![]() |
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
Nevertheless, the Germans claim these kills:
Feb '45: I/JG-1, Oberst Herbert Ihlefeld's wingman, Sill, near Kircheim-Treck April 26, 1945: I/JG-1, Unteroffizer Rechenbach May 4, 1945: I/JG-1 Leutnant Rudolf Schmitt, near Rostock, Typhoon aircraft No mention of a I/JG-1 kill for April 19, 1945 which comes from Green's outdated "Warplanes of the Third Reich". I find the first kill in Feb '45 dubious since I/JG-1 wasn't ready for combat until mid-April 1945. The two other kills are usually the ones generally accepted and the last one is verified as Schmitt was captured by the British and treated with respect, an invited guest at the Staff Officers Club. Nevertheless, no RAF single engine aircraft was lost in the area where Rudi claimed one - to put a finer point on it, no German signed the claim as a witness, and no RAF aircraft was lost there. To me, that means Rudi was dreamin'. There was also nothing in JG 1s wartime KTBs that show an He 162 lost to any air combat. I have gone through them - its not there. I don't usually recommend Tony Woods claims lists, but have you ever gone through them, Rob? They represent the current data on German claims, culled directly from the wartime records only - a few mistakes that I know of personally, but without a doubt these lists of Tony's are the best online resource, as they are completely independent of postwar second hand info (unfortch, some such lists are generated entirely out of books, perpetuating myths as well as introducing their own errors as well). http://tonywood.cjb.net/ These are far more complete than anything produced in the past - the opening of various east european archives has brought a large infusion of additional wartime data to the table; at the same time, it has removed support for some long cherished ideas. With a total lack of supporting data for the JG 1 claims (i.e., NO original claim forms, signed by anyone, have come to light - even the pilots that came forward after the war to say they had combat in He 162s somehow failed to keep copies of their claims!) So, we then have to go to the PRO to check the other side of the leger - did the RAF lose anything that corresponds to the "Typhoon" (or any other single in that region)? Nope. A couple of flak hits on kites on the day in question but nothing else. Continuing deeper, we turn to the gold mine of wartime docs - the ULTRA decrypts. Still, the record is silent: apparently, JG 1 never notified anyone in its chain of command that three of their pilots (or two, or even one) had engaged feindflug and scored an abschusse. Postwar books that repeat the JG 1 claims invariably leave out the fact that no Jafu or OKL document supports them. As for the Brits treating Rudi well - they were downright respectful to Welter too, and they knew quite well that he claimed dozens of Mosquitos that were safely parked on their hardstands in east anglia. Gordon Stormbirds.com/recon |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Air Force identifies operational shortfalls | Otis Willie | Military Aviation | 0 | December 17th 03 09:47 PM |
Soviet Submarines Losses - WWII | Mike Yared | Military Aviation | 4 | October 30th 03 03:09 AM |
A-4 / A-7 Question | Tank Fixer | Military Aviation | 135 | October 25th 03 03:59 AM |
Why did Britain win the BoB? | Grantland | Military Aviation | 79 | October 15th 03 03:34 PM |
Joint Russian-French 5th generation fighter? | lihakirves | Military Aviation | 1 | July 5th 03 01:36 AM |