If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Collision Avoidance
I am going to be setting up a new (TO me) glider panel during our fast approaching off season. Standard category if it matters and two of the things on the list are PowerFlarm and a Transponder. From talking to some people (Suppliers and other pilots) there are a few who are doing either or, and one who is forgoing the installation of a TX for a PF. Am I missing something? I have always thought you needed both the TX and PF. Have been flying with PF and so far it is doing a good job of detecting TX equipped gliders and power planes.
|
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Collision Avoidance
On Wednesday, September 5, 2012 8:12:53 AM UTC-4, K wrote:
I am going to be setting up a new (TO me) glider panel during our fast approaching off season. Standard category if it matters and two of the things on the list are PowerFlarm and a Transponder. From talking to some people (Suppliers and other pilots) there are a few who are doing either or, and one who is forgoing the installation of a TX for a PF. Am I missing something? I have always thought you needed both the TX and PF. Have been flying with PF and so far it is doing a good job of detecting TX equipped gliders and power planes. Principal benefits for a glider: - Transponder makes you visible to TCAS of heavies. - Use PowerFLARM for everything else. For *most* gliders PowerFLARM will be more useful. You don't *need* either. Hope that helps, Best Regards, Dave "YO electric" PS: Please study http://www.gliderpilot.org/FLARM |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Collision Avoidance
On Sep 5, 7:12*am, K wrote:
I am going to be setting up a new (TO me) glider panel during our fast approaching off season. Standard category if it matters and two of the things on the list are PowerFlarm and a Transponder. From talking to some people (Suppliers and other pilots) there are a few who are doing either or, and one who is forgoing the installation of a TX for a PF. Am I missing something? I have always thought you needed both the TX and PF. Have been flying with PF and so far it is doing a good job of detecting TX equipped gliders and power planes. My 2c: It depends where you are and cost/benefit. I fly in the Chicago area, near a lot of commercial traffic, and lots of power traffic that is talking to ATC. The transponder means they see us. The transponder triggers the jet and bizjet tcas. The transponder means ATC routes jets around us. (I've watched southwest 737 turn away from us.) The transponder means that parachute jump operations, talking to center, see you and won't jump on top of you. Flying above Aurora class D the other day, the transponder triggered a friendly call, did I know I was 2 miles from Ohare class B and headed right for it. (Answer, yes thanks. Answer omitted, yes, and there is a fat cumulus cloud 1/2 mile ahead after which I'm going to turn left.) Of course, the transponder means you'd better fly right because the FAA is watching, but we all do that anyway. Flarm is great. (Well, I hope so if I ever get the thing installed. Thanks for making it so easy, Flarm. ) But you are invisible to them with flarm. I regard flarm as primarily to avoid glider-glider collisions, and helps me see them. The transponder helps them see you. Definitely worth it. John Cochrane. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Collision Avoidance
On Wednesday, September 5, 2012 5:12:53 AM UTC-7, K wrote:
I am going to be setting up a new (TO me) glider panel during our fast approaching off season. Standard category if it matters and two of the things on the list are PowerFlarm and a Transponder. From talking to some people (Suppliers and other pilots) there are a few who are doing either or, and one who is forgoing the installation of a TX for a PF. Am I missing something? I have always thought you needed both the TX and PF. Have been flying with PF and so far it is doing a good job of detecting TX equipped gliders and power planes. As Dave said, it depends on where you fly. I got a transponder because the airline traffic into/out of McCarren Int'l is intense, and often flies right through the routes into/out of Jean. Before I installed a transponder, I often spent a good part of the first hour of each flight dodging heavies. I rarely see another glider, and the GA traffic is well below me. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Collision Avoidance
I've had a transponder in my glider since 2006 and, like John, have the benefit of watching commercial airliners diverted around me. I also once saw a pair of F-16s pulling a high-g maneuver to avoid me. However, it doesn't confer immunity from all power traffic, especially light twins and some military aircraft. The nearest collision I've had was another glider flying head-on under a cloud street - we passed within 100-feet of each other.
I'm not sure the FAA always pays a lot of attention to glider traffic after I inadvertently flew into Mexico and back not too long ago - that usually brings Border Patrol aircraft on your tail! They either didn't notice or decided to ignore me! Mike |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Collision Avoidance
On Wednesday, September 5, 2012 8:37:15 AM UTC-6, Mike the Strike wrote:
I've had a transponder in my glider since 2006 and, like John, have the benefit of watching commercial airliners diverted around me. I also once saw a pair of F-16s pulling a high-g maneuver to avoid me. However, it doesn't confer immunity from all power traffic, especially light twins and some military aircraft. The nearest collision I've had was another glider flying head-on under a cloud street - we passed within 100-feet of each other. I'm not sure the FAA always pays a lot of attention to glider traffic after I inadvertently flew into Mexico and back not too long ago - that usually brings Border Patrol aircraft on your tail! They either didn't notice or decided to ignore me! Mike Mike, UF, John and Dave, Thanks for the responses. I fly in two areas of heavy power and airliner traffic and your comments validate my concerns. It makes me wonder if we will have both the TX and PF functions combined into one unit someday. For now I will live with two separate installations. |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Collision Avoidance
On Wednesday, September 5, 2012 10:10:18 AM UTC-5, K wrote:
On Wednesday, September 5, 2012 8:37:15 AM UTC-6, Mike the Strike wrote: I've had a transponder in my glider since 2006 and, like John, have the benefit of watching commercial airliners diverted around me. I also once saw a pair of F-16s pulling a high-g maneuver to avoid me. However, it doesn't confer immunity from all power traffic, especially light twins and some military aircraft. The nearest collision I've had was another glider flying head-on under a cloud street - we passed within 100-feet of each other. I'm not sure the FAA always pays a lot of attention to glider traffic after I inadvertently flew into Mexico and back not too long ago - that usually brings Border Patrol aircraft on your tail! They either didn't notice or decided to ignore me! Mike Mike, UF, John and Dave, Thanks for the responses. I fly in two areas of heavy power and airliner traffic and your comments validate my concerns. It makes me wonder if we will have both the TX and PF functions combined into one unit someday. For now I will live with two separate installations. I have a transponder in the Cherokee and have recently bought a portable powerFLARM. it has alerted me twice now to airplanes about to cruise through my thermal at my altitude. I still haven't seen a glider on it. Only a few locals are equipped with PowerFLARM. |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Collision Avoidance
My take:
A transponder lets those with TCAS (usually airliners and biz jets) get immediate in-cockpit alerts to divert. ATC can also alert any aircraft on IFR or Flight Watch verbally of conflicts. Your transponder will do NOTHING to let you know who is about to skewer you (unless you happen to be in comm with ATC). Best if you fly near Class B/C. A PCAS lets YOU know who is near you with a transponder (includes GA, Biz jets, and some gliders, if equipped). A pure PCAS is relatively cheap on eBay. PowerFlarm as a built in PCAS. Great for flying near busy GA airports. PowerFlarm has a two kinds transponder detection. One is a simple PCAS function. The other is ADS-B (presently only some transponder equipped aircraft have ADS-B capability) which gives you additional location and identification information. Great for flying near busy GA airports. PowerFlarm additionally has Flarm-to-Flarm alerts which gives each flarm equipped aircraft distance, direction and ID. There are very few Flarm equipped aircraft in the US but numbers are growing. The flarm-to-flarm protocol is also clever in that it filters out non-threatening encounters (i.e., in a gaggle or flying with a buddy on the ridge). Best for glider contests and good for gliding areas if you have other gliders in your area with Flarms. Useless if they don't a Flarm too. Having both a PowerFlarm and a transponder covers you the best for all airspace. I flew for a while with only a PCAS and was impressed enough that I wouldn't fly without at least a PCAS. I recently replaced it with a PowerFlarm. I got PCAS hits but only one Flarm alert so far. As soon as I save enough pennies I'll be investing in a transponder as well. Probably the Trig21 as it has lowest power consumption and is compact with it's built-in altitude encoder. Having the tiny display separate from the core electronics box also makes cramming it into tight panels more likely. -Jim |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Collision Avoidance
On Wednesday, September 5, 2012 11:10:18 AM UTC-4, K wrote:
me wonder if we will have both the TX and PF functions combined into one unit someday. Well, immense certification costs spread over a small market make this a not-so-great idea. Unless a "certified module" was adapted (Georg ?). Better: replace remote head (as in Trig) with interface to existing glider stuff (doable but may not meet transponder legal requirements in some situations/venues). See ya, Dave |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Collision Avoidance Systems | jcarlyle | Soaring | 27 | September 7th 06 03:38 AM |
Collision Avoidance and ATC | Bubba | Soaring | 5 | September 1st 06 04:31 AM |
Collision Avoidance Systems | [email protected] | Products | 0 | May 21st 06 10:15 PM |
Collision avoidance equipment | samcapt | Products | 2 | May 13th 05 04:41 PM |
Collision avoidance device | Jim Hendrix | Soaring | 1 | October 19th 04 09:24 AM |