If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
For those willing to take a close look at Nick Lappos's presentation
and it's referenced supporting data, please note the following: 1) The 1,050 KM range shown for the CH-53 in Nick's presentation is with additional internal and external aux tanks installed. Using only normal internal fuel tanks, the CH-53 ferry range is only 590 KM. 2) The 1,030 KM V-22 ferry range shown in Nick's presentation is actually 2 X the 515 Amphib Assault mission range. With internal ferry tanks installed the V-22 ferry range is 2,100 KM. Twice that of the CH-53. 3) The 1,150 KM ferry range shown for the MILITARY UH-60L in Nick's presentation is with four additional 230 gallon external aux tanks installed. Using only normal internal fuel tanks, the UH-60L ferry range is only 290 KM. 4) The 750 KM ferry range shown in Nick's presentation for the CIVIL BA609 is with using only current internal fuel tanks. This is almost three times the UH-60L ferry range. With internal tanks planned for the Military BA609 version, ferry range is increased to 1,000 KM. In short, for Nick's presentation, using as many internal and external aux fuel tanks as possible for the CH-53 and UH-60L is acceptable. But the use of even additional internal aux tanks on V-22 or BA609 is prohibited. So Nishant, do your own research before you draw any conclusions. Don't take anyone's opinion (even mine) until you look closely at all reliable data sources. Good luck, CTR |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
CTR is so off base, he confuses the units on the charts. The ranges shown
are all in 1050 Nautical Miles. Yes, in the presentation, aux tanks are used for both types, tilt rotors and helicopters, and their weight (payload reduction) is accounted for properly. I stand by my numbers, they are impeccable. A tilt rotor carries half the payload to the same range as a helicopter, and it has less transport efficiency, and costs twice as much for the same payload. http://webpages.charter.net/nlappos/...comparison.pdf Nick "CTR" wrote in message oups.com... For those willing to take a close look at Nick Lappos's presentation and it's referenced supporting data, please note the following: 1) The 1,050 KM range shown for the CH-53 in Nick's presentation is with additional internal and external aux tanks installed. Using only normal internal fuel tanks, the CH-53 ferry range is only 590 KM. 2) The 1,030 KM V-22 ferry range shown in Nick's presentation is actually 2 X the 515 Amphib Assault mission range. With internal ferry tanks installed the V-22 ferry range is 2,100 KM. Twice that of the CH-53. 3) The 1,150 KM ferry range shown for the MILITARY UH-60L in Nick's presentation is with four additional 230 gallon external aux tanks installed. Using only normal internal fuel tanks, the UH-60L ferry range is only 290 KM. 4) The 750 KM ferry range shown in Nick's presentation for the CIVIL BA609 is with using only current internal fuel tanks. This is almost three times the UH-60L ferry range. With internal tanks planned for the Military BA609 version, ferry range is increased to 1,000 KM. In short, for Nick's presentation, using as many internal and external aux fuel tanks as possible for the CH-53 and UH-60L is acceptable. But the use of even additional internal aux tanks on V-22 or BA609 is prohibited. So Nishant, do your own research before you draw any conclusions. Don't take anyone's opinion (even mine) until you look closely at all reliable data sources. Good luck, CTR |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Nick, thanks for the help again. I am studying in the A.I.S.S.M.S's
Engineering college in India under the Pune University. I plan to pursue a Master's degree in Aerospace Engineering after I finish my Mechanical Engineering next year.......Due to obvious reasons getting the AHS papers is not really an option, as ordering them over the net translates into a lot of money, when converted into Indian Rupees. So, I end up searching the net. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Nishant,
You may find this of value. http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/ca...1993008694.pdf Due to obvious reasons getting the AHS papers is not really an option, as ordering them over the net translates into a lot of money, when converted into Indian Rupees. So, I end up searching the net. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Nick said;
"Also, Stepniewski and Keys "Rotary Wing Aerodynamics" (Dover publications) has a major section on tilt rotor design aspects.' OK Nick, what chapter is missing from my copy of "Rotary Wing Aerodynamics"???? Chapter II - IV is on the Winged (compound) Helicopter. Chapter II - V is on the Tandem (fore & aft rotors) helicopter. The Tilt-rotor is covered in 45 words and a picture in Chapter I - I. As a mater of fact, Stepniewski recommends the Intermeshing configuration for tomorrow's rotorcraft. http://www.UniCopter.com/1093.html "NickL" wrote in message There are many American Helicopter Society technical papers that have been given at the AHS annual forum over the years, several at a level which would be right for undergraduate work. Ask your school librarian for help, these are usually available in a few days. Also, Stepniewski and Keys "Rotary Wing Aerodynamics" (Dover publications) has a major section on tilt rotor design aspects. Nick Lappos For some broad performance comparisons between helicopters and tilt rotors and supporting sites, see my site: http://webpages.charter.net/nlappos/Disk-Loading.pdf |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
OOPS, I couldn't find my copy (still in cartons in the garage, after my move
South) so I THOUGHT I remembered a chapter on it. Oh well, sorry about that. Nick "Dave Jackson" wrote in message news:sey1f.114567$tl2.98843@pd7tw3no... Nick said; "Also, Stepniewski and Keys "Rotary Wing Aerodynamics" (Dover publications) has a major section on tilt rotor design aspects.' OK Nick, what chapter is missing from my copy of "Rotary Wing Aerodynamics"???? Chapter II - IV is on the Winged (compound) Helicopter. Chapter II - V is on the Tandem (fore & aft rotors) helicopter. The Tilt-rotor is covered in 45 words and a picture in Chapter I - I. As a mater of fact, Stepniewski recommends the Intermeshing configuration for tomorrow's rotorcraft. http://www.UniCopter.com/1093.html "NickL" wrote in message There are many American Helicopter Society technical papers that have been given at the AHS annual forum over the years, several at a level which would be right for undergraduate work. Ask your school librarian for help, these are usually available in a few days. Also, Stepniewski and Keys "Rotary Wing Aerodynamics" (Dover publications) has a major section on tilt rotor design aspects. Nick Lappos For some broad performance comparisons between helicopters and tilt rotors and supporting sites, see my site: http://webpages.charter.net/nlappos/Disk-Loading.pdf |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
EW model "D" IGC approved flight recorder- info needed | MC | Soaring | 0 | March 7th 05 07:14 PM |
Ball 620H vario info needed | Ray | Soaring | 0 | December 16th 04 03:13 PM |
Info needed: Slingsby Sky | Erwin Janssen | Soaring | 0 | January 13th 04 08:35 PM |
Groom Lake/area 51 Migs from 70s info needed | Aerophotos | Military Aviation | 23 | September 13th 03 05:16 PM |
RB-47H info needed for model | Matt Wiser | Military Aviation | 0 | August 3rd 03 03:54 AM |