If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Tow cars and trailers
Well, gas is $3.50/Gal in many parts of the US and who is to say it won't be
$4/gal next summer. This is starting to hurt - and getting me to think of a more economical vehicle. Many of us drive larger vehicles than we might otherwise choose simply to pull our trailers 1% of the time. 99% of the time, we could be driving, say, a Volkswagen Passat TDI diesel getting 45mpg. The problem isn't the gas milage when towing a glider trailer. We don't do that often enough for it to impact out annual fuel budget. The problem is a big SUV as a daily driver. So, are there any tricks here? One is to simply own two cars. One to pull a trailer and another for a daily driver that gets good milage. Paying license fees, insurance and other fixed costs for a vehicle driven 1% of the time seems outrageous though. The other thread about surge brakes got me thinking WAY outside the box. Is there a way for the trailer to be self-propelled? If one were to install a load sensor in the trailer tongue that could sense the pull of the tow vehicle as well as the push of an over-running trailer, could that control a small power plant in the trailer that drove the trailer's wheels? If done perfectly, a light towing vehicle might not feel the trailer at all. If the trailer power were electric, you would have a parallel, plug-in hybrid. The car engine would charge the trailer batteries when they were not needed for propulsion and the electrics would kick in on the hills. Downhill regenerative braking would also charge the trailer batteries as could large solar panels on the trailer. It might work fine for a short commute to the glider field and maybe not so well on a cross country trip but it's fun thinking about. Bill Daniels |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Tow cars and trailers
Bill Daniels schrieb:
Many of us drive larger vehicles than we might otherwise choose simply to pull our trailers 1% of the time. 99% of the time, we could be driving, say, a Volkswagen Passat TDI diesel getting 45mpg. The Volkswagen Passat TDI is a fairly common tow vehicle in Europe. No need for a SUV. But then, this has been discussed here many times. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Tow cars and trailers
"anonymous" no.email@spamfree wrote in message ... Bill Daniels schrieb: Many of us drive larger vehicles than we might otherwise choose simply to pull our trailers 1% of the time. 99% of the time, we could be driving, say, a Volkswagen Passat TDI diesel getting 45mpg. The Volkswagen Passat TDI is a fairly common tow vehicle in Europe. No need for a SUV. But then, this has been discussed here many times. Yes, I know that. However, it's not common in the US bacause of the higher, hotter, longer trip conditions here. Almost any trip in the western US will include at least one long, steep grade starting with temperatures above 40C that may climb to 3600 meters ASL. I know of one VW that arrived as essentially junk after one trip. The next time I saw that pilot, he was driving a much bigger tow vehicle. If you prefer the manufacturer's position, here's a comment from USA Today's James R. Healey:: "Back to the Passat towing spec question: VW just called to say towing's not recommended with the Passat and that's why no towing spec is provided. Would towing void the warranty? Uh, um, well, probably not, VW says, as long as you tow light loads with a proper hitch installed and used per the aftermarket supplier's recommendations. Unless, of course, some damage is the obvious result of towing. Sounds to me as if anybody who wants to tow should choose a different car. Too much 'maybe' factor with Passat. " The VW Passat TDI diesel is a great car. I just wouldn't abuse it by towing a glider trailer. Bill Daniels |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Tow cars and trailers
On May 18, 12:48 am, "Bill Daniels" bildan@comcast-dot-net wrote:
Yes, I know that. However, it's not common in the US bacause of the higher, hotter, longer trip conditions here. Almost any trip in the western US will include at least one long, steep grade starting with temperatures above 40C that may climb to 3600 meters ASL. I know of one VW that arrived as essentially junk after one trip. The next time I saw that pilot, he was driving a much bigger tow vehicle. I can only think that it was very old or not maintained. Gliders are light; a modern European TDi would barely notice the load even over the roads you describe (which are common in the Alps). Dan |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Tow cars and trailers
Bill Daniels wrote:
"anonymous" no.email@spamfree wrote in message ... Bill Daniels schrieb: Many of us drive larger vehicles than we might otherwise choose simply to pull our trailers 1% of the time. 99% of the time, we could be driving, say, a Volkswagen Passat TDI diesel getting 45mpg. The Volkswagen Passat TDI is a fairly common tow vehicle in Europe. No need for a SUV. But then, this has been discussed here many times. Yes, I know that. However, it's not common in the US bacause of the higher, hotter, longer trip conditions here. Almost any trip in the western US will include at least one long, steep grade starting with temperatures above 40C that may climb to 3600 meters ASL. I know of one VW that arrived as essentially junk after one trip. The next time I saw that pilot, he was driving a much bigger tow vehicle. If you prefer the manufacturer's position, here's a comment from USA Today's James R. Healey:: "Back to the Passat towing spec question: VW just called to say towing's not recommended with the Passat and that's why no towing spec is provided. Would towing void the warranty? Uh, um, well, probably not, VW says, as long as you tow light loads with a proper hitch installed and used per the aftermarket supplier's recommendations. Unless, of course, some damage is the obvious result of towing. Sounds to me as if anybody who wants to tow should choose a different car. Too much 'maybe' factor with Passat. " The VW Passat TDI diesel is a great car. I just wouldn't abuse it by towing a glider trailer. Bill Daniels Bill, I have to agree with Dan. With the TDI (turbocharged diesel injection) the elevation would have almost no effect. Yes, pulling up the hills would work the engine a bit, but gearing down and watching the temps should cover that. Ed |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Tow cars and trailers
At 00:48 18 May 2007, Ed Winchester wrote:
Bill Daniels wrote: 'anonymous' wrote in message ... Bill Daniels schrieb: Many of us drive larger vehicles than we might otherwise choose simply to pull our trailers 1% of the time. 99% of the time, we could be driving, say, a Volkswagen Passat TDI diesel getting 45mpg. The Volkswagen Passat TDI is a fairly common tow vehicle in Europe. No need for a SUV. But then, this has been discussed here many times. Yes, I know that. However, it's not common in the US bacause of the higher, hotter, longer trip conditions here. Almost any trip in the western US will include at least one long, steep grade starting with temperatures above 40C that may climb to 3600 meters ASL. I know of one VW that arrived as essentially junk after one trip. The next time I saw that pilot, he was driving a much bigger tow vehicle. If you prefer the manufacturer's position, here's a comment from USA Today's James R. Healey:: 'Back to the Passat towing spec question: VW just called to say towing's not recommended with the Passat and that's why no towing spec is provided. Would towing void the warranty? Uh, um, well, probably not, VW says, as long as you tow light loads with a proper hitch installed and used per the aftermarket supplier's recommendations. Unless, of course, some damage is the obvious result of towing. Sounds to me as if anybody who wants to tow should choose a different car. Too much 'maybe' factor with Passat. ' The VW Passat TDI diesel is a great car. I just wouldn't abuse it by towing a glider trailer. Bill Daniels Bill, I have to agree with Dan. With the TDI (turbocharged diesel injection) the elevation would have almost no effect. Yes, pulling up the hills would work the engine a bit, but gearing down and watching the temps should cover that. Ed I think we must be careful not to use too light of a vehicle to tow our glider trailers with. Although the 2:1 ratio some trailer rental companies use ('U-Haul used to require 2:1 ratio between the towing vehicle and the trailer. Stated differently, the towing vehicle must weigh twice as much as the trailer and its contents. To increase rentals, U-Haul lowered that ratio from 2:1 to 1:1. This change decreased stability and increased accidents'.--from http://www.beasleyallen.com) may be suitable for short coupled trailers, our glider trailers although admittedly light in weight, have much greater moments due to the longer arm, so for me at least, that unfortunately rules out small, lightweight super efficient vehicles, due to safety concerns. I did find this in another thread though, talking about glider towing with a Toyota Highlander Hybrid: 'I'll add my two cents to this thread. I towed my glider trailer last weekend with a HH 4wd. Glider trailers are tricky to tow because of their length (28') and the fact that they have a lot of sail area. Weight is about 1800 lbs. The rig was rock solid in mountainous terrain with a 25 mph crosswind. Was at least as good as my previous vehicle, a Grand Cherokee. I am quite pleased with the performance. Overall, I am getting about 26-27 MPG'. found in: http://townhall-talk.edmunds.com/direct/view/.f0daea6 I like the idea of good gas mileage, since I tow mine enough for that to be a major budget concern, for me. (Ca to Memphis last Feb, Ca to Oshkosh later, plus several milk runs...ouch) I currently tow with a Chevy Astro Van, and get around 18-19mpg, doing normal interstate speeds (70-80mph), so 26-27mpg does not sound too bad, although I would need a motel when I got where I was going because the Highlander Hybrid does not sound big enough for me to camp in with my dog while on site. It does sound like a good possible solution for some of you though. I do really like the idea of some sort of drive-assist system in the trailer though, an idea I've considered before, although my gas mileage without the trailer is near the same in the Astro. Somebody needs to develop a hybrid van, with good towing capacity, coupled to a trailer that assists and then we would be on to something. Although, the excessive cost of this combo would probably outweigh the extra money that would be saved on gas, it seems like a step in the right direction none the less. Paul Hanson "Do the usual, unusually well"--Len Niemi |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Tow cars and trailers
On May 18, 3:14 pm, Paul Hanson
wrote: At 00:48 18 May 2007, Ed Winchester wrote: Bill Daniels wrote: 'anonymous' wrote in message . ch... Bill Daniels schrieb: Many of us drive larger vehicles than we might otherwise choose simply to pull our trailers 1% of the time. 99% of the time, we could be driving, say, a Volkswagen Passat TDI diesel getting 45mpg. The Volkswagen Passat TDI is a fairly common tow vehicle in Europe. No need for a SUV. But then, this has been discussed here many times. Yes, I know that. However, it's not common in the US bacause of the higher, hotter, longer trip conditions here. Almost any trip in the western US will include at least one long, steep grade starting with temperatures above 40C that may climb to 3600 meters ASL. I know of one VW that arrived as essentially junk after one trip. The next time I saw that pilot, he was driving a much bigger tow vehicle. If you prefer the manufacturer's position, here's a comment from USA Today's James R. Healey:: 'Back to the Passat towing spec question: VW just called to say towing's not recommended with the Passat and that's why no towing spec is provided. Would towing void the warranty? Uh, um, well, probably not, VW says, as long as you tow light loads with a proper hitch installed and used per the aftermarket supplier's recommendations. Unless, of course, some damage is the obvious result of towing. Sounds to me as if anybody who wants to tow should choose a different car. Too much 'maybe' factor with Passat. ' The VW Passat TDI diesel is a great car. I just wouldn't abuse it by towing a glider trailer. Bill Daniels Bill, I have to agree with Dan. With the TDI (turbocharged diesel injection) the elevation would have almost no effect. Yes, pulling up the hills would work the engine a bit, but gearing down and watching the temps should cover that. Ed I think we must be careful not to use too light of a vehicle to tow our glider trailers with. Although the 2:1 ratio some trailer rental companies use ('U-Haul used to require 2:1 ratio between the towing vehicle and the trailer. Stated differently, the towing vehicle must weigh twice as much as the trailer and its contents. To increase rentals, U-Haul lowered that ratio from 2:1 to 1:1. This change decreased stability and increased accidents'.--fromhttp://www.beasleyallen.com) may be suitable for short coupled trailers, our glider trailers although admittedly light in weight, have much greater moments due to the longer arm, so for me at least, that unfortunately rules out small, lightweight super efficient vehicles, due to safety concerns. I did find this in another thread though, talking about glider towing with a Toyota Highlander Hybrid: 'I'll add my two cents to this thread. I towed my glider trailer last weekend with a HH 4wd. Glider trailers are tricky to tow because of their length (28') and the fact that they have a lot of sail area. Weight is about 1800 lbs. The rig was rock solid in mountainous terrain with a 25 mph crosswind. Was at least as good as my previous vehicle, a Grand Cherokee. I am quite pleased with the performance. Overall, I am getting about 26-27 MPG'. found in:http://townhall-talk.edmunds.com/direct/view/.f0daea6 I like the idea of good gas mileage, since I tow mine enough for that to be a major budget concern, for me. (Ca to Memphis last Feb, Ca to Oshkosh later, plus several milk runs...ouch) I currently tow with a Chevy Astro Van, and get around 18-19mpg, doing normal interstate speeds (70-80mph), so 26-27mpg does not sound too bad, although I would need a motel when I got where I was going because the Highlander Hybrid does not sound big enough for me to camp in with my dog while on site. It does sound like a good possible solution for some of you though. I do really like the idea of some sort of drive-assist system in the trailer though, an idea I've considered before, although my gas mileage without the trailer is near the same in the Astro. Somebody needs to develop a hybrid van, with good towing capacity, coupled to a trailer that assists and then we would be on to something. Although, the excessive cost of this combo would probably outweigh the extra money that would be saved on gas, it seems like a step in the right direction none the less. Paul Hanson "Do the usual, unusually well"--Len Niemi- Hide quoted text - - Show quoted text - A little sideways on this thread ,how does a Chevy Blazer 4.3 litre, handle the towing loads as I am considering one as a tow vehicle ,pulling a tube type of trailer for a Ventus b or Nimbus 2 model. Any bad reports or known problems I should be aware of . gary |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Tow cars and trailers
I think it's important to be clear what we're talking about here. A VW
Passat TDi station wagon has a combined mpg of 48 and a long-run mpg of 58, with 236lbs/ft of torque at 1,750rpm. The car has a kerbweight of 3,500lbs and using the figure of 85%* of kerbweight to give towing capacity, that allows trailers of up to 3,000lbs to be towed comfortably. *85% kerbweight - with 7% of the trailer's weight on the hitch or the tow car's maximum, whichever is lower - is the maximum safe weight for good stability, arrived at by the University of Bath in the 1990s when they did instrumented testing and model simulation of tow cars and trailer combinations. Dan |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Tow cars and trailers
Dan G wrote:
I think it's important to be clear what we're talking about here. A VW Passat TDi station wagon has a combined mpg of 48 and a long-run mpg of 58, with 236lbs/ft of torque at 1,750rpm. The car has a kerbweight of 3,500lbs and using the figure of 85%* of kerbweight to give towing capacity, that allows trailers of up to 3,000lbs to be towed comfortably. *85% kerbweight - with 7% of the trailer's weight on the hitch or the tow car's maximum, whichever is lower - is the maximum safe weight for good stability, arrived at by the University of Bath in the 1990s when they did instrumented testing and model simulation of tow cars and trailer combinations. Dan Closed Trailer with a Std Cirrus in it is 680kg (54% is easily inside the 85%)The sail effect is a bigger decider for me - the trailer can push a smaller car around when you are exposed to gusts at speed. Hatchback weight is 1250Kg. Tows happily at the national speed limit, although it does get a bit hard work in the mountains. Tops of our passes are around 2,300m MSL Nothing too bad for the small car to tow. Then I got into a Kestrel T59D with one piece wings. It's trailer is unaerodynamic, heavy (900Kg) and just plain huge. The stability issue is in a different class. With nearly 2 tons of Wales' best (XC70 is made in Wales not Sweden) and a really big polar moment on such a long vehicle, the disturbance from trucks and wind is a lot lower. Fuel consumption is not that different towing the trailer between the two - unless you get irresponsible/inattentive with the speed. The control reserve is generally bigger with the bigger car. So stability is the primary towing reason for getting the barge - the other reasons are indefensible. (It's hard making a logical case for something that comes down to - "I like it".)In town the hatchback is the place to be - on the open road or dirt roads the Volvo is a far nicer ride. Cost - @ 2l/100km additional fuel is around 400litres per year. (roughly 100US gallons)At ~R7/l (4USD/US gallon) that is quite a lot of money. In South Africa the cost of my vehicular extravagance is equivalent to at least one tow per month. I winch launch so the extra fuel for the trip to the airfield is close to the cost of a winch launch. |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Tow cars and trailers
On May 17, 11:14 pm, Paul Hanson
wrote: I think we must be careful not to use too light of a vehicle to tow our glider trailers with. Although the 2:1 ratio some trailer rental companies use ('U-Haul used to require 2:1 ratio between the towing vehicle and the trailer. Stated differently, the towing vehicle must weigh twice as much as the trailer and its contents. To increase rentals, U-Haul lowered that ratio from 2:1 to 1:1. This change decreased stability and increased accidents'.--fromhttp://www.beasleyallen.com) may be suitable for short coupled trailers, our glider trailers although admittedly light in weight, have much greater moments due to the longer arm, so for me at least, that unfortunately rules out small, lightweight super efficient vehicles, due to safety concerns. I did find this in another thread though, talking about glider towing with a Toyota Highlander Hybrid: 'I'll add my two cents to this thread. I towed my glider trailer last weekend with a HH 4wd. Glider trailers are tricky to tow because of their length (28') and the fact that they have a lot of sail area. Weight is about 1800 lbs. The rig was rock solid in mountainous terrain with a 25 mph crosswind. Was at least as good as my previous vehicle, a Grand Cherokee. I am quite pleased with the performance. Overall, I am getting about 26-27 MPG'. found in:http://townhall-talk.edmunds.com/direct/view/.f0daea6 I like the idea of good gas mileage, since I tow mine enough for that to be a major budget concern, for me. (Ca to Memphis last Feb, Ca to Oshkosh later, plus several milk runs...ouch) I currently tow with a Chevy Astro Van, and get around 18-19mpg, doing normal interstate speeds (70-80mph), so 26-27mpg does not sound too bad, although I would need a motel when I got where I was going because the Highlander Hybrid does not sound big enough for me to camp in with my dog while on site. It does sound like a good possible solution for some of you though. I do really like the idea of some sort of drive-assist system in the trailer though, an idea I've considered before, although my gas mileage without the trailer is near the same in the Astro. Somebody needs to develop a hybrid van, with good towing capacity, coupled to a trailer that assists and then we would be on to something. Although, the excessive cost of this combo would probably outweigh the extra money that would be saved on gas, it seems like a step in the right direction none the less. Paul Hanson "Do the usual, unusually well"--Len Niemi Also consider the Ford Escape/Mercury Mariner hybrids (aka FEH or MMH). Curb weight 3800lbs, 35-40mpg with good driving techniques. Supposedly there's a Toyota hybrid minivan coming one of these days (it's been available in Japan for several years now) that includes electric drive on the rear wheels (like the HyHi). Personally I have a Prius as my wife's car, which I love except for the fact that it can't tow anything. One additional consideration is to think further outside the box. What about using public transportation, bicycling, or telecommuting for your daily grind? You can keep the gashog around for the weekends. When I was riding the bus every day to work my gas usage in my truck dropped to around 1 tank a month (300 miles or so), which is enough to keep it running well but not enough to be a financial drag. I also got a break on car insurance because I wasn't using it for daily commute. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Flying Cars | bryan chaisone | Home Built | 2 | September 10th 04 07:01 PM |
Flying Cars | bryan chaisone | Rotorcraft | 0 | September 10th 04 01:57 PM |
Air cars ? | Felger Carbon | Home Built | 9 | January 3rd 04 07:41 AM |
Air cars will never fly (911 more reasons) | [email protected] | Piloting | 36 | October 4th 03 03:26 PM |
(was) Air cars will never fly (911 more reasons) | Montblack | Owning | 6 | September 29th 03 08:56 PM |