If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Handheld Nav/Com suggestions?
The OTHER Kevin in San Diego skiddz*AT*adelphia*DOT*net wrote:
I'm kinda leaning towards the ICOM A23 for what I think may be a "silly" reason. NiMH batteries. I'm not at all keen on carrying alkalines with me all the time and I've seen 1st hand the "memory" problems inherent with NiCd batteries. The small size and weight are pros as well. If you will be using the radio and charging the batteries regularly, then NiMH is a good choice. However, if you plan to throw the radio in your flight bag and expect it to work six months from now (especially for transmitting), the NiMH batteries will have long since self-discharged. Alkalines have a long shelf life, but are heavier, and the A23 at least will not transmit at all when powered by alkalines. After lots of experimenting with the A23 and different battery combinations, I finally chose the Sportys SP-200 powered by photo lithium AAs. A full set of eight costs about $20, but they have a long shelf life, and are about half the weight of alkalines. My SP-200 with lithium AAs weighs about the same as an A23 with a set of alkalines. Other advantages of the SP-200 over the A23: - The 8.33 khz channel spacing, as you already noted. Like the changeover from 360 to 720 to 760 channels, this change will happen gradually over time, with the newer frequencies being assigned to services like ASOS, ATIS, clearance delivery, etc. The SP-200 will extend the life of my aircraft radio by allowing me to access these new frequencies. - The A23's CDI is so TINY as to be unusable. - The A23 will receive the audio of localizer frequencies, but the CDI is non-functional. The SP-200's CDI will work on localizers. - I don't like the recessed keys of the A23. The one aspect of the A23 I like over the SP-200 is the ability to use one of the knobs to dial a VOR radial. The SP-200 requires the desired radial be entered via the keypad. Before you make your choice, beg, borrow, or steal (temporarily) the handheld you are considering, and take it for some in-flight trials. It always amazes me how many people carry handhelds for "emergency" use, but have never once taken them out of the bag in flight. What is its range in your aircraft? Does it work with your headset? How easy/difficult is it to work the controls while flying the plane? Happy landings, Ross Oliver |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
On Mon, 13 Sep 2004 06:07:43 +0000, Ross Oliver wrote:
First, let me say great comparison. I googled for this very topic and stumbled on this thread. So, thanks! Second, I'm sorry to jump in, but I didn't think you would mind. [snip] If you will be using the radio and charging the batteries regularly, then NiMH is a good choice. However, if you plan to throw the radio in your flight bag and expect it to work six months from now (especially for transmitting), the NiMH batteries will have long since self-discharged. Alkalines have a long shelf life, but are heavier, and the A23 at least will not transmit at all when powered by alkalines. Why would the A23 prevent someone from transmitting when using alkalines? Most nicads only put out 1.2 volts. Really nice nicads will put out ~1.25 volts, but tend to be very expenseive (for batteries) and much harder to find. An alkaline puts out 1.5 volts. The difference in power may make the difference between transmitting at full power (5 watts) and transmitting at something much less. Also, power density for alkalines is normally much higher than what you typically find for nicads. Which means, generally speaking, a set of alkalines will last longer when it's in use; though clearly I am making some assumptions here. And, as you rightly pointed out, a set of alkalines can last a very long time in a flight bag. Whereas, a set of nicads will be almost fully discharged within 30-60 days; again, depending on your batteries. Alkaline batteries also slowly discharge, whereas, nicads act like they jumped off a cliff when nearly discharged. This means, with a set of alkalines, you can usually pick and choose when you want to change your batteries. Not to mention, you'll generally know when it's time. With a set of nicads, you may be transmitting fine one second, only to find that your batteries are completely dead the next. Long story show, your comment struck me as odd. Is the transmission limitation built into the radio's electronics or did it come from a personal observation? What's the basis for your comment? Thanks in advance, Greg |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Handheld Nav/Com suggestions? | Vaughn | Products | 2 | November 21st 04 08:45 PM |
Handheld Nav/Com suggestions? | Vaughn | Rotorcraft | 0 | September 12th 04 03:42 PM |
Handheld Nav/Com Radios | Dave Burton | Piloting | 17 | August 24th 04 05:12 PM |
Upgrade handheld GPS, or save for panel mount? | [email protected] | Owning | 7 | March 8th 04 03:33 PM |
Ext antenna connection for handheld radio | Ray Andraka | Owning | 7 | March 5th 04 01:10 PM |