If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Variometers for other Soaring Sports
I have noticed that there are lots of sports that also use variometers
and I have some comments/questions. These variometers are for Power Parachutes, Hang Gliders, Balloons, Ultralights, Parafoils to name a few. Here are some links; http://www.ascentvario.com/ http://digiflyuk.com http://brauniger.com http://flytec.com http://www.aircotec.ch These are all standalone "outside the cockpit" variometers. I don't know about their realiability or sensitivity how well these might work "inside a cockpit". What I am impressed with is the innovative design and feature sets of these devices. Why don't these manufacturers build for our sport? Is it that soaring aircraft are bound by archaic rules and regulations that other newer flying sports are not? I suppose we all ask ourselves the same questions about why our sport isn't seen as trendy and hip. My $0.02. - John DeRosa |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Variometers for other Soaring Sports
On Nov 3, 4:25*am, ContestID67 wrote:
I have noticed that there are lots of sports that also use variometers and I have some comments/questions. These variometers are for Power Parachutes, Hang Gliders, Balloons, Ultralights, Parafoils to name a few. *Here are some links; * *http://www.ascentvario.com/ * *http://digiflyuk.com * *http://brauniger.com * *http://flytec.com * *http://www.aircotec.ch These are all standalone "outside the cockpit" variometers. *I don't know about their realiability or sensitivity how well these might work "inside a cockpit". *What I am impressed with is the innovative design and feature sets of these devices. Why don't these manufacturers build for our sport? *Is it that soaring aircraft are bound by archaic rules and regulations that other newer flying sports are not? * I suppose we all ask ourselves the same questions about why our sport isn't seen as trendy and hip. As I understand it, variometers for gliders need total energy compensation for the information they provide to be reasonably accurate. You can't fly fast and pull up in the kinds of craft you mention. Thus, designing a variometer for a glider is a more complicated matter than one for a balloon. In addition gliders come under the aegis of EASA (in the EU) which means that new instruments have to be certified, though whatever was fitted when the glider was transitioned in was accepted. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Variometers for other Soaring Sports
Since there is no certification standard for electronic variometers, they
can't be certified. This would be a problem if the statement below was true, fortunately it isn't. Only instruments required by the type certificate (normally ASI, Altimeter and Magnetic compass) must be certified, others must be installed in a safe manner and the installation signed for by an approved engineer. It is true that some CAA inspectors pre-EASA certification tried to insist on self launching gliders to have only Form 1/FAA8130-3 equipment fitted, but sense eventually prevailed. In addition gliders come under the aegis of EASA (in the EU) which means that new instruments have to be certified, though whatever was fitted when the glider was transitioned in was accepted. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Variometers for other Soaring Sports
At 10:45 03 November 2008, Peter Purdie wrote:
Since there is no certification standard for electronic variometers, they can't be certified. This would be a problem if the statement below was true, fortunately it isn't. Only instruments required by the type certificate (normally ASI, Altimeter and Magnetic compass) must be certified, others must be installed in a safe manner and the installation signed for by an approved engineer. That's good to hear - but what about variometers with a connection to the pitot (airspeed sensor?) |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Variometers for other Soaring Sports
At 04:25 03 November 2008, ContestID67 wrote:
I have noticed that there are lots of sports that also use variometers and I have some comments/questions. These are all standalone "outside the cockpit" variometers. I don't know about their realiability or sensitivity how well these might work "inside a cockpit". What I am impressed with is the innovative design and feature sets of these devices. I agree that the range of features, apparent build quality etc are impressive. But which features impressed you that mainstream sailplane varios currently lack? |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Variometers for other Soaring Sports
Since LX7007/LX8000/C302/ILEC vario/flight directors are fitted to EASA
CofA sailplanes by major manufacturers (using a pitot connection common with the ASI) then it must be assumed this is permissible. At 12:15 03 November 2008, Simon Taylor wrote: At 10:45 03 November 2008, Peter Purdie wrote: Since there is no certification standard for electronic variometers, they can't be certified. This would be a problem if the statement below was true, fortunately it isn't. Only instruments required by the type certificate (normally ASI, Altimeter and Magnetic compass) must be certified, others must be installed in a safe manner and the installation signed for by an approved engineer. That's good to hear - but what about variometers with a connection to the pitot (airspeed sensor?) |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Variometers for other Soaring Sports
On Nov 3, 10:45*am, Peter Purdie wrote:
Since there is no certification standard for electronic variometers, they can't be certified. *This would be a problem if the statement below was true, fortunately it isn't. Only instruments required by the type certificate (normally ASI, Altimeter and Magnetic compass) must be certified, others must be installed in a safe manner and the installation signed for by an approved engineer. It is true that some CAA inspectors pre-EASA certification tried to insist on self launching gliders to have only Form 1/FAA8130-3 equipment fitted, but sense eventually prevailed. In addition gliders come under the aegis of EASA (in the EU) which means that new instruments have to be certified, though whatever was fitted when the glider was transitioned in was accepted. OK, so certification isn't a problem. What about total energy compensation? |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Variometers for other Soaring Sports
Glad that someone started this discussion. I switched from hang
gliding to sail planes a couple of years and am quite familiar with the current crop of HG instruments. The Flytec 6030 is a great instrument and I know a couple of sail plane pilots that use it within their cockpits. The instrument has a pitot tube and can be connected to gliders tubing quite easily. TE compensation has been implemented electronically. My experience with the 5030/6030 in a sailplane is that it works OK but speed range, speed scales and TE and STF compensations need improvement for the higher speeds and speed dynamics experienced. I have spoken with the North American distributor and there is discussion and potentially some work being done to offer a glider version and to get the instrument IGC certified. What would be the advantage? The largest one is cost and functionality. These instruments are currently priced under $1,500 and provide logger, builtin GPS, vario, STF, flight computer capabilities including contest flying, stand alone instrument, 35+ hours of battery life, airspace, all in a small durable package. Great for a club, backup instrument, stand alone logger. Ron Gleason |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Variometers for other Soaring Sports
On Nov 2, 8:25*pm, ContestID67 wrote:
I have noticed that there are lots of sports that also use variometers and I have some comments/questions. These variometers are for Power Parachutes, Hang Gliders, Balloons, Ultralights, Parafoils to name a few. *Here are some links; * *http://www.ascentvario.com/ * *http://digiflyuk.com * *http://brauniger.com * *http://flytec.com * *http://www.aircotec.ch These are all standalone "outside the cockpit" variometers. *I don't know about their realiability or sensitivity how well these might work "inside a cockpit". *What I am impressed with is the innovative design and feature sets of these devices. Why don't these manufacturers build for our sport? *Is it that soaring aircraft are bound by archaic rules and regulations that other newer flying sports are not? * I suppose we all ask ourselves the same questions about why our sport isn't seen as trendy and hip. My $0.02. - John DeRosa A very simple and cheap audio vario: http://www.flyaboveall.com/mini.htm My hearing is poor, so I clip it on my hat brim right next to me ear. It reacts very quickly, and I find it useful for centering thermals. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Variometers for other Soaring Sports
Thanks to everyone who commented. I especially appreciated Ron's
comments from the "other side" of soaring. Cats mentioned the need for TE, etc. Yes, that is true. I envision that the manufacturers would create a glider specific version of their product that would deal with our specific needs and form factors. Simon wanted to know about features. What triggered this whole thread was after looking at the http://www.ascentvario.com/ variometer. Here are some of its features all packed into a case 1.75"x2.36"x0.63" (44mmx60mmx16mm) and weighing 1.4oz (40g). Solid state digital, LCD display, Audio variometer, altimeter, VSI in m/s or ft/min, averager, temperature, max alt, sink alarm, max climb, timers, flight data recorder*, USB, car or AC charging. $299 with a car charger. Even the site is much slicker than our glider variometers' sites. Could this and other non-glider manufacturers create something for our market? Sure they could. But we have to ask why aren't they? Is our market too small? Is it unknown? Is the grown of our market (and the number of devices to be sold) too slow? My $0.02. - John DeRosa * Flight number, date, time, duration, altitude (start/max/end), max lift, max ave lift, max sink, temp (min/max). There is no GPS in this model but there other manufacturers with GPS models. A few are FAI certified flight recorders. |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
2007 Sports Class Nationals 12-21 June at Caesar Creek Soaring Club near Waynesville Ohio | 2007 Sports Class Nationals | Soaring | 1 | November 28th 06 01:02 PM |
Gizmo Variometers? | Mike C 17 | Soaring | 1 | August 19th 06 07:01 PM |
FS: Winter variometers | Marc Ramsey | Soaring | 0 | June 1st 06 07:46 AM |
S&V variometers? | chris | Soaring | 7 | January 5th 06 06:43 PM |
Variometers as audible AOA indicators | John | Soaring | 1 | March 17th 04 02:02 AM |