AHRS and competition/badges/records/OLC ?

On Wednesday, March 31, 2021 at 2:26:10 PM UTC-7, Tim Newport-Peace wrote:
On 31/03/2021 19:01, Jeff Bures wrote:
Hi all,

I'm bored. I'm without a sailplane. I'm planning for my retirement, which is still some years away. I hope it will include some OLC, casual competitions, badge, or regional record attempts probably limited to the USA. It could possibly include a homebuilt or refurbished sailplane.

As such, I’ve been goofing around with panel layouts, researching and planning instruments and equipment. I’ve created everything from the ‘Ultimate’ to the ‘Minimalistic’ setup.

One interesting thing has caught my attention and I need to know more. Hopefully this group will help. No flaming please.

The availability of AHRS for sailplanes is growing rapidly. There are several affordable options available from several manufacturers, some targeted specifically at sailplanes. Many are included (or upgrades) to soaring computers. Examples include uAvionix, LX Navigation, LX Nav, and even some phone/tablet solutions (iLevil, FlightBox, WingBug).

An AV-30 could replace three (or more) instruments (airspeed, altitude, and Xpnder/ADS-B head unit). Instead of being excessively more money, it has become an affordable safety/luxury item. Soaring computers are already so very sophisticated, it won’t be long until we’ll have one screen that does everything (like a Dynon or MGL unit in amateur built aircraft).

All this leads me to some questions about competitions, badges, OLC, and records.

1. I see that SSA competition rules, section 6.6.1 prohibits AHRS type instruments. I also see there is a ‘waiver’ system, but you have to be able to disable the artificial horizon type features. What do people do these days at competitions? Do modern glide computers with AHRS include an approved ‘lock out’ feature? Does everyone get a waiver? Do most people just not buy or install the capability? I cannot see this as a tenable solution moving forward as so many AHRS systems are becoming so affordable (and possibly default installations). How is this all managed at competitions (visual inspection, self reporting, or honor system)?

2. What about OLC, badges, or records? I wasn’t able to locate information about ‘prohibited’ equipment. If they are prohibited, is it ‘honor system’ or something else that guarantees compliance?

Flight Recorders that are IGC-approved and have AHRS capability have two
features relating to this, aimed at Competitions.

The .IGC file records the activating of an AHRS.

The AHRS feature can be disabled for a period of days and cannot be
re-activated until the said days have passed.

For un-approved recorders, it is anyone's guess.

So if I have an AHRS without IGC logger, I can't participate in competitions.

What about OLC, badges, and record attempts?

On Thursday, April 1, 2021 at 11:56:25 AM UTC+10, Jeff Bures wrote:
On Wednesday, March 31, 2021 at 2:26:10 PM UTC-7, Tim Newport-Peace wrote:
On 31/03/2021 19:01, Jeff Bures wrote:
Hi all,

I'm bored. I'm without a sailplane. I'm planning for my retirement, which is still some years away. I hope it will include some OLC, casual competitions, badge, or regional record attempts probably limited to the USA. It could possibly include a homebuilt or refurbished sailplane.

As such, I’ve been goofing around with panel layouts, researching and planning instruments and equipment. I’ve created everything from the ‘Ultimate’ to the ‘Minimalistic’ setup.

One interesting thing has caught my attention and I need to know more.. Hopefully this group will help. No flaming please.

The availability of AHRS for sailplanes is growing rapidly. There are several affordable options available from several manufacturers, some targeted specifically at sailplanes. Many are included (or upgrades) to soaring computers. Examples include uAvionix, LX Navigation, LX Nav, and even some phone/tablet solutions (iLevil, FlightBox, WingBug).

An AV-30 could replace three (or more) instruments (airspeed, altitude, and Xpnder/ADS-B head unit). Instead of being excessively more money, it has become an affordable safety/luxury item. Soaring computers are already so very sophisticated, it won’t be long until we’ll have one screen that does everything (like a Dynon or MGL unit in amateur built aircraft).

All this leads me to some questions about competitions, badges, OLC, and records.

1. I see that SSA competition rules, section 6.6.1 prohibits AHRS type instruments. I also see there is a ‘waiver’ system, but you have to be able to disable the artificial horizon type features. What do people do these days at competitions? Do modern glide computers with AHRS include an approved ‘lock out’ feature? Does everyone get a waiver? Do most people just not buy or install the capability? I cannot see this as a tenable solution moving forward as so many AHRS systems are becoming so affordable (and possibly default installations). How is this all managed at competitions (visual inspection, self reporting, or honor system)?

2. What about OLC, badges, or records? I wasn’t able to locate information about ‘prohibited’ equipment. If they are prohibited, is it ‘honor system’ or something else that guarantees compliance?

Flight Recorders that are IGC-approved and have AHRS capability have two
features relating to this, aimed at Competitions.

The .IGC file records the activating of an AHRS.

The AHRS feature can be disabled for a period of days and cannot be
re-activated until the said days have passed.

For un-approved recorders, it is anyone's guess.
So if I have an AHRS without IGC logger, I can't participate in competitions.

What about OLC, badges, and record attempts?

OLC you can trivially forge entire traces, lie about your glider type (set your EB29 to a 2-33?), so cloud flying is the least of your problems.
Badges and records, you need to convince your official observer that your flight was not only within the FAI rules, but also legal. So the onus is on your OO to verify it, as well as your honour.

On 01/04/2021 03:49, Matthew Scutter wrote:
On Thursday, April 1, 2021 at 11:56:25 AM UTC+10, Jeff Bures wrote:
On Wednesday, March 31, 2021 at 2:26:10 PM UTC-7, Tim Newport-Peace wrote:
On 31/03/2021 19:01, Jeff Bures wrote:
Hi all,

I'm bored. I'm without a sailplane. I'm planning for my retirement, which is still some years away. I hope it will include some OLC, casual competitions, badge, or regional record attempts probably limited to the USA. It could possibly include a homebuilt or refurbished sailplane.

As such, I’ve been goofing around with panel layouts, researching and planning instruments and equipment. I’ve created everything from the ‘Ultimate’ to the ‘Minimalistic’ setup.

One interesting thing has caught my attention and I need to know more. Hopefully this group will help. No flaming please.

The availability of AHRS for sailplanes is growing rapidly. There are several affordable options available from several manufacturers, some targeted specifically at sailplanes. Many are included (or upgrades) to soaring computers. Examples include uAvionix, LX Navigation, LX Nav, and even some phone/tablet solutions (iLevil, FlightBox, WingBug).

An AV-30 could replace three (or more) instruments (airspeed, altitude, and Xpnder/ADS-B head unit). Instead of being excessively more money, it has become an affordable safety/luxury item. Soaring computers are already so very sophisticated, it won’t be long until we’ll have one screen that does everything (like a Dynon or MGL unit in amateur built aircraft).

All this leads me to some questions about competitions, badges, OLC, and records.

1. I see that SSA competition rules, section 6.6.1 prohibits AHRS type instruments. I also see there is a ‘waiver’ system, but you have to be able to disable the artificial horizon type features. What do people do these days at competitions? Do modern glide computers with AHRS include an approved ‘lock out’ feature? Does everyone get a waiver? Do most people just not buy or install the capability? I cannot see this as a tenable solution moving forward as so many AHRS systems are becoming so affordable (and possibly default installations). How is this all managed at competitions (visual inspection, self reporting, or honor system)?

2. What about OLC, badges, or records? I wasn’t able to locate information about ‘prohibited’ equipment. If they are prohibited, is it ‘honor system’ or something else that guarantees compliance?

Flight Recorders that are IGC-approved and have AHRS capability have two
features relating to this, aimed at Competitions.

The .IGC file records the activating of an AHRS.

The AHRS feature can be disabled for a period of days and cannot be
re-activated until the said days have passed.

For un-approved recorders, it is anyone's guess.
So if I have an AHRS without IGC logger, I can't participate in competitions.

What about OLC, badges, and record attempts?

OLC you can trivially forge entire traces, lie about your glider type (set your EB29 to a 2-33?), so cloud flying is the least of your problems.
Badges and records, you need to convince your official observer that your flight was not only within the FAI rules, but also legal. So the onus is on your OO to verify it, as well as your honour.

OLC make their own rules.
For IGC badges and records AHRS are not prohibited. Read the Sporting Code.
For National Records and National Competitions, it is a local decision.

On Wed, 31 Mar 2021 18:56:23 -0700, Jeff Bures wrote:

So if I have an AHRS without IGC logger, I can't participate in
competitions.

What about OLC, badges, and record attempts?

Correct, but only because you the logger is required: the scoring program
works by reading the logger trace, so no logger = zero score.

Whether AHRS carriage is permitted or not is a local competition rule.


--
Martin | martin at
Gregorie | gregorie dot org