If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#71
|
|||
|
|||
Back_To_Flying wrote: He is in more danger of dying in a car crash on the way to the airport. Driving is still the most dangerous activity we humans do. Nope, not even close. |
#72
|
|||
|
|||
Just remember --- a car accident is not news unless it's really
unusual. Any aircraft event is considered news by the local media because they don't know any better. |
#73
|
|||
|
|||
Also plane crashes are newsworthy because something bad has happened to
"good" people. I.e., us, friends. Let's step way back for the big picture view, drop the customary caution, and say it: airplane people are from the top drawer of society. We are successful enough to afford flying, smart enough to be able to learn it, and persistent enough to see it through. If it were high school, we're in the top 1% of the class. Not too many crack whores out on the flight line. So, there is melodrama and entertainment value in a news tory where, for example, a dentist and his family make a smoking hole in the ground on Thanksgiving. A gazillion other people from all walks of life also bought it on Thanksgiving in an untold number of mundane ways, but if it happened to one of us, it was news. "G.R. Patterson III" wrote in message ... PaulH wrote: News outlets seem to focus on small plane crashes for reasons I've never understood. Because if it happens frequently, it's not news. They concentrate on them because crashes don't happen very often. George Patterson If a man gets into a fight 3,000 miles away from home, he *had* to have been looking for it. |
#74
|
|||
|
|||
"Mike Rapoport" wrote in message nk.net... "Peter Duniho" wrote in message ... high risk. IMHO, if you and your family are not prepared to lose either you or your husband, then you need to fix that. Whether or not he's flying, bad things can happen, and they won't necessarily wait until the kids are older. If you ARE prepared, then you ought to (IMHO) live life, and not worry so much about whether what you're doing could kill you. Pete Good point and well put! Mike MU-2 Well Said Pete. |
#75
|
|||
|
|||
I think you also have to focus on the safety risks of different kinds of
"driving." A Sunday morning drive on a deserted country lane is quite safe. Anywhere close to a high school at 4 pm on a school day is like Russian roulette. Big city freeways, when not at a standstill, are congested, high speed, tailgating, free-for-alls. I am sure my flying in my plane is safer than my driving on my city freeways. I have to drive about 20 miles on those freeways to get to my airport, and always breathe a sigh of relief that the dangerous part is over when I pull onto the airport ramp. Statistics are relevant to me only if the sample is of people very close to people like me taking risks like mine. It is quite possible that for many of us, our driving is more dangerous than our flying. "Mike Rapoport" wrote in message ink.net... "kontiki" wrote in message ... Here is my opinion, for what it it worth. The safety of flying is very dependent upon the quality of the pilot. Compared to driving a car for example, if some nutcase headed in the opposite direction decides to reach for his beer, your skills as a driver are not worth much. In an airplane you are many times more likely to be a victim of your own stupidity/carelessness/ignorance you name it. On the other hand a cautious pilot is generally not subjected to the degree of idiocy one experiences on the road on a daily basis. Therefore I feel flying is safer for careful and conciencous pilots than driving. You may feel safer but there is no evidence to support your feeling and a lot to refute it. GA has well over 100 times the fatal accident rate of airlines and about 10 time the fatal rate of driving. Personal flying ( as opposed to business, corporate or flight training) has an even higher risk than the average GA rate. Even if you remove all the pilot error accidents, personal flying is still much more dangerous than driving. Mike MU-2 |
#76
|
|||
|
|||
"Dan Thompson" wrote in message . com... I think you also have to focus on the safety risks of different kinds of "driving." A Sunday morning drive on a deserted country lane is quite safe. Anywhere close to a high school at 4 pm on a school day is like Russian roulette. Big city freeways, when not at a standstill, are congested, high speed, tailgating, free-for-alls. I am sure my flying in my plane is safer than my driving on my city freeways. I have to drive about 20 miles on those freeways to get to my airport, and always breathe a sigh of relief that the dangerous part is over when I pull onto the airport ramp. Statistics are relevant to me only if the sample is of people very close to people like me taking risks like mine. It is quite possible that for many of us, our driving is more dangerous than our flying. You will not find any supporting evidence for your assumptions. Any way you want to look at it GA flying is more likely to result in your death than driving many times over. What you would find is that two lane country roads are among the most dangerous. Two way undivided traffic allows for very little error and even single car accidents are spectacular. Divided multilane traffic is among the safest. The Nall report is available on the AOPA WEB site. It makes for interesting reading. |
#77
|
|||
|
|||
"Judah" wrote in message . .. You seem to insist that flying is inherently more dangerous than other modes of transportation, but fail to quote any sources or relevant statistics. I'm with Mike on this. Flying is higher risk than gardening. That doesn't mean we should all switch to growing tomatoes. are caused by "pilot error". But living in the New York area, I am much more sensitive to the fact that many accidents in high traffic areas are caused by errors of ANOTHER driver. Living in Boston I am sensitive to the fact that people around me drive like maniacs. (I on the other hand am merely defensively aggressive) It still doesn't mean flying is safer. There is virtually no trip in an airplane that can't be made safer by car or airliner. Unless you live in Alaska, flying in a small plane for transportation is done for benefits other than risk reduction. Accidents like these are not very likely in GA aircraft. I can't think of any situation in an airborne craft when you would be 2 seconds away from the plane in front of you. And while there are unquestionably mechanical failures that will most likely lead to an accident in an airplane, such as a failed engine, or failed instruments, there are also failures in automobiles that lead to accidents. Some years back, Audi was sued because of failures related to their accelerator and brakes that led to fatalities. Yet another one of the great myths invented by the plaintiff's bar. Despite untold thousands of hours of tests, they were never able to replicate this problem. It ruined Audi's sales here for most of a decade though. Damn shame as they are among the most wonderfully engined machines on four wheels. Tire blowouts can be serious. Sure an engine out is not as likely to cause a fatality on the ground as it is on the air, but a brake failure on a car is much worse in a car on a highway than in a plane in the air (or even on the ground for that matter!). Passenger cars and trucks have dual brake systems. I lost one side of the system in an F-150 on a nice steep hill headed towards a busy intersection. Had no trouble stopping in time. In fact still had enough brakes to drive it to the dealership (I took it slow). I don't lose a moment's sleep on mechanical failures in cars and I drive a middle-aged Ford Escort on which I avoid every repair that isn't necessary to pass inspection or get rid of a noise that might embarass me on a date. Frankly I don't worry so much about mechanicals in my airplane either because I don't spare a dime on maintenance of critical systems. I worry about failure of the primary FMS, aka the pilot, aka Me. Even if I do have a mechanical failure it's likely that the decisions I make will have a large impact on how it turns out. (ie: control my fate)?" And if someone doesn't understand the hows and whys of flying, they will believe it to be out of their control, and be afraid of it. The answer is education... "It is useless to attempt to reason a man out of what he was never reasoned into." (Jonathan Swift) -cwk. |
#78
|
|||
|
|||
|
#79
|
|||
|
|||
Unlike a motorcycle, a pilot gets to choose his
level of risk. LOL, Obviously you do not ride a motorcycle. I race up and down Palomar Mountain, Ortega Highway, and many other popular Southern California sport bike roads. Motorcycle riders definitely choose their own level of risk every time they get onto a motorcycle. However, I do largely accept the premise that when I am flying, the likelihood is that if I have an accident, it will be because of my poor decision process. On the other hand, if I have a motorcycle accident, it is more likely to be an accidental or intentional action from another motorist. |
#80
|
|||
|
|||
Are you assuming that the 1.3/100k fatal accident rate applies to the type of flying that you do? I'll take that bate. Yes, it is one component of the statistic. The 1.3/100K is an aggregate of all types of GA flying. Divide that into different categories of flight (mountain flying, bush flying, IMC, Night, etc: of course being careful that categories don't share population like my examples...) and it is very reasonable to hypothesize that the statistics across types could be very different. Carl |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
What's minimum safe O2 level? | PaulH | Piloting | 29 | November 9th 04 07:35 PM |
Baghdad airport safe to fly ?? | Nemo l'ancien | Military Aviation | 17 | April 9th 04 11:58 PM |
An Algorithm for Defeating CAPS, or how the TSA will make us less safe | Aviv Hod | Piloting | 0 | January 14th 04 01:55 PM |
Fast Safe Plane | Charles Talleyrand | Piloting | 6 | December 30th 03 10:23 PM |
Four Nimitz Aviators Safe after | Otis Willie | Naval Aviation | 0 | July 28th 03 10:31 PM |