If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
SSA Spot Repository
Hi Gang
I decided I would put my self into the position of a member of a search and rescue which had been alerted that a certain person Dave Bingham was missing and that he was carrying a Spot tracker and that a recording of his flight might be found at the URL ssa.com which has a repository of recent Spot tracks for a few pilots around the US (maybe around the world). Now being an average person I am going to assume (maybe incorrectly) that I know how to turn on a computer and bring up a web browser and even type in the address bar ssa.com and press enter. The SSA home page comes up. I don't see anything with the words track or Spot. The thought occurs to me did I get the words track and Spot correctly or did I mistake the message. OK what to do? Should I call back the original message giver and ask for clarification or should I play around and explore pages outside the home page? I explore SSA pages and if I am lucky I notice that cunningly hidden on the SSA page at the one from the bottom of the long list is "Sailplane Tracker". That's funny! I was told a glider with a pilot named Dave Bingham was missing. What's a sailplane? Is a sailplane the same as a glider? Anyhow I click on "Sailplane Tracker' and sure enough a list of names come up including Dave Bingham. I click on the name and the Spot shared page message comes up. Now seeing the Spot message page for the first time is very different from seeing the message page for the hundredth time. What does it say and how do I get information from it? There are no GPS coordinates or times listed only the day on the shared Spot pages. So what to do now? Finally I see an icon that says "show on a map" and I click it. A map comes up and the Spot messages are displayed but which is the first and which is the last in time. Its not obvious which! Since I view most flights both on SeeYou and Spot everything is intuitively obvious to me now but for a neophyte that is not the case. What I have just described could be a nightmare for many people and could possibly waste valuable time in a search and rescue mission. So lets think through some of the issues I am raising: 1) Many people have very limited understanding of computers so everything should be designed to be INTUITIVELY OBVIOUS. SSA should rethink and redo this valuable Spot repository function and before releasing it test it out on a few average Joe guinea pigs. Make sure that most people can quickly find the relevant information. 2) The Spot shared page does not (at least in my case) show either GPS coordinates nor times of the messages (tracks). This is a serious deficiency and has to be fixed. My normal message page shows all this info but to use that page would require entering a name and password. 3) I use my Spot in all my 3 flying machines - SparrowHawk ultralight, Stemme motorglider and the LSA. So messages seen in the SSA repository might be from either so why does the SSA require you to list the glider manufacturer and model in your profile and repository? Keep the repository simple and remove that unnecessary and not pertinent information. Its always easy to criticize something especially when there are no clear cut presidents. I am very pleased that the SSA has reacted positively to the suggestion made after Thierry's tragic death this summer by I think Marty Hellman that a Spot repository could be a valuable resource in assisting search and rescue missions. I support this. However it is clear this project is still in the formulative mode and needs to be refined for it to become a simple help tool. I would welcome comments on my criticisms and suggestions to make the SSA Spot repository easier to use. Dave |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
SSA Spot Repository
On Oct 24, 2:13*pm, kd6veb wrote:
Hi Gang *I decided I would put my self into the position of a member of a search and rescue which had been alerted that a certain person Dave Bingham was missing and that he was carrying a Spot tracker and that a recording of his flight might be found at the URL ssa.com which has a repository of recent Spot tracks for a few pilots around the US (maybe around the world). Now being an average person I am going to assume (maybe incorrectly) that I know how to turn on a computer and bring up a web browser and even type in the address bar ssa.com and press enter. The SSA home page comes up. *I don't see anything with the words track or Spot. The thought occurs to me did I get the words track and Spot correctly or did I mistake the message. OK what to do? Should I call back the original message giver and ask for clarification or should I play around and explore pages outside the home page? I explore SSA pages and if I am lucky I notice that cunningly hidden on the SSA page at the one from the bottom of the long list is "Sailplane Tracker". That's funny! I was told a glider with a pilot named Dave Bingham was missing. What's a sailplane? Is a sailplane the same as a glider? Anyhow I click on "Sailplane Tracker' and sure enough a list of names come up including Dave Bingham. *I click on the name and the Spot shared page message comes up. Now seeing the Spot message page for the first time is very different from seeing the message page for the hundredth time. What does it say and how do I get information from it? There are no GPS coordinates or times listed only the day on the shared Spot pages. So what to do now? Finally I see an icon that says "show on a map" and I click it. A map comes up and the Spot messages are displayed but which is the first and which is the last in time. Its not obvious which! *Since I view most flights both on SeeYou and Spot everything is intuitively obvious to me now but for a neophyte that is not the case. What I have just described could be a nightmare for many people and could possibly waste valuable time in a search and rescue mission. So lets think through some of the issues I am raising: 1) Many people have very limited understanding of computers so everything should be designed to be INTUITIVELY OBVIOUS. SSA should rethink and redo this valuable Spot repository function and before releasing it test it out on a few average Joe guinea pigs. Make sure that most people can quickly find the relevant information. 2) The Spot shared page does not (at least in my case) show either GPS coordinates nor times of the messages (tracks). This is a serious deficiency and has to be fixed. My normal message page shows all this info but to use that page would require entering a name and password. 3) I use my Spot in all my 3 flying machines - SparrowHawk ultralight, Stemme motorglider and the LSA. So messages seen in the SSA repository might be from either so why does the SSA require you to list the glider manufacturer and model in your profile and repository? Keep the repository simple and remove that unnecessary and not pertinent information. *Its always easy to criticize something especially when there are no clear cut presidents. I am very pleased that the SSA has reacted positively to the suggestion made after Thierry's tragic death this summer by I think Marty Hellman that a Spot repository could be a valuable resource in assisting search and rescue missions. I support this. However it is clear this project is still in the formulative mode and needs to be refined for it to become a simple help tool. I would welcome comments on my criticisms and suggestions to make the SSA Spot repository easier to use. Dave I don't use Spot (yet), and it is the first time I've looked at the page on SSA.org and the Spot repository. It didn't take longer than a couple of minutes for me to find the link and figure out how to acquire the information for tracking point 20. I simply clicked on the Spot Icon on the Map or the + on the left menu. While I'm reasonably conversant with technology, the format seemed to be highly intuitive and in line with the way many programs and internet features like Google Maps have worked for several years - run the cursor on the map until a finger or another change to the cursor icon points to underlying information. 0-7408862Type :Track ProgressLatitude : 39.02135Longitude :-119.75862Time :Saturday, October 24, 2009 5:46:33 PM |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
SSA Spot Repository
On Oct 24, 12:13*pm, kd6veb wrote:
Hi Gang *I decided I would put my self into the position of a member of a search and rescue which had been alerted that a certain person Dave Bingham was missing and that he was carrying a Spot tracker and that a recording of his flight might be found at the URL ssa.com which has a repository of recent Spot tracks for a few pilots around the US (maybe around the world). Now being an average person I am going to assume (maybe incorrectly) that I know how to turn on a computer and bring up a web browser and even type in the address bar ssa.com and press enter. The SSA home page comes up. *I don't see anything with the words track or Spot. The thought occurs to me did I get the words track and Spot correctly or did I mistake the message. OK what to do? Should I call back the original message giver and ask for clarification or should I play around and explore pages outside the home page? I explore SSA pages and if I am lucky I notice that cunningly hidden on the SSA page at the one from the bottom of the long list is "Sailplane Tracker". That's funny! I was told a glider with a pilot named Dave Bingham was missing. What's a sailplane? Is a sailplane the same as a glider? Anyhow I click on "Sailplane Tracker' and sure enough a list of names come up including Dave Bingham. *I click on the name and the Spot shared page message comes up. Now seeing the Spot message page for the first time is very different from seeing the message page for the hundredth time. What does it say and how do I get information from it? There are no GPS coordinates or times listed only the day on the shared Spot pages. So what to do now? Finally I see an icon that says "show on a map" and I click it. A map comes up and the Spot messages are displayed but which is the first and which is the last in time. Its not obvious which! *Since I view most flights both on SeeYou and Spot everything is intuitively obvious to me now but for a neophyte that is not the case. What I have just described could be a nightmare for many people and could possibly waste valuable time in a search and rescue mission. So lets think through some of the issues I am raising: 1) Many people have very limited understanding of computers so everything should be designed to be INTUITIVELY OBVIOUS. SSA should rethink and redo this valuable Spot repository function and before releasing it test it out on a few average Joe guinea pigs. Make sure that most people can quickly find the relevant information. 2) The Spot shared page does not (at least in my case) show either GPS coordinates nor times of the messages (tracks). This is a serious deficiency and has to be fixed. My normal message page shows all this info but to use that page would require entering a name and password. 3) I use my Spot in all my 3 flying machines - SparrowHawk ultralight, Stemme motorglider and the LSA. So messages seen in the SSA repository might be from either so why does the SSA require you to list the glider manufacturer and model in your profile and repository? Keep the repository simple and remove that unnecessary and not pertinent information. *Its always easy to criticize something especially when there are no clear cut presidents. I am very pleased that the SSA has reacted positively to the suggestion made after Thierry's tragic death this summer by I think Marty Hellman that a Spot repository could be a valuable resource in assisting search and rescue missions. I support this. However it is clear this project is still in the formulative mode and needs to be refined for it to become a simple help tool. I would welcome comments on my criticisms and suggestions to make the SSA Spot repository easier to use. Dave Dave, Are you trolling or are you serious? Bottom line is it took me two seconds to find the correct location on the SSA web page and my track today clearly shows time and position on the SPOT tracking page. As for which glider, don't put on if you don't want to; no one is going to care. The page is great and the average search and rescue person is not going to look at the web-page, it is going to be your buddies or spouse who knows where to look. TT |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
SSA Spot Repository
On Oct 24, 8:48*pm, Tim Taylor wrote:
On Oct 24, 12:13*pm, kd6veb wrote: Hi Gang *I decided I would put my self into the position of a member of a search and rescue which had been alerted that a certain person Dave Bingham was missing and that he was carrying a Spot tracker and that a recording of his flight might be found at the URL ssa.com which has a repository of recent Spot tracks for a few pilots around the US (maybe around the world). Now being an average person I am going to assume (maybe incorrectly) that I know how to turn on a computer and bring up a web browser and even type in the address bar ssa.com and press enter. The SSA home page comes up. *I don't see anything with the words track or Spot. The thought occurs to me did I get the words track and Spot correctly or did I mistake the message. OK what to do? Should I call back the original message giver and ask for clarification or should I play around and explore pages outside the home page? I explore SSA pages and if I am lucky I notice that cunningly hidden on the SSA page at the one from the bottom of the long list is "Sailplane Tracker". That's funny! I was told a glider with a pilot named Dave Bingham was missing. What's a sailplane? Is a sailplane the same as a glider? Anyhow I click on "Sailplane Tracker' and sure enough a list of names come up including Dave Bingham. *I click on the name and the Spot shared page message comes up. Now seeing the Spot message page for the first time is very different from seeing the message page for the hundredth time. What does it say and how do I get information from it? There are no GPS coordinates or times listed only the day on the shared Spot pages. So what to do now? Finally I see an icon that says "show on a map" and I click it. A map comes up and the Spot messages are displayed but which is the first and which is the last in time. Its not obvious which! *Since I view most flights both on SeeYou and Spot everything is intuitively obvious to me now but for a neophyte that is not the case. What I have just described could be a nightmare for many people and could possibly waste valuable time in a search and rescue mission. So lets think through some of the issues I am raising: 1) Many people have very limited understanding of computers so everything should be designed to be INTUITIVELY OBVIOUS. SSA should rethink and redo this valuable Spot repository function and before releasing it test it out on a few average Joe guinea pigs. Make sure that most people can quickly find the relevant information. 2) The Spot shared page does not (at least in my case) show either GPS coordinates nor times of the messages (tracks). This is a serious deficiency and has to be fixed. My normal message page shows all this info but to use that page would require entering a name and password. 3) I use my Spot in all my 3 flying machines - SparrowHawk ultralight, Stemme motorglider and the LSA. So messages seen in the SSA repository might be from either so why does the SSA require you to list the glider manufacturer and model in your profile and repository? Keep the repository simple and remove that unnecessary and not pertinent information. *Its always easy to criticize something especially when there are no clear cut presidents. I am very pleased that the SSA has reacted positively to the suggestion made after Thierry's tragic death this summer by I think Marty Hellman that a Spot repository could be a valuable resource in assisting search and rescue missions. I support this. However it is clear this project is still in the formulative mode and needs to be refined for it to become a simple help tool. I would welcome comments on my criticisms and suggestions to make the SSA Spot repository easier to use. Dave Dave, Are you trolling or are you serious? *Bottom line is it took me two seconds to find the correct location on the SSA web page and my track today clearly shows time and position on the SPOT tracking page. *As for which glider, don't put on if you don't want to; no one is going to care. The page is great and the average search and rescue person is not going to look at the web-page, it is going to be your buddies or spouse who knows where to look. TT- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - I've been hearing about this Spot tracking for as long as it's been out. I've never tried to get on a shared page before. Here are my impressions; Went to the SSA site; Easy www.ssa,org Saw the "Track a sailplane icon on the lower right side of the home page; Easy, click on on it. Saw a alphabetical listing of pilots, it ended at the letter G. I went guessed that the letter M might bo on the second page; Easy, click on page 2. Found the name of my friend Steve Mason, it says "Click here"; Easy, click here! Trac comes up with numbered tags for each reported point starting with 1 and ending at 16 (which happen to be the same location) and a map appears under the track and tags. Easy. If you can't figure out what's going on with this system how are you able to do any part of a serious SAR effort, Give me a break! |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Spot deal, today only, buy service get a free Spot | Tim Taylor | Soaring | 3 | December 1st 08 10:30 PM |
Hot Spot | Alan Erskine[_3_] | Aviation Photos | 6 | July 19th 08 07:59 PM |
SPOT | D.Rizzato | General Aviation | 0 | February 5th 08 01:04 AM |
SPOT | D.Rizzato | Piloting | 0 | February 5th 08 12:42 AM |
SPOT | D.Rizzato | Owning | 0 | February 5th 08 12:42 AM |