If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Emotion tends to remove the analytical, I have found it is very
difficult to convince anyone of your position when their's has become established. For me, the "safety" equation more than balances the "fun" equation. When you are finishing at 50 feet and 150 mph and something goes wrong there really aren't too many options. Rember "Don't try to teach a pig to sing, it probably won't work and it annoys the pig." |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
|
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Hi Gary,
I have no illusions about changing the mind-set of the Neanderthals. I'm continuing this discussion in the hope that contest managers and CD's will see the potential dangers in using the finish gate. Who knows, maybe a Director or two might just be listening, or even the rules committee? JJ At 05:30 17 March 2005, wrote: Emotion tends to remove the analytical, I have found it is very difficult to convince anyone of your position when their's has become established. For me, the 'safety' equation more than balances the 'fun' equation. When you are finishing at 50 feet and 150 mph and something goes wrong there really aren't too many options. Rember 'Don't try to teach a pig to sing, it probably won't work and it annoys the pig.' |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Whille we r on the subject of the Senior's Contest....has
anyone analyzed the average age for these guys vs a 'regular' contest... Is there in fact any significant average age difference between them? At 20:00 17 March 2005, John Sinclair wrote: Hi Gary, I have no illusions about changing the mind-set of the Neanderthals. I'm continuing this discussion in the hope that contest managers and CD's will see the potential dangers in using the finish gate. Who knows, maybe a Director or two might just be listening, or even the rules committee? JJ At 05:30 17 March 2005, wrote: Emotion tends to remove the analytical, I have found it is very difficult to convince anyone of your position when their's has become established. For me, the 'safety' equation more than balances the 'fun' equation. When you are finishing at 50 feet and 150 mph and something goes wrong there really aren't too many options. Rember 'Don't try to teach a pig to sing, it probably won't work and it annoys the pig.' |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Any time you divide a group at some breakpoint (like 55 years of age), the
means will be different; if there are more than a few on each side, they are likely to be statistically significantly different from each other as well. For the Choice Reaction-time "contest" at the convention, the contestants were fairly evenly divided with 101 competitors in the 55 class and 88 in the seniors. The mean ages were 66.26 vs. 42.59 (p0.000). If you drop the "juniors" (age26), you raise the mean for the 55 class to 45.44. The usual disclaimers, of course, apply. Ray Warshaw 1LK "Stewart Kissel" wrote in message ... Whille we r on the subject of the Senior's Contest....has anyone analyzed the average age for these guys vs a 'regular' contest... Is there in fact any significant average age difference between them? At 20:00 17 March 2005, John Sinclair wrote: Hi Gary, I have no illusions about changing the mind-set of the Neanderthals. I'm continuing this discussion in the hope that contest managers and CD's will see the potential dangers in using the finish gate. Who knows, maybe a Director or two might just be listening, or even the rules committee? JJ At 05:30 17 March 2005, wrote: Emotion tends to remove the analytical, I have found it is very difficult to convince anyone of your position when their's has become established. For me, the 'safety' equation more than balances the 'fun' equation. When you are finishing at 50 feet and 150 mph and something goes wrong there really aren't too many options. Rember 'Don't try to teach a pig to sing, it probably won't work and it annoys the pig.' |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
I don't understand the talk about "conflicts" in the finish cylinder.
Everybody is inbound on a radial, heading for the center of the cylinder, when you reach 1 mile, your clock stops. Where is the conflict? Lots of sky out there, 5280 X 3.1416 X 2 = 33,175 feet around it, each radial = 91 feet at 1 mile. There is no "head-on" conflict, because the guy coming at you is on the other side of the cylinder which is 2 miles away. And we don't have my favorite little jewel, "hooking the gate". Let me take a crack at the numbers; The finish line is 1000 meters (3281 feet), but we don't use all of it because we aim for the closest corner, when straight on, we center punch it at the GPS coordinates. So lets divide the finish line by 8 to get 410 feet which I will call the target area (area where a conflict might happen). The finish cylinder circumference is 33,175, but lets take the worst case where everybody is coming from the same turn point and divide it by the same factor of 8 to give us the distance in the 45 degree hunk of pie we're all headed for. That's 4147feet and almost exactly 10 times more distance in the cylinder target area as in the finish line target area. I'm going to say there is 10 times more chance of a conflict at the finish line than there is at the finish cylinder JJ |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Err, okay...so does that mean they are actually an
older group at the seniors? I don't see to many spring-chickens in the 15-Standard-Open Classes. At 00:00 18 March 2005, Raphael Warshaw wrote: Any time you divide a group at some breakpoint (like 55 years of age), the means will be different; if there are more than a few on each side, they are likely to be statistically significantly different from each other as well. For the Choice Reaction-time 'contest' at the convention, the contestants were fairly evenly divided with 101 competitors in the 0.000). If you drop the 'juniors' (age wrote in message ... Whille we r on the subject of the Senior's Contest....has anyone analyzed the average age for these guys vs a 'regular' contest... Is there in fact any significant average age difference between them? At 20:00 17 March 2005, John Sinclair wrote: Hi Gary, I have no illusions about changing the mind-set of the Neanderthals. I'm continuing this discussion in the hope that contest managers and CD's will see the potential dangers in using the finish gate. Who knows, maybe a Director or two might just be listening, or even the rules committee? JJ At 05:30 17 March 2005, wrote: Emotion tends to remove the analytical, I have found it is very difficult to convince anyone of your position when their's has become established. For me, the 'safety' equation more than balances the 'fun' equation. When you are finishing at 50 feet and 150 mph and something goes wrong there really aren't too many options. Rember 'Don't try to teach a pig to sing, it probably won't work and it annoys the pig.' |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Disagree JJ. The exact same scenario is possible - even more likely in
the finish cylinder. One of the more recent weaknesses of the finish line was introduced by GPS. The rules now state that the finish is based on your trace and not whether or not you turned inside a physical feature. To my mind, this is proof positive that our rules makers aren't thinking their decisions through carefully, but are acting based on technological possibility and ground crew convenience. I, for one, don't check the panel for anything but airspeed once I've committed to a gate finish. I can judge my altitude well enough, and I'm much more interested in traffic than which way the nav arrow is pointing. Not the case in the cylinder. I've flown through the latter enough now to know I'm not comfortable with the amount of panel time I need to plan execute my finish. BTW, here's one of the hazards of flying empty. You are much more visible with your comet tail in the finish gate/cylinder. Gosh, as all the legends get older, this sport sure is getting prissy. I'm all for safe... but sterile? ;-) |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
Use a 30 degree course variance from the midpoint of the final leg (15
degrees each side of nominal) of an AST for 10 sailplanes 20 miles out approaching a 1 sm radius cyclinder. There will be an arc on the face of the cylinders described by their course to the midpoint of the cylinder. If they all arrive at the same time and the same altitude, what is their separation? Sorry, I've got time to pose the question, but not enough to answer it. And Andy makes a good point, when they call 4 miles... 4 miles from what? Cheers, OC |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Seniors Contest | Bob Fidler | Soaring | 68 | March 17th 05 03:50 AM |
2005 Region 7 Contest | Paul Remde | Soaring | 0 | August 13th 04 03:48 AM |
Survival and Demise Kit; Contest Points | Jim Culp | Soaring | 1 | June 21st 04 04:35 AM |
USA Double Seater Contest | Thomas Knauff | Soaring | 1 | April 13th 04 05:24 PM |
30th Annual CCSC Soaring Contest | Mario Crosina | Soaring | 0 | March 17th 04 06:31 AM |