If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
NIMH Batteries
I've used NiMH cells to make my glfider battery for over 5 years now.
I always charge them with an RC Hobby charger, they have given excellent performance. The reason I went to 11 cells is to get 14 volts so as to insure that my aircraft radio did not drop off due to low voltage at the end of the day (10.5 v is the cutoff for most radios). The reason for not using Li chemestry cells is concern for possible overheating, bursting of cells, and resultant "Very Energetic" fire from the release of the Lithium inside the cells. The RC hobby has burned down well over 100 houses, apartments, cars, trucks, model planes and garages during the learning phases of using LiPoly chemistry cells. They require extreme care in all phases of use to avoid catching fire when overcharged, over-discharged, or compromising the plastic cases. Currentlfy the biggest issue is "Balancing " them so that one or more cells don't reach full charge prematurely. This requires a tap on each cell led out to a balancing set of circuitry. All this information, advice and hardware information is freely available on the RC Forums. The Li-ion and LiFe (A123) chemistries are also suseptable to these events, but because of the steel cases, like NiCad & NiMh, will resist abuse better than LiPoly. In actual practice they still use specialized charging and balancing circuits, and usually over- discharging circuits, esp. in consumer devices such as Laptops and Cameras. IMHO the NiMH is the most reasonable replacement for the SLA batteries, unless you really want to be on the cutting edge (Bleeding Edge) of the Li technology. I was also unaware that many others had equiped their gliders with NiMh batteries and and had uniformly good results with their use. BTW, I take issue with; "Both LiFePO4 series (of batteries) are claimed to be able to be charged on most standard lead acid chargers (set for AGM/GEL cells)", unless a complete set of charging and balancing circuity is included in the package. And at the prices quoted, they really should be!! Happy thermals, Wayne |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
NIMH Batteries
At 19:11 04 December 2008, K M wrote:
I had similar thoughts some months ago. Being the owner of a DG glider, I asked them for advice on NiMH & lithium based systems. The answers we "We several times have discussed this topic. No doubt about that you can store more electric power in the same compartment with the same weight. But you will need a special charger and we have to make a "Technical Note" after having tested all technical questions with this new power system (Temperature, Danger of Fire etc.) On the other hand the battery of a self launcher always is big enough. And we are supplying solar cells. With this eqipment you never will have any electric power problems. Often we do not have any problems with the weight because the batteries are used as a counter weight for the correct C/G. This all is the reason why we have not made such an investigations." and... "You just cannot change the battery system by your own. That is a "Major Change" and must be certified by the manufacturer. ........ When you have any additional instruments and like to have a second battery for them - strictly separated from the main electric system - you can use another battery-system on your own risk. Of course this system never may supply more than 14,4 Volt. My advice: Don't change anything! It might be dangerous." The British Gliding Association picked up this discussion and published this in their newsletter: "Glider Batteries. Several new types of battery (NiMH, Li-Po, Li-ion etc) are now on the market, as suggested alternatives to Lead Acid (gel). There are a number of safety risks associated with batteries and with replacing lead acid batteries with non-lead acid alternatives. More information is available at http://atsipowermanagement.co.uk, http://dg-flugzeugbau.de/forum-dg0.html (click on English language forum and follow link to non-lead acid batteries) and http://www.caa.co.uk/docs/33/CAP562.pdf (note this is a 15Mb document). The BGA advises owners to understand fully the need to use the correct charging system, whether installed in the glider or not, with whatever battery type is used; different technology batteries should not be mixed. In terms of certification, glider parts should be approved by the type certificate holder or by modification and should either be released or a standard part. Glider batteries are normally considered to be standard parts. Owners should ensure that, where batteries are replaced by alternatives, the installation, aircraft charging system (if appropriate), weight, balance and use meets type design approval." So...there may be certification and insurance implictions. Cheers Martyn Dear List, It is time to replace one of the battery packs for my sailplane. I currently use packs consisting of 7 2.5V SLA batteries to make a 14V pack. This has worked very well for me in the past but the AH on these cells is somewhat limited. I would like to ad a transponder and possibly some type of collision avoidance device so I am looking to upgrade the power supply. I have seen Nickel Metal Hydrate batteries that come in 12V and 10 to 14 AH sized the same as the SLA batteries alot of the glider people are using. There is a company in the UK , ATSI, who markets these NIMH batteries for aviation use. My question is does anyone on the list have any experience with these or any other 12V NIMH batteries for glider use. I dont mind using the sealed lead acid batteries but the NIMH has many advantages . And yea, I know price isnt one of them. Thanks |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
NIMH Batteries
On Fri, 05 Dec 2008 09:07:56 -0800, Mike wrote:
I purchased my batteries here; http://www.battlepack.com/NICAD-Battlepacks.asp I notice a lot of Sanyo single cells in their catalog. If those are anything like their NiCds, they'll do me! -- martin@ | Martin Gregorie gregorie. | Essex, UK org | |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
NIMH Batteries
"Free Flight 107" wrote
The reason for not using Li chemestry cells is concern for possible overheating, bursting of cells, and resultant "Very Energetic" fire from the release of the Lithium inside the cells. The Li-ion and LiFe (A123) chemistries are also suseptable to these events, but because of the steel cases, like NiCad & NiMh, will resist abuse better than LiPoly. In actual practice they still use specialized charging and balancing circuits, and usually over- discharging circuits, esp. in consumer devices such as Laptops and Cameras. I have seen reports of burned LiPo and also some LiIo batteries and I would not use them in my glider (apart from the LiPo in every PDA, Cellphone, MP3 Player, ....). But I have never heard of any A123 cells starting a fire, and there are modelers who did some serious abuse testing. BTW, I take issue with; "Both LiFePO4 series (of batteries) are claimed to be able to be charged on most standard lead acid chargers (set for AGM/GEL cells)", unless a complete set of charging and balancing circuity is included in the package. And at the prices quoted, they really should be!! I have balancing tabs on my LiFe packs and use both, a standard lead acid charger and a microprocessor controled charger / balancer combination. Either way the individual cells stay pretty closely balanced. If you want to know how some people (mis-)treat their A123 packs google for "zip charging A123" ... Michael |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
For Sale: 12V 10 AH NiMh Battery Pack | [email protected] | Soaring | 3 | February 20th 08 03:33 PM |
Batteries, charger for Yaesu handheld - NiCad or NiMH? | David Herman | Owning | 10 | November 7th 04 04:30 PM |
C & D NiMH Best Deal | Larry | Home Built | 6 | October 1st 04 01:41 PM |
AA NiMH Best Deal | Jim Weir | Home Built | 27 | September 29th 04 08:39 PM |
AA NiMH Best Deal | Jim Weir | Piloting | 26 | September 29th 04 07:51 PM |