we were only able to hold about about 70 knots (90 knots is normal). Just before this all happened, I was up with another student in a different plane (still a 152 but a different tail number), and the performance was about the same as it normally is. The thing that confuses me about all this, was how the engine RPM was perfectly normal. Full throttle was about 2500 which is where it normally is. Wouldn't an engine that is producing less power have less RPM's as long as it's a constant speed prop? I know it isn't a airspeed indicator problem because I could clearly notice a difference in ground speed from comparing the two flights. After the flight I went around the place to see if there was anything on the airframe that could have caused a lot of drag, but it all was normal. What could it have been? |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
bad engine performance today
buttman wrote
The thing that confuses me about all this, was how the engine RPM was perfectly normal. Full throttle was about 2500 which is where it normally is. Wouldn't an engine that is producing less power have less RPM's as long as it's a constant speed prop? I think that you probably meant to write "fixed pitch prop". Bob Moore |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
bad engine performance today
"buttman" wrote in message oups.com... I had a simular problem years ago in a 150. I didn't notice an RPM drop either, but it turned out the carb heat was out of adjustment. You might double check for a good indication of RPM drop in run up. For me it was one of the first really hot days of the summer, and although I did see some RPM drop on run up, the drop was more pronounced after the adjustment. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
bad engine performance today
Do they have the same prop?
|
#5
|
|||
|
|||
bad engine performance today
Tachometer malfunction- shows too high rpm? Just a guess. |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
bad engine performance today
On Apr 30, 8:43 am, "Snowbird" wrote:
Tachometer malfunction- shows too high rpm? Just a guess. Tachs often read low. In Canada we have to check them yearly, and they're allowed to be no more than 4% off in the middle of the cruise RPM range. Works out to 100 RPM at 2500. And the error is always on the low side: the tach will under-read because the magnets in it weaken with age. In flight training we have an exercise demonstrating reduced- performance takeoff. We cut the RPM by about 50, and the climb almost vanishes. It takes very little power loss in a light aircraft to hurt performance. But that would mean that the engine would have to be putting out less as well as the tach being off on the high side, which is unlikely. A more likely problem involves a pitot or static error that makes the airspeed indicator under-read; the pilot will keep the nose lower to get the Vy reading he's after so that climb suffers, and the ASI will be low in cruise. Groundspeed estimations need to be done with the stopwatch to prove it. I bet there's a static blockage. Dan |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
bad engine performance today
carb ice... 150's can be very susceptable.
Did you try to apply carb heat? |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
bad engine performance today
ktbr wrote:
carb ice... 150's can be very susceptable. Did you try to apply carb heat? @ 35º C ? |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
bad engine performance today
Were you leaning the engines before take-off. As it gets hotter this
can be more critical for best power. I haven't done the math but I suspect that warm you are getting close to a 5000 ft density alititude. As noted in the post it doesnt take much of an RPM change to affect performance so you might not notice on the tach. Also even small differences in the propeller can affect performance greatly Brian |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
bad engine performance today
"ManhattanMan" wrote ...
ktbr wrote: carb ice... 150's can be very susceptable. Did you try to apply carb heat? Carb heat, carb ice, etc. - none of these things make sense to me in this case. If two airplanes have the same engines and the same fixed-pitch props, and their tachs are reading accurately, then rpm should be an indication of power. In other words, it would seem to me that they cannot both be turning the same rpms and be doing the same amount of work if they are not putting out the same HP. Anything that would cause a decrease in power should also cause a decrease in rpm with a fixed-pitch prop. With the numbers given we're not talking about a small decrease in power either - 70 kts cruise versus 90 kts cruise I believe were the numbers quoted. Maybe someone forgot to untie the tail and you were dragging a large piece of the airport along with you :) BDS |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Saturn V F-1 Engine Testing at F-1 Engine Test Stand 6866986.jpg | [email protected] | Aviation Photos | 1 | April 11th 07 04:48 PM |
Cessna 150 with 150hp engine performance | The Ponderosa | Owning | 0 | September 18th 04 06:14 AM |
Complex / High Performance / Low Performance | R.T. | Owning | 22 | July 6th 04 08:04 AM |
High Performance Single Engine Choices | O. Sami Saydjari | Owning | 82 | January 6th 04 07:32 PM |
Hi-performance endorsment with a experimental engine | Paul Lee | Home Built | 15 | September 11th 03 12:00 AM |