If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
RFI is best squelched at the souce, i.e. on the PC board. The biggest
source of RFI is the clock that drives the processor, etc. If it isn't routed on the board very well or properly terminated, it will radiate like a pig. Also, effective grounding of the PC board to the case is important. Given that you have a noisy PC board, the only way to effectively shield it is the fully enclose it in a conductive case, preferrable made out of steel since that will also block the magnetic portion of the radiation. Any gaps or slots in the case that are as large as the wavelengths of the radiated signals will allow the signals to escape. In an airplane, aluminum cases are preferred due to their light weight and lack of magnetic effects on the compass. Also, wires that run out of the enclosure will often carry the RFI signals and re-radiate them by acting as antennas unless they are also well shielded and properly terminated to the case ground. Ferrite cores can also be effective in blocking such signals from traveling out through the wires. Dean These are all band-aids for the original problem of having an overly noisy PC board. "jcpearce" wrote in message ups.com... As a pet/learning project I made a data aquisition unit using an 8051 microprocessor and an EPIA M motherboard running a variant of Linux to process and display the information. It all works but the EMI from the EPIA M causes way too much noise to the aircraft radios. I have tried shielding the whole device in an aluminum case with very little improvement. Any ideas on how to smother the EMI or some other small motherboard which may not have as much an issue (as a test I took my portable aviation radio and within 6' of any my home computers the same occurs which gives me little hope) Thanks |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks Dean, Elippse, Colin Lamb, Bob, AINut Don, Kayroc & Tim, I
really appreciate the advice. Your comments rekindle my drive, I had hit a low point after designing the data capture board, OS, circuits etc.. and then... being killed with RF noise. An odd, but beneficial I suppose, confluence of circumstances involving a broken window pane and a mischievous dog and a storm lead to water getting on the DC to DC power supply (11~14 DC - 12V, 5V, 3.3V +-) for the EPIA M motherboard. Not surprisingly it decided not to continue functioning. I then pulled out a traditional power supply to use, and.. amazingly 80% of the noise went away! I would hate to curse but the blasted PW-60 #!@! ( http://store.ituner.com/ituner/pw60caatxpos.html ) power supply was the primary culprit. It is a switching power supply with evidently little RF and EMI protection. I am trying to find another DC-DC power supply without these issues, they all appear to be switching power supplies, I would rather deal with energy/heat loss than RF noise. I don't want to go through the space and elaborate hastle of going from the 11-14V bus to 120V AC to a bulky PC power supply (space is critical) to 12,5,3.3V so I need to find a suitable non noisy power supply and then deal with the issues you knowledgeable fellows enumerated in the posts. Thanks again to Dean, Elippse, Colin Lamb, Bob, AINut Don, Kayroc & Tim. Your comments rekindle my drive, I had hit a low point after designing the data capture board, OS, circuits etc.. and then... being killed with RF noise. An odd, but beneficial I suppose, confluence of circucumstances involving a broken window pane and a mischevious dog and a storm lead to water getting on the DC to DC power supply (11~14 DC - 12V, 5V, 3.3V +-) for the EPIA M motherboard. Not surprisingly it decided not to continue functioning. I then pulled out a traditional power supply to use, and.. amazingly 90% of the noise went away! I would hate to curse but the blasted PW-60 #!@! ( http://store.ituner.com/ituner/pw60caatxpos.html ) power supply was the primary culprit. It is a switching power supply with evidently all the wrong harmonics. I am trying to find another DC-DC power supply without these issues, they all appear to be switching power supplies, I would rather deal with energy/heat loss than RF noise. I don't want to go through the space and elaborate hastle of going from the 11-14V bus to 120V AC to a bulky PC power supply (space is critical) to 12,5,3.3V so I need to find a suitable non noisy power supply and then deal with the issues you knowledgable fellows enumerated in the posts. Thanks again to Dean, Elippse, Colin Lamb, Bob, AINut Don, Kayroc & Tim. |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
You're welcome! Keep us informed, please, of your trials and successes.
jcpearce wrote: Thanks Dean, Elippse, Colin Lamb, Bob, AINut Don, Kayroc & Tim, I really appreciate the advice. Your comments rekindle my drive, I had hit a low point after designing the data capture board, OS, circuits etc.. and then... being killed with RF noise. An odd, but beneficial I suppose, confluence of circumstances involving a broken window pane and a mischievous dog and a storm lead to water getting on the DC to DC power supply (11~14 DC - 12V, 5V, 3.3V +-) for the EPIA M motherboard. Not surprisingly it decided not to continue functioning. I then pulled out a traditional power supply to use, and.. amazingly 80% of the noise went away! I would hate to curse but the blasted PW-60 #!@! ( http://store.ituner.com/ituner/pw60caatxpos.html ) power supply was the primary culprit. It is a switching power supply with evidently little RF and EMI protection. I am trying to find another DC-DC power supply without these issues, they all appear to be switching power supplies, I would rather deal with energy/heat loss than RF noise. I don't want to go through the space and elaborate hastle of going from the 11-14V bus to 120V AC to a bulky PC power supply (space is critical) to 12,5,3.3V so I need to find a suitable non noisy power supply and then deal with the issues you knowledgeable fellows enumerated in the posts. Thanks again to Dean, Elippse, Colin Lamb, Bob, AINut Don, Kayroc & Tim. Your comments rekindle my drive, I had hit a low point after designing the data capture board, OS, circuits etc.. and then... being killed with RF noise. An odd, but beneficial I suppose, confluence of circucumstances involving a broken window pane and a mischevious dog and a storm lead to water getting on the DC to DC power supply (11~14 DC - 12V, 5V, 3.3V +-) for the EPIA M motherboard. Not surprisingly it decided not to continue functioning. I then pulled out a traditional power supply to use, and.. amazingly 90% of the noise went away! I would hate to curse but the blasted PW-60 #!@! ( http://store.ituner.com/ituner/pw60caatxpos.html ) power supply was the primary culprit. It is a switching power supply with evidently all the wrong harmonics. I am trying to find another DC-DC power supply without these issues, they all appear to be switching power supplies, I would rather deal with energy/heat loss than RF noise. I don't want to go through the space and elaborate hastle of going from the 11-14V bus to 120V AC to a bulky PC power supply (space is critical) to 12,5,3.3V so I need to find a suitable non noisy power supply and then deal with the issues you knowledgable fellows enumerated in the posts. Thanks again to Dean, Elippse, Colin Lamb, Bob, AINut Don, Kayroc & Tim. |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
curse but the blasted PW-60 #!@! (
http://store.ituner.com/ituner/pw60caatxpos.html ) power supply was the primary culprit. It is a switching power supply with evidently all the wrong harmonics. I am trying to find another DC-DC power supply without these issues, they all appear to be switching power supplies, I would rather deal with energy/heat loss than RF noise. The 110v power supplies used in desktop computers are also switching supplies. So the problem is the cheapness of the 12v unit you selected. I'd try another make unit and see if that works if not try putting the power supply in its own shielded case and shielding and ferrite beading the input/output leads from it. Good luck and let us know what you workout! John |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
"jcpearce" wrote in message
ups.com... Thanks Dean, Elippse, Colin Lamb, Bob, AINut Don, Kayroc & Tim, I really appreciate the advice. Your comments rekindle my drive, I had hit a low point after designing the data capture board, OS, circuits etc.. and then... being killed with RF noise. An odd, but beneficial I suppose, confluence of circumstances involving a broken window pane and a mischievous dog and a storm lead to water getting on the DC to DC power supply (11~14 DC - 12V, 5V, 3.3V +-) for the EPIA M motherboard. Not surprisingly it decided not to continue functioning. I then pulled out a traditional power supply to use, and.. amazingly 80% of the noise went away! I would hate to curse but the blasted PW-60 #!@! ( http://store.ituner.com/ituner/pw60caatxpos.html ) power supply was the primary culprit. It is a switching power supply with evidently little RF and EMI protection. I am trying to find another DC-DC power supply without these issues, they all appear to be switching power supplies, I would rather deal with energy/heat loss than RF noise. I don't want to go through the space and elaborate hastle of going from the 11-14V bus to 120V AC to a bulky PC power supply (space is critical) to 12,5,3.3V so I need to find a suitable non noisy power supply and then deal with the issues you knowledgeable fellows enumerated in the posts. Thanks again to Dean, Elippse, Colin Lamb, Bob, AINut Don, Kayroc & Tim. Your comments rekindle my drive, I had hit a low point after designing the data capture board, OS, circuits etc.. and then... being killed with RF noise. An odd, but beneficial I suppose, confluence of circucumstances involving a broken window pane and a mischevious dog and a storm lead to water getting on the DC to DC power supply (11~14 DC - 12V, 5V, 3.3V +-) for the EPIA M motherboard. Not surprisingly it decided not to continue functioning. I then pulled out a traditional power supply to use, and.. amazingly 90% of the noise went away! I would hate to curse but the blasted PW-60 #!@! ( http://store.ituner.com/ituner/pw60caatxpos.html ) power supply was the primary culprit. It is a switching power supply with evidently all the wrong harmonics. I am trying to find another DC-DC power supply without these issues, they all appear to be switching power supplies, I would rather deal with energy/heat loss than RF noise. I don't want to go through the space and elaborate hastle of going from the 11-14V bus to 120V AC to a bulky PC power supply (space is critical) to 12,5,3.3V so I need to find a suitable non noisy power supply and then deal with the issues you knowledgable fellows enumerated in the posts. Thanks again to Dean, Elippse, Colin Lamb, Bob, AINut Don, Kayroc & Tim. Ahhh.... yes. I should have thought to mention the importance of a quiet power supply. A PI filter between the supply and the PC is a good idea to help ensure that switching noise from your supply doesn't get into your PC board. I'm used to designing my own power supplies for systems like this, so I didn't stop to think that you might be using an off-the-shelf supply. Dean |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1 JC, Having tackled this issue myself for other apps, I can point you to an excellent resource, "The Art Of Electronics" by Horowitz & Hill. In there, they outline some techniques witch you may consider paranoid, but I have found to work. For instance, building an enclosure within an enclosure. The outer enclosure is little more than a way to terminate your outside wire connections (including power), allowing you to bring them into a controlled environment where you can then apply such gross tricks as caps & ferrite filters on your power lines and data lines (don't forget fuses!). After you have performed whatever magic you can on the in/outbound leads, you then bring the signal & power into the inner enclosure. Also remember that for homemade enclosures of bent & riveted aluminum, small gaps where one flap is riveted to another can have gaps in then which WILL leak RF. To fix this, your local electronics parts supplier (or Digikey) will sell conductive tape. Welding also works. When attaching the top of the enclosure, you could employ either one of those fine mesh springy wire gaskets, or ... more tape. Good luck, Evan Carew P.S. IF you want me to forward some of the specific steps outlined in TAOE, let me know. -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.0.6 (GNU/Linux) Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org iD8DBQFB/48apxCQXwV2bJARAl5fAJ9SEYjU1Cv42YAG12kRkQVl2034PwC fV4Wv SmcILTAIIIE+cHexj2fbBE0= =xelG -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
jcpearce wrote:
So it is coming solely from the motherboard, some chip on the board is oscillating in the 107~130 Mhz range, given this occurs against one That frequency is awful close to the bus frequency of modern systems (133Mhz). If you're using DIMM memory, do you have a card in every slot, or do you have some of those little radiators hanging free? |
#28
|
|||
|
|||
Thanks Evan, I have eyed that book at the local bookstore and given
that you mention there is a section (and paranoid no less, a good thing) on this I'll purchase a copy. Books like this can save a lot of hair being pulled out. The enclosure I made is riveted and there are very small gaps in addition to where the mandrel pulls out leaving a small hole. Would encompassing the whole thing in aluminum foil (as a test, not for deployment) accurately simulate these sophisticated seals? Before going through that effort I would want to know what, if any, gain I may derive. Ernest the MB only has one DDR slot, where a single 512 Mb card is plugged in. I am encouraged that if the power supply issue can be solved via shielding I will be set. The people at ituner admitted the PW-60 DC-DC power supply was a noise daemon but there new super improved model the M1-ATX ( http://www.mini-box.com/s.nl/sc.8/ca...it.A/id.356/.f ) model would solve this and they are sending me a unit, they are willing to work with me which is quite good customer service. If it is still too noisy I'll get paranoid with cases within cases, welding, prayer, etc... If still too noisy (please no) I'll do my own power supply, Thanks for the replies. |
#29
|
|||
|
|||
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1 JC, [Comments follow your text] jcpearce wrote: Thanks Evan, I have eyed that book at the local bookstore and given that you mention there is a section (and paranoid no less, a good thing) on this I'll purchase a copy. Books like this can save a lot of hair being pulled out. The enclosure I made is riveted and there are very small gaps in addition to where the mandrel pulls out leaving a small hole. Would encompassing the whole thing in aluminum foil (as a test, not for deployment) accurately simulate these sophisticated seals? Before going through that effort I would want to know what, if any, gain I may derive. Well, when last I did this, I remember the RF "bonding" tape was nickel plated coper foil with a collodial silver stickey backing. As I remember, it worked perfectly, if somewhat expensively. Since this was a little more than 10 years ago, I imagine that there have been some cheaper alternatives developed since then. Your problem when using tin foil will be getting it at the precise potential of the rivited box underneath it. To accomplish this, it needs to be "bonded", ie electrically grounded to the main box at regular intervals. What these intervals is, has either to be determined experimentally, or solved via the paranoid method (nickel plated coper tape with $ilver......). Ultimately, I think the better solution would be to get some cheap double or single sided FR11 PC board and solder it together with coper foil (cheap at your local electrical supply). To seal the top, you are going to have to order some king of conductive compression tape (cheap from digikey. If you are interested, email me off group & I'll see if I can find you some hardware ideas from Digikey. Evan -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.0.6 (GNU/Linux) Comment: Using GnuPG with Mozilla - http://enigmail.mozdev.org iD8DBQFCCjHZpxCQXwV2bJARAhTAAJkBU0SgGlHr5CBIgFPOac FAc0nTAwCeOEWI rqXJENBMFEO4l079skK5oHs= =ZpGE -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- |
#30
|
|||
|
|||
"Evan Carew" wrote Well, when last I did this, I remember the RF "bonding" tape was nickel plated coper foil with a collodial silver stickey backing. As I remember, it worked perfectly, if somewhat expensively. Sounds similar to something you can get in the heating and cooling sections of the big box hardware stores. It is thin aluminum tape with sticky on it. Seems like reversing it once in a while, or at the ends would get the al to al contact, to bypass the non conductive sticky. I have not tried it, but advice is worth what you pay for it! g -- Jim in NC |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|