If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
WWGC.
On Friday, 17 January 2020 20:11:52 UTC+2, wrote:
Now that the information is out, it seems a fair penalty. Unfortunate for the pilots, impossible to know the degree of complicity there, if any. I'd feel like a pretty big idiot right now if I was the coach of Jo Davis. This took her off the podium at a world championship. That will sting. The advantage of cheating was used (to whatever degree) every day of the contest and so to me the penalty now seems appropriate. That said I really have no idea, I'm not a contest pilot, but it would equate to about a 20 point penalty per day, eliminating any real likelyhood of winning, which it should. Seems obvious to me that any reasonably honest soul can see that hacking the tracking info is unfair play, and would obviously be illegal. The 15 min. delay is there for obvious reasons. It's a soaring contest, not an IT contest. It doesn't need to be written down anywhere to be enforced. It's cheating. And it seems there is a larger and larger group of people that are able to come up with justifications for what is obviously that. True, it was a fair penalty and this is going to be an important precedent. "Ground controlling" the pilots is something that whole team has to bear the responsibility, not only the guy on the ground telling relaying info. Medal was lost because of the penalty, but it might as well be won because of cheating. |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
WWGC.
Doping race horses, throwing a boxing match, stealing baseball signals,
and now this.Â* Whoda thunk it? On 1/17/2020 12:09 PM, krasw wrote: On Friday, 17 January 2020 20:11:52 UTC+2, wrote: Now that the information is out, it seems a fair penalty. Unfortunate for the pilots, impossible to know the degree of complicity there, if any. I'd feel like a pretty big idiot right now if I was the coach of Jo Davis. This took her off the podium at a world championship. That will sting. The advantage of cheating was used (to whatever degree) every day of the contest and so to me the penalty now seems appropriate. That said I really have no idea, I'm not a contest pilot, but it would equate to about a 20 point penalty per day, eliminating any real likelyhood of winning, which it should. Seems obvious to me that any reasonably honest soul can see that hacking the tracking info is unfair play, and would obviously be illegal. The 15 min. delay is there for obvious reasons. It's a soaring contest, not an IT contest. It doesn't need to be written down anywhere to be enforced. It's cheating. And it seems there is a larger and larger group of people that are able to come up with justifications for what is obviously that. True, it was a fair penalty and this is going to be an important precedent. "Ground controlling" the pilots is something that whole team has to bear the responsibility, not only the guy on the ground telling relaying info. Medal was lost because of the penalty, but it might as well be won because of cheating. -- Dan, 5J |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
WWGC.
Huge resources are committed to WGC. I think the organizers and the sanctioning body owe the competitors a fair competition at a minimum.
225 pts means you aren't serious about the infraction, and you look forward to more of the same. T8 |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
WWGC.
Huge resources are committed to WGC. I think the organizers and the
sanctioning body owe the competitors a fair competition at a minimum. 225 pts means you aren't serious about the infraction, and you look forward to more of the same. Congratulations to Sarah Arnold !and every other competitor who abided by the rules, explicit and implicit)!!! Opining as someone 100% ignorant of the rules as they apply to this sort of cheating, were I king, the entire team woulda been disqualified, end of discussion. Kinda-sorta related, can anyone advise me where I can go to have my moral compass inexpensively removed? Bob W. |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
WWGC.
It cost one pilot a win, that’s a pretty fair sanction.
|
#16
|
|||
|
|||
WWGC.
At 22:21 17 January 2020, Charlie Quebec wrote:
It cost one pilot a win, that=E2=80=99s a pretty fair sanction. So having looked at the rules, I can't see anything which forbids this in this competition. No 'hacking' was involved. There are lots of freely available sites that show the live data. The UK competition rules were changed last year to specifically forbid this, but the rules of this comp don't appear to have done so. I wonder what the US rules say? |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
WWGC.
The problem was accessing the live tracking without a delay, via pst access allowed. This gave an unfair advantage apparently.
|
#18
|
|||
|
|||
WWGC.
On Friday, January 17, 2020 at 6:00:05 PM UTC-5, Al McNamara wrote:
At 22:21 17 January 2020, Charlie Quebec wrote: It cost one pilot a win, that=E2=80=99s a pretty fair sanction. So having looked at the rules, I can't see anything which forbids this in this competition. No 'hacking' was involved. There are lots of freely available sites that show the live data. The UK competition rules were changed last year to specifically forbid this, but the rules of this comp don't appear to have done so. I wonder what the US rules say? I'm guessing that it was from Local Procedures V9.1 para 4.1.1.c: Carriage of GNSS data transmitters for public displays The organizers will require competing sailplanes to carry GNSS data transmitters to enable the public display of GNSS flight records during competition flights. Such display will not begin before the start line is opened and the actual positions of the sailplanes shall be displayed with a time delay of at least 15 minutes. This delay may be reduced to zero prior the finish.. |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
WWGC.
At 23:11 17 January 2020, Dan Daly wrote:
On Friday, January 17, 2020 at 6:00:05 PM UTC-5, Al McNamara wrote: At 22:21 17 January 2020, Charlie Quebec wrote: It cost one pilot a win, that=3DE2=3D80=3D99s a pretty fair sanction. So having looked at the rules, I can't see anything which forbids this in this competition. No 'hacking' was involved. There are lots of freely available sites that show the live data. =20 The UK competition rules were changed last year to specifically forbid this, but the rules of this comp don't appear to have done so. I wonder what the US rules say? I'm guessing that it was from Local Procedures V9.1 para 4.1.1.c: Carriage = of GNSS data transmitters for public displays The organizers will require competing sailplanes to carry GNSS data transmi= tters to enable the public display of GNSS flight records during competitio= n flights. Such display will not begin before the start line is opened and = the actual positions of the sailplanes shall be displayed with a time delay= of at least 15 minutes. This delay may be reduced to zero prior the finish= But nothing which forbids teams from accessing live data via any of the many sites that show it, and nothing which restricts what teams can discuss with pilots on the allocated frequencies. I'm not suggesting that we should be allowing this in competitions going forward (but ultimately do wonder how it can be effectively policed) rather questioning whether any rules in this comp were actually broken. |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
WWGC.
If anything, the penality response to the 2019 WWGC "real time tracking" has sent the message its OK to cheat in FAI soaring competitions. How disgraceful, how disappointing! A one-time 225 point penality is absurd considering it "covers" 9 days of scoring.
So the question ... what should the penality be in this instance? Opining: First, team pilots should be given a contest score of 1 point per contest day. Following: Team management, technicians, and pilots should be banned from the premisess of any World Gliding Championships for the next two championships. Directed to Eric Mozer and Rick Sheppe: It is my deepest hope the IGC will amend Annex A to install harsher penalties for rule infractions deemed "Unsporting Behavior". Above and beyond all, soaring needs to eliminate cheating. IGC, please step up. |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Pre- WWGC and Australian Club and Standard Class Nationals | JS[_5_] | Soaring | 3 | January 9th 19 11:53 AM |
WWGC | Duster | Soaring | 14 | June 3rd 17 04:17 PM |
Podium Finish for Sarah at WWGC!! | Linwood Stevenson | Soaring | 6 | July 15th 13 01:56 PM |
2013 WWGC .... | Ron Gleason | Soaring | 9 | July 12th 13 09:51 PM |
Few impressions from WWGC 2009 Szeged (HUN) | db | Soaring | 1 | August 4th 09 03:01 PM |