If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Tow Signals
There had been yet another fatality recently as a result of
misinterpreting the open spoilers signal. True we all passed the written test and know that wiggeling the rudder means check spoilers and rocking the wings means release, yet so many students and experienced pilots alike continiue to confuse this signal and releasing the tow rope instead, often resulting in accidents. It is not hard to understand why: The tow plane barely climb, the glider pilot suspects something must be wrong with the tow plane, then he/she sees the rudder signal which confirms his thought that something is wrong, then releases the tow rope in panic, since this is what we were taught to do if something is wrong with the tow plane. I think that there is a relatively simple solution for this: 1 - If radio is available (and it always should) - use it instead of the rudder signal! 2 - If this doesn't doesn't work, the signal should be avoided until the glider is at least 200 feet, unless of course, the tow plane is in immediate danger. 3 - If the glider pilot sees the tow plane signaling something (wigling the rudder or rocking the wings) the FIRST look at the spoilers, then release the tow rope if necessary. In this case, the pilot will do the correct action regardless of the signal. I think this is what needs to be taught. I am not an instructor myself, so this is just my humble opinion... Ramy |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Tow Signals
Ramy,
I feel it is almost certain more accidents will occur in the confusion of these important tow signals. I agree with you that it would be best for the tow pilot to try the radio first if the "situation" allows for it. In an effort to help students keeps these signals straight ... I teach the rudder wag as a visual metaphor(?) for being slapped in the face... as in "WAKE UP!!!" and I repeat it every time signals are discussed or practiced in flight. So far so good.... Curt Lewis - 95 Genesis 2 CFIG On Oct 11, 2:02 pm, "Ramy" wrote: There had been yet another fatality recently as a result of misinterpreting the open spoilers signal. True we all passed the written test and know that wiggeling the rudder means check spoilers and rocking the wings means release, yet so many students and experienced pilots alike continiue to confuse this signal and releasing the tow rope instead, often resulting in accidents. It is not hard to understand why: The tow plane barely climb, the glider pilot suspects something must be wrong with the tow plane, then he/she sees the rudder signal which confirms his thought that something is wrong, then releases the tow rope in panic, since this is what we were taught to do if something is wrong with the tow plane. I think that there is a relatively simple solution for this: 1 - If radio is available (and it always should) - use it instead of the rudder signal! 2 - If this doesn't doesn't work, the signal should be avoided until the glider is at least 200 feet, unless of course, the tow plane is in immediate danger. 3 - If the glider pilot sees the tow plane signaling something (wigling the rudder or rocking the wings) the FIRST look at the spoilers, then release the tow rope if necessary. In this case, the pilot will do the correct action regardless of the signal. I think this is what needs to be taught. I am not an instructor myself, so this is just my humble opinion... Ramy |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Tow Signals
Great metaphor to cement the signal's meaning!
"CLewis95" wrote in message oups.com... Ramy, I feel it is almost certain more accidents will occur in the confusion of these important tow signals. I agree with you that it would be best for the tow pilot to try the radio first if the "situation" allows for it. In an effort to help students keeps these signals straight ... I teach the rudder wag as a visual metaphor(?) for being slapped in the face... as in "WAKE UP!!!" and I repeat it every time signals are discussed or practiced in flight. So far so good.... Curt Lewis - 95 Genesis 2 CFIG On Oct 11, 2:02 pm, "Ramy" wrote: There had been yet another fatality recently as a result of misinterpreting the open spoilers signal. True we all passed the written test and know that wiggeling the rudder means check spoilers and rocking the wings means release, yet so many students and experienced pilots alike continiue to confuse this signal and releasing the tow rope instead, often resulting in accidents. It is not hard to understand why: The tow plane barely climb, the glider pilot suspects something must be wrong with the tow plane, then he/she sees the rudder signal which confirms his thought that something is wrong, then releases the tow rope in panic, since this is what we were taught to do if something is wrong with the tow plane. I think that there is a relatively simple solution for this: 1 - If radio is available (and it always should) - use it instead of the rudder signal! 2 - If this doesn't doesn't work, the signal should be avoided until the glider is at least 200 feet, unless of course, the tow plane is in immediate danger. 3 - If the glider pilot sees the tow plane signaling something (wigling the rudder or rocking the wings) the FIRST look at the spoilers, then release the tow rope if necessary. In this case, the pilot will do the correct action regardless of the signal. I think this is what needs to be taught. I am not an instructor myself, so this is just my humble opinion... Ramy |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Tow Signals
how many instructors coordinate with their tow pilot to give a rudder wag at
200ft AGL.. and then watch what happens.. after appropriate ground school in a previous lesson of course.. and then.. on another lesson day.. coordinates for a wave off at 300ft? and a good tow pilot might reduce power with the wave off or maybe start a gradual descent? so many times.. I've had the tow pilot pull a close in down wind turn.. briefed of course.. never get above 500ft AGL and then start the wave off.. the student or rated pilot on a flight review does not realize that the pattern IS NOT NORMAL... what's going on.. and then... ohh.. he wants me to get off.. and then takes his sweet time doing it.. granted.. if all appears well.. make sure you are in a safe place to get off tow.. but if things did not look normal before.. that should have been the earlier clue to be ready for something. BT "CLewis95" wrote in message oups.com... Ramy, I feel it is almost certain more accidents will occur in the confusion of these important tow signals. I agree with you that it would be best for the tow pilot to try the radio first if the "situation" allows for it. In an effort to help students keeps these signals straight ... I teach the rudder wag as a visual metaphor(?) for being slapped in the face... as in "WAKE UP!!!" and I repeat it every time signals are discussed or practiced in flight. So far so good.... Curt Lewis - 95 Genesis 2 CFIG On Oct 11, 2:02 pm, "Ramy" wrote: There had been yet another fatality recently as a result of misinterpreting the open spoilers signal. True we all passed the written test and know that wiggeling the rudder means check spoilers and rocking the wings means release, yet so many students and experienced pilots alike continiue to confuse this signal and releasing the tow rope instead, often resulting in accidents. It is not hard to understand why: The tow plane barely climb, the glider pilot suspects something must be wrong with the tow plane, then he/she sees the rudder signal which confirms his thought that something is wrong, then releases the tow rope in panic, since this is what we were taught to do if something is wrong with the tow plane. I think that there is a relatively simple solution for this: 1 - If radio is available (and it always should) - use it instead of the rudder signal! 2 - If this doesn't doesn't work, the signal should be avoided until the glider is at least 200 feet, unless of course, the tow plane is in immediate danger. 3 - If the glider pilot sees the tow plane signaling something (wigling the rudder or rocking the wings) the FIRST look at the spoilers, then release the tow rope if necessary. In this case, the pilot will do the correct action regardless of the signal. I think this is what needs to be taught. I am not an instructor myself, so this is just my humble opinion... Ramy |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Tow Signals
BT wrote: how many instructors coordinate with their tow pilot to give a rudder wag at 200ft AGL.. and then watch what happens.. after appropriate ground school in a previous lesson of course.. and then.. on another lesson day.. coordinates for a wave off at 300ft? and a good tow pilot might reduce power with the wave off or maybe start a gradual descent? so many times.. I've had the tow pilot pull a close in down wind turn.. briefed of course.. never get above 500ft AGL and then start the wave off.. the student or rated pilot on a flight review does not realize that the pattern IS NOT NORMAL... what's going on.. and then... ohh.. he wants me to get off.. and then takes his sweet time doing it.. granted.. if all appears well.. make sure you are in a safe place to get off tow.. but if things did not look normal before.. that should have been the earlier clue to be ready for something. BT BT, I couldn't agree with you more - many instructors let students get all the way to their rating without the above sorts of "dirty tricks". This is unacceptable. Three that I always do: - Towpilot begins to slowly throttle back (simulating loss of power due to any number of reasons) at a pre-arranged altitude of about 500-700 AGL without a waveoff. In real-life, this is exactly what might happen in the event of a non-catastrophic towplane problem while the towpilot tries to figure out "what the ***". What does the student do? Most will watch as the inevitable slack line develops and we begin to transition from positive rate of climb to descent. About 20% figure out something is wrong and release while they still have time to make a reasonable pattern and landing. When towpilot finally gives the wave off MOST of the remainder are already on a high enough alert level that they release immediately. A few freeze. - Towpilot gives the rudder waggle at altitude (always above a safe glide to the airport). Most do the right thing. A few either a) release or b) ask me "what's he doing." - This last one is "fun", though it isn't really a tow signal per se. I admit that it's a hassle, but it can be a great learning tool. I will have the towpilot plan on a particularly slow acceleration and a marginal liftoff well down the field. All the while, I'll be asking the student "does this feel right"? I will then pull the release (if student hasn't already) and land straight ahead. The discussion that ensues is along the lines of : a) Hey, it's your neck on the line. b) Don't trust the towpilot blindly - maybe he's got a problem and has forgotten about you. c) The trees at the end of the runway won't care whose fault it was when you impact them 20 feet below the tops. Caution: This requires careful coordination and briefing with the towpilot, an ample length of remaining runway, coordination with other traffic, etc. etc. I'll admit that not every student of mine has been through this, though we do have the discussion. Anyway, I think a lot of people get through training without these and other dirty tricks, and it's a shame. Erik Mann LS8-18 (P3) |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Tow Signals
Papa3 wrote: BT wrote: how many instructors coordinate with their tow pilot to give a rudder wag at 200ft AGL.. and then watch what happens.. after appropriate ground school in a previous lesson of course.. and then.. on another lesson day.. coordinates for a wave off at 300ft? and a good tow pilot might reduce power with the wave off or maybe start a gradual descent? so many times.. I've had the tow pilot pull a close in down wind turn.. briefed of course.. never get above 500ft AGL and then start the wave off.. the student or rated pilot on a flight review does not realize that the pattern IS NOT NORMAL... what's going on.. and then... ohh.. he wants me to get off.. and then takes his sweet time doing it.. granted.. if all appears well.. make sure you are in a safe place to get off tow.. but if things did not look normal before.. that should have been the earlier clue to be ready for something. BT BT, I couldn't agree with you more - many instructors let students get all the way to their rating without the above sorts of "dirty tricks". This is unacceptable. Three that I always do: - Towpilot begins to slowly throttle back (simulating loss of power due to any number of reasons) at a pre-arranged altitude of about 500-700 AGL without a waveoff. In real-life, this is exactly what might happen in the event of a non-catastrophic towplane problem while the towpilot tries to figure out "what the ***". What does the student do? Most will watch as the inevitable slack line develops and we begin to transition from positive rate of climb to descent. About 20% figure out something is wrong and release while they still have time to make a reasonable pattern and landing. When towpilot finally gives the wave off MOST of the remainder are already on a high enough alert level that they release immediately. A few freeze. - Towpilot gives the rudder waggle at altitude (always above a safe glide to the airport). Most do the right thing. A few either a) release or b) ask me "what's he doing." - This last one is "fun", though it isn't really a tow signal per se. I admit that it's a hassle, but it can be a great learning tool. I will have the towpilot plan on a particularly slow acceleration and a marginal liftoff well down the field. All the while, I'll be asking the student "does this feel right"? I will then pull the release (if student hasn't already) and land straight ahead. The discussion that ensues is along the lines of : a) Hey, it's your neck on the line. b) Don't trust the towpilot blindly - maybe he's got a problem and has forgotten about you. c) The trees at the end of the runway won't care whose fault it was when you impact them 20 feet below the tops. Caution: This requires careful coordination and briefing with the towpilot, an ample length of remaining runway, coordination with other traffic, etc. etc. I'll admit that not every student of mine has been through this, though we do have the discussion. Anyway, I think a lot of people get through training without these and other dirty tricks, and it's a shame. Erik Mann LS8-18 (P3) This is very interesting subject....preflight check? Brakes closed and locked? Now, this leads me to another point of this subject...how many pilots are taking off with their brakes open because it "helps them achieve faster aileron response" ? And then how many pilots are taking off in flapped gliders with negative flaps? Now imagine combination of negative flaps and open brakes right on the take off. Isn't that a recipe for disaster? How often ? I don't know exact number but I see it very frequently. And the most amazing part of that is that the instructors are teaching it this way. When I asked about it, I never got a straight answer but everybody is saying "it must be done that way". O really? Jacek CFI-G Washington State |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Tow Signals
Now, this leads me to another point of this subject...how many pilots are taking off with their brakes open because it "helps them achieve faster aileron response" ? And then how many pilots are taking off in flapped gliders with negative flaps? Jacek, you have to make a distinction here between "taking off" and starting the take off roll.To answer your question, I would say that most pilots, when operating an older ship with a CG hook in a crosswind will use spoilers or negative flap until they get some roll authority.Another thing to consider is with ships like the ASW20 the ailerons droop and rise with the flaps.This makes a HUGE difference on the roll control at slow speeds.It is spelled out in the P.O.H. and therefore it is considered normal operating procedure. Isn't that a recipe for disaster? How often ? I don't know exact number but I see it very frequently. And the most amazing part of that is that the instructors are teaching it this way. Instructors are required to teach compliance with the POH, so I would say this is perfectly normal. When I asked about it, I never got a straight answer but everybody is saying "it must be done that way". O really? Jacek CFI-G Washington State |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Tow Signals
|
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Tow Signals
Papa3.. I like your third one..
now another... how many instructors pull the rope at about 20-30ft AGL.. just as the climb starts.. and watch the student try to go every which way but straight ahead and land. Remember the mantra.. below 200ft land straight ahead. We have a long 3500ft runway, we stage about 500ft down the runway, the tow is normally airborn with 1500ft remaining.. we have 600ft of gravel beyond the paved portion, that is 2100ft to land on from 40ft AGL. I can pull the rope at 20-40ft at the 1500ft remaining marker.. (cross taxi way).. a good student will get it down and I'll have to coax him to let it roll to the end so we can just turn around and tow out the opposite direction. I've had other students looking for a place to go and I've had to take over. Tow pilot may be briefed ahead.. but we have a standing rule.. if the tow is airborne and feels a release.. the tow keeps going.. do not try to land... your blocking the runway for the glider.. we also have about 150ft of good landable grading beside the runway, whole length. BT "Papa3" wrote in message ups.com... BT wrote: how many instructors coordinate with their tow pilot to give a rudder wag at 200ft AGL.. and then watch what happens.. after appropriate ground school in a previous lesson of course.. and then.. on another lesson day.. coordinates for a wave off at 300ft? and a good tow pilot might reduce power with the wave off or maybe start a gradual descent? so many times.. I've had the tow pilot pull a close in down wind turn.. briefed of course.. never get above 500ft AGL and then start the wave off.. the student or rated pilot on a flight review does not realize that the pattern IS NOT NORMAL... what's going on.. and then... ohh.. he wants me to get off.. and then takes his sweet time doing it.. granted.. if all appears well.. make sure you are in a safe place to get off tow.. but if things did not look normal before.. that should have been the earlier clue to be ready for something. BT BT, I couldn't agree with you more - many instructors let students get all the way to their rating without the above sorts of "dirty tricks". This is unacceptable. Three that I always do: - Towpilot begins to slowly throttle back (simulating loss of power due to any number of reasons) at a pre-arranged altitude of about 500-700 AGL without a waveoff. In real-life, this is exactly what might happen in the event of a non-catastrophic towplane problem while the towpilot tries to figure out "what the ***". What does the student do? Most will watch as the inevitable slack line develops and we begin to transition from positive rate of climb to descent. About 20% figure out something is wrong and release while they still have time to make a reasonable pattern and landing. When towpilot finally gives the wave off MOST of the remainder are already on a high enough alert level that they release immediately. A few freeze. - Towpilot gives the rudder waggle at altitude (always above a safe glide to the airport). Most do the right thing. A few either a) release or b) ask me "what's he doing." - This last one is "fun", though it isn't really a tow signal per se. I admit that it's a hassle, but it can be a great learning tool. I will have the towpilot plan on a particularly slow acceleration and a marginal liftoff well down the field. All the while, I'll be asking the student "does this feel right"? I will then pull the release (if student hasn't already) and land straight ahead. The discussion that ensues is along the lines of : a) Hey, it's your neck on the line. b) Don't trust the towpilot blindly - maybe he's got a problem and has forgotten about you. c) The trees at the end of the runway won't care whose fault it was when you impact them 20 feet below the tops. Caution: This requires careful coordination and briefing with the towpilot, an ample length of remaining runway, coordination with other traffic, etc. etc. I'll admit that not every student of mine has been through this, though we do have the discussion. Anyway, I think a lot of people get through training without these and other dirty tricks, and it's a shame. Erik Mann LS8-18 (P3) |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Tow Signals
What about tow plane aborts on the runway?
I had a tug pilot shut down and brake sharply to a stop right on the centerline just after I had lifted off. It took some trick flying to avoid hitting him. I thought this was one in a million until I saw it happen to another glider pilot only a year later. In my case the tuggie suddenly decided he didn't want to fly right then. In the other case, the tuggie left the fuel cap off the Pawnee and gas was streaming onto the canopy. Part of the "Emergency" pre-takeoff planning has to be about where to go if the tug slams on the brakes. I'd think the tuggie should move as far to the left as possible - even departing the runway to the left during an abort if that is possible. AFAIK, runway aborts aren't addresed in tow pilot training. Bill Daniels "BT" wrote in message news:LhAXg.4029$gM1.2379@fed1read12... Papa3.. I like your third one.. now another... how many instructors pull the rope at about 20-30ft AGL.. just as the climb starts.. and watch the student try to go every which way but straight ahead and land. Remember the mantra.. below 200ft land straight ahead. We have a long 3500ft runway, we stage about 500ft down the runway, the tow is normally airborn with 1500ft remaining.. we have 600ft of gravel beyond the paved portion, that is 2100ft to land on from 40ft AGL. I can pull the rope at 20-40ft at the 1500ft remaining marker.. (cross taxi way).. a good student will get it down and I'll have to coax him to let it roll to the end so we can just turn around and tow out the opposite direction. I've had other students looking for a place to go and I've had to take over. Tow pilot may be briefed ahead.. but we have a standing rule.. if the tow is airborne and feels a release.. the tow keeps going.. do not try to land... your blocking the runway for the glider.. we also have about 150ft of good landable grading beside the runway, whole length. BT "Papa3" wrote in message ups.com... BT wrote: how many instructors coordinate with their tow pilot to give a rudder wag at 200ft AGL.. and then watch what happens.. after appropriate ground school in a previous lesson of course.. and then.. on another lesson day.. coordinates for a wave off at 300ft? and a good tow pilot might reduce power with the wave off or maybe start a gradual descent? so many times.. I've had the tow pilot pull a close in down wind turn.. briefed of course.. never get above 500ft AGL and then start the wave off.. the student or rated pilot on a flight review does not realize that the pattern IS NOT NORMAL... what's going on.. and then... ohh.. he wants me to get off.. and then takes his sweet time doing it.. granted.. if all appears well.. make sure you are in a safe place to get off tow.. but if things did not look normal before.. that should have been the earlier clue to be ready for something. BT BT, I couldn't agree with you more - many instructors let students get all the way to their rating without the above sorts of "dirty tricks". This is unacceptable. Three that I always do: - Towpilot begins to slowly throttle back (simulating loss of power due to any number of reasons) at a pre-arranged altitude of about 500-700 AGL without a waveoff. In real-life, this is exactly what might happen in the event of a non-catastrophic towplane problem while the towpilot tries to figure out "what the ***". What does the student do? Most will watch as the inevitable slack line develops and we begin to transition from positive rate of climb to descent. About 20% figure out something is wrong and release while they still have time to make a reasonable pattern and landing. When towpilot finally gives the wave off MOST of the remainder are already on a high enough alert level that they release immediately. A few freeze. - Towpilot gives the rudder waggle at altitude (always above a safe glide to the airport). Most do the right thing. A few either a) release or b) ask me "what's he doing." - This last one is "fun", though it isn't really a tow signal per se. I admit that it's a hassle, but it can be a great learning tool. I will have the towpilot plan on a particularly slow acceleration and a marginal liftoff well down the field. All the while, I'll be asking the student "does this feel right"? I will then pull the release (if student hasn't already) and land straight ahead. The discussion that ensues is along the lines of : a) Hey, it's your neck on the line. b) Don't trust the towpilot blindly - maybe he's got a problem and has forgotten about you. c) The trees at the end of the runway won't care whose fault it was when you impact them 20 feet below the tops. Caution: This requires careful coordination and briefing with the towpilot, an ample length of remaining runway, coordination with other traffic, etc. etc. I'll admit that not every student of mine has been through this, though we do have the discussion. Anyway, I think a lot of people get through training without these and other dirty tricks, and it's a shame. Erik Mann LS8-18 (P3) |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
"Signal jamming a factor in future wars, general says" | Mike | Military Aviation | 23 | August 24th 11 02:17 AM |
UAV's and TFR's along the Mexico boarder | John Doe | Piloting | 145 | March 31st 06 06:58 PM |
Glider - Towplane Signals | Mike the Strike | Soaring | 24 | March 26th 05 09:33 PM |
The wrong signals to send to young visitors. | Larry Dighera | Piloting | 57 | November 26th 03 07:05 AM |