If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
What's more, it is possible, though difficult, to fly slower than Vs and NOT
stall. Trivially, when the plane is standing on the ground, it is not stalled. If you botch a loop you can easily end up inverted at the top of a loop with almost zero airspeed, and not be stalled. Of course in normal flight it's very hard to lose speed without stalling, but if you pull vertical you can do it. It's true that if you're below Vs and not stalled, you won't have much lift either and you'll be falling. But the airflow is still attached to the wing, and hence you are not stalled. John "ShawnD2112" wrote in message ... Chris, It IS a myth. Stall is related to critical angle of attack and has absolutely nothing to do with airspeed. The quoted stall speeds are based on very important assumptions of configuration and power setting. Typically when people talk about the stall speed of an airplane, they mean V0, which is clean, flaps up, power off. You can stall the airplane at Vne if you pull hard enough. There are enough warbird accidents where the pilot stalled at the bottom of the loop and flopped flat into the ground to prove the theory. Shawn "Chris Hoffmann" wrote in message ... The first thing that jumped out at me from your report is this: Another myth cited in the AOPA study is "watch your airspeed, or you're going to stall this airplane!" Pardon me, but if your airspeed gets below stall speed, you ARE going to stall. Further, if your airspeed is below the usual 1.3 Vso safety cushion, you are getting to the point where all it takes is a turn too steep, or a bit of tailwind, or a yank back on the yoke, and you are LIKELY to stall. This is not "myth". On the other hand, this: "Just don't let airspeed get below a safe value and stalls are not a problem." is not an axiom to fly by. Students *should* know/be taught that a stall can occur at any speed, any attitude, of course. But I see nothing wrong with training students to keep their airspeed where it's supposed to be in the pattern and on approach, which, I believe, is the context from which those two quoted remarks were taken. -- Chris Hoffmann Student Pilot @ UES 30 hours |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|